Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T22:02:05.488Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

7 - Christianity and paganism, II: Asia Minor

from Part II - Christianity Contested

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2008

Augustine Casiday
Affiliation:
University of Wales, Lampeter
Frederick W. Norris
Affiliation:
Emmanuel School of Religion
Get access

Summary

Asia Minor was a region of broad religious diversity in the time of the Tetrarchy and afterwards, under the successor regimes established by Licinius, Constantine and his sons (284–361). Significant communities of Jews and Christians populated its cities and their territories amid the great pagan Greek majority. Christians were a tiny minority c. 300, perhaps 5 to 10 per cent in most cities except in some places like Nicomedia and Eumeneia, and in villages throughout Phrygia, where large numbers lived. Its institutional expansion is reflected in the fact that, in 325, the representatives of some 150 episcopal sees in Asia Minor attended the Council of Nicaea. This posed a serious ideological challenge to the pagan temple cults of Asia Minor. Their priesthoods were filled by city councillors who had accrued great wealth from their agricultural estates. The ancestral cults of the agricultural cycle were considered the basis for preserving the ‘peace of the gods’, whose chief manifestation lay in the regularity of the forces of nature; their neglect was thought to cause the meteorological catastrophes that periodically damaged agricultural production. A decree of the emperor Maximinus Daia in 312 sums up this theological argument in some detail.

Education in grammar, rhetoric and the Greek paideia provided an ideological basis for the city councillors’ religious opinions; it was a key factor in their resistance to Christian ideas, particularly where the conflicting theologies gave rival interpretations of particular questions, such as the divine nature, cosmogony and ethics. The importance of the Greek paideia is particularly evident in the writings of Themistius, who taught rhetoric in Ancyra in the mid-fourth century, but also in many Christian inscriptions.

Type
Chapter
Information
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Momigliano, A., ed. The conflict between paganism and Christianity in the fourth century (Oxford, 1963).
Anderson, J. G. C.Exploration in Galatia cis Halym’, Journal of Hellenic studies 19 (1899).Google Scholar
Anderson, J. G. C.Paganism and Christianity in the Upper Tembris valley’, in Ramsey, W. M., ed., Studies in the art and archaeology of the Eastern Roman provinces (Aberdeen, 1906).Google Scholar
Barnes, T. D. Constantine and Eusebius (Cambridge, MA, 1981).
Basil, . Letters. Ed. Courtonne, Yves, Saint Basile. Lettres (Paris, 1957, 1961, 1966).
Bayliss, R. Provincial Cilicia and the archaeology of temple conversion, British Archaeological Reports International Series 1281 (Oxford, 2004).
Brixhe, C.Interactions between Greek and Phrygian under the Roman empire’, in Adams, J. N., Janse, M. and Swain, S., eds., Bilingualism in ancient society. Language contact and written text (Oxford, 2002).Google Scholar
Buckler,, W. H., Calder, W. M. and Cox, C. W. M.. ‘Asia Minor, 1924. v. – Monuments from the Upper Tembris valley’, Journal of Roman studies 18 (1928).Google Scholar
Buckler, W. H., Calder, W. M. and Cox, C. W. M.. ‘Asia Minor, 1924. 1. – Monuments from Iconium, Lycaonia and Isauria’, Journal of Roman studies 14 (1924).Google Scholar
Buresch, K. Klaros. Untersuchungen zum Orakelwesen des späteren Altertums (Leipzig, 1889; reprint: Aal, 1973).
Calder, W. M.A journey through the Proseilemmene’, Klio 10 (1901).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Colonia Caesareia Antiocheia’, Journal of Roman studies 2 (1912).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Corpus inscriptionum neo-Phrygianum. – II’, Journal of Hellenic studies 33 (1913).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Corpus inscriptionum neo-Phrygianum’, Journal of Hellenic studies 31 (1911).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Early Christian epitaphs from Phrygia’, Anatolian studies 5 (1955).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Julia-Ipsus and Augustopolis’, Journal of Roman studies 2 (1912).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Philadelphia and Montanism’, Bulletin of the John Rylands Library 7 (1922–3).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Studies in early Christian epigraphy: II’, Journal of Roman studies 14 (1924).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.Studies in early Christian epigraphy’, Journal of Roman studies 10 (1920).Google Scholar
Calder, W. M.The Eumenian formula’, in Calder, W. M. and Keil, J., eds., Anatolian studies presented to William Hepburn Buckler (Manchester, 1939).Google Scholar
,Callinicus of Rufinianae. De vita S. Hypatii liber (Leipzig, 1895); Sources chrétiennes 177.
Chaniotis, A.Zwischen Konfrontation und Interaktion: Christen, Juden und Heiden im spätantiken Aphrodisias’, in Ackermann, A. and Müller, K. E., eds., Patchwork (Bielefeld, 2002).Google Scholar
Chuvin,, P. Chronique des derniers païens: La disparition du paganisme dans l’empire romaine, du règne de Constantine à celui de Justinien (Paris, 1991).
Codex Justinianus (Codex Justinianus). Ed. Krüger, P., Corpus iuris civilis (Berlin, 1929).
Coleman-Norton, P. R. Roman state & Christian church (London, 1966).
Cormack, R.The temple as cathedral’, in Roueché, C. and Erim, K. T., eds., Aphrodisias papers: Recent work on the architecture and sculpture (Ann Arbor, 1990).Google Scholar
Cox, C. W. M.Bishop Heortasius of Appia’, in Calder, W. M. and Keil, J., eds., Anatolian studies presented to William Hepburn Buckler (Manchester, 1939).Google Scholar
Cumont, F.Les anges du paganisme’, Revue d’histoire des religions 72 (1915).Google Scholar
Hunt, D., ‘Julian’, in Cameron, Averil and Garnsey, P., eds., The Cambridge ancient history (Cambridge, 1998), XIII.Google Scholar
Damascius, . Das Leben des Philosophen Isidors von Damaskios aus Damaskos, trans. Asmus, R. (Leipzig, 1911).
Damascius, . Vitae Isidori reliquiae, ed. Zintzen, C. (Hildesheim, 1967).
De Ste. Croix, G. E. M. The class struggle in the ancient Greek world from the archaic age to the Arab conquest (London, 1981).
Deichmann, F. W.Frühchristliche Kirchen in antiken Heiligtümern’, Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts 54 (1939).Google Scholar
Dodds, E. R.Theurgy’, in The Greeks and the irrational (Berkeley, 1951).Google Scholar
Dodds, E. R. Pagan and Christian in an age of anxiety (Cambridge, 1965).
Drew-Bear, Th. and Naour, Ch.. ‘Divinités de Phrygie’, in Haase, W., ed., Aufstieg und Niedergang der antiken Welt 2.18.3 (Berlin, 1990).Google Scholar
Erdmann, K.Feuerheiligtum-Kreuzkuppelkirche’, in Alföldy, A. et al., eds., Neue Beiträge zur Kunstgeschichte des 1. Jahrtausends, (Baden-Baden, 1952), 1.Google Scholar
Erim, K. T. and Smith, R. R. R.. ‘Sculpture from the theatre: A preliminary report’, in Erim, K. T. and Smith, R. R. R., eds., Aphrodisias papers 2 (Ann Arbor, 1991).Google Scholar
Erim, K. T.Portrait sculpture at Aphrodisias’, in Roueché, C. and Erim, K. T., eds., Aphrodisias papers: Recent work on the architecture and sculpture (Ann Arbor, 1990).Google Scholar
Cabrol, F., and Leclercq, H., eds. Dictionnaire d’archéologie chrétienne et de liturgie (Paris, 1903–50).
Feld, O., and Weber, H.. ‘Tempel und Kirche über der korykischen Grotte (Cennet Cehennem) in Kilikien’, Istanbuler Mitteilungen 17 (1967).Google Scholar
Fleischer, R.Der Fries des Hadrianstempels in Ephesos’, in Festschrift für Fritz Eichler zum achtzigsten Geburtstag (Vienna, 1967).Google Scholar
Frend, W. H. C. The archaeology of early Christianity. A history (London, 1996).
Geffcken, J. The last days of Greco-Roman paganism, trans. MacCormack, S. (Amsterdam, 1978).
,George the Monk. Vie de Théodore de Sykéôn, ed. Festugière, A. -J., Subsidia Hagiographica 48 (Brussels, 1970).
Gough, M.A temple and church at Ayas (Cilicia)’, Anatolian studies 4 (1954).Google Scholar
Gough, M.The Church of the Evangelists at Alahan’, Anatolian studies 12 (1962).Google Scholar
Musurillo, H., ed. Acts of the Christian martyrs (Oxford, 1972).
Nikolaos., Hagios Der heilige Nikolaos in der griechischen Kirche, ed. Anrich, G. (Leipzig, 1913–17).
Hahn, J. Gewalt und religiöser Konflikt (Berlin, 2004).
Halkin, F. Actuarium Bibliothecae Hagiographicae Graecae, Subsidia Hagiographica 47 (Brussels, 1969).
Halkin, F. Bibliotheca Hagiographica Graeca 1–2, Subsidia Hagiographica 8a (Brussels, 1957).
Hanson, R. P. C.The transformation of pagan temples into churches in the early Christian centuries’, Journal of Semitic studies 23 (1978).Google Scholar
Harl, K. W.From pagan to Christian in cities of Roman Anatolia during the fourth and fifth centuries’, in Burns, T. S. and Eadie, J. W., eds., Urban centers and rural contexts in late antiquity (East Lansing, 2001).Google Scholar
Harper, R. P.Tituli Comanorum Cappadociae’, Anatolian studies 18 (1968).Google Scholar
Hasluck, F. W. Christianity and Islam under the sultans (Oxford, 1929).
Hefele, C. J. Histoire des conciles d’après les documents originaux, trans. Leclercq, H. (Paris, 1907–49).
Hellenkemper, H.Die Kirche im Tempel: Zeustempel und Paulus basilica am Kalykadnos’, in Orbis Romanus Christianusque ab Diocletiani aetate usque ad Heraclium: Travaux sur l’antiquité tardive rassemblés autour des recherches de Noël Duval (Paris, 1995).Google Scholar
Honoré, Tony, Tribonian (London, 1978).
Bidez, J., and Cumont, F., eds. Imperatoris Caesaris Flavii Claudii Iuliani epistulae, leges, poemata, fragmenta varia (Paris, 1922).
Jaeger, W. Early Christianity and Greek paideia (Cambridge, MA, 1961).
Joannou, P. P. ed. Discipline générale antique (IVe–IXe s.) (Rome, 1962–3).
Joannou, P.-P. La législation impériale et la christianisation de l’empire romaine (311–476), Orientalia Christiana Analecta 192 (Rome, 1972).
Jones, A. H. M. The later Roman empire 284–602: A social, economic and administrative survey (Oxford, 1964).
Jones, C. P.A family of Pisidian Antioch’, Phoenix 36 (1982).Google Scholar
Julian., The works of the emperor Julian, trans. Wright, W. C., Loeb Classical Library (London, 1913).
Kirsten, E.Artemis von Ephesus und Eleuthera von Myra mit Seitblick auf St. Nicolaus und auf Commagene’, in Sahin, S. et al., eds., Studien zur Religion und Kultur Kleinasiens: Festschrift für Karl Dörner (Leiden, 1978), 11.Google Scholar
Kitzinger, E.The cult of images in the age before iconoclasm’, Dumbarton Oaks Papers 8 (1954).Google Scholar
Lane Fox, R. Pagans and Christians (London, 1986).
Lawson, J. C. Modern Greek folklore and ancient Greek religion (Cambridge, 1910).
Lee, A. D. Pagans and Christians in late antiquity. A sourcebook (London, 2000).
Lemerle, P.L’histoire des Pauliciens d’Asia mineur d’après les sources grecques’, Travaux et mémoires 5 (1973).Google Scholar
Mango, C.Germia: A postscript’, Jahrbuch der österreichischen Byzantinistik 41 (1991).Google Scholar
Mango, C.St. Michael and Attis’, Deltion tês Christianikês Etaireias 12 (1984).Google Scholar
Mitchell, S.Maximinus and the Christians in A. D. 312: A new Latin inscription’, Journal of Roman studies 78 (1988).Google Scholar
Mitchell, S.The life of Saint Theodotus of Ancyra’, Anatolian studies 32 (1982).Google Scholar
Monumenta Asiae Minoris antiqua, eds. Calder, W. M. et al. (Manchester, 1928–56).
Mullen, R. L. The expansion of Christianity. A gazetteer of its first three centuries (Leiden, 2004).
Joannou, P.-P., ed. Discipline générale antique (IVe–IXes.) (Rome, 1962–3).
Papyri Graecae magicae: Die griechischen Zauberpapyri, eds. Preisendanz, K. et al. (Stuttgart, 1973–4).
Photius., The Letters of Photius, ed. Baletta, J. N. (London, 1864).
Procopius., De bellis. Ed. Haury, J. and Wirth, G., Procopius. Opera omnia (Leipzig, 1962–4).
Ramsay, W. M.The Tekmorian guest-friends: Ananti-Christian society on the imperial estates at Pisidian Antioch’, in Studies in the history and art of the Eastern Roman provinces (Aberdeen, 1906).Google Scholar
Ramsay, W. M. Cities and bishoprics of Phrygia (Oxford, 1895).
Recueil des inscriptions grecques-chrétiennes d’Asie Mineure, ed. Grégoire, H. (Paris, 1922; reprint: Chicago, 1980).
Robert, L.Didymes à l’époque byzantine’, Hellenica 11–12 (1960).Google Scholar
Robert, L.Villes et monnaies de Lycie’, Hellenica 10 (1955).Google Scholar
Rochow, I.Die Heidenprozesse unter Kaisern Tiberios II. Konstantinos und Maurikios’, in Winkelmann, F. et al., eds., Studien zum 7. Jahrhundert in Byzanz (Berlin, 1976).Google Scholar
Rochow, I.Zu einigen oppositionellen religiösen Strömungen 1: Zur Rolle der Anhänger antiker Kulte und Bräuche’, in Winkelmann, F., ed., Byzanz im 7. Jahrhundert (Berlin, 1978).Google Scholar
Roueché, C. Aphrodisias in late antiquity (London, 1989); available on-line: http://insaph. kcl.ac.uk/ala2004/refer/concord.html.
Saradi-Mendelovici, H.Christian attitudes to pagan monuments in late antiquity and their legacy in later Byzantine centuries’, Dumbarton Oaks Papers 44 (1990).Google Scholar
Sardis VII. Greek and Latin inscriptions. Part 1, eds. Buckler, W. H. and Robinson, D. M. (Leiden, 1932).
Schneider, C. M.Leibestätigkeit als Strafe: Bemerkungen zu einer Inschrift an Sardis’, in Wirth, P., ed., Polychordia: Festschrift Franz Dölgerzum 75 Geburtstag (Amsterdam, 1966), 1.Google Scholar
Sheppard, A. R. R.Pagan cult of angels in Roman Asia Minor’, Talanta 12–13 (1980–1).Google Scholar
Smith, R. R. R.Archaeological research at Aphrodisias 1989–1992’, in Roueché, C. and Smith, R. R. R., eds., Aphrodisias papers 3 (Ann Arbor, 1996).Google Scholar
Smith, R. R. R.Late Roman philosophers’, in Erim, K. T. and Smith, R. R. R., eds., Aphrodisias papers 2 (Ann Arbor, 1991).Google Scholar
Snyder, G. Ante pacem. Archaeological evidence of church life before Constantine (Macon, 1985).
Strabo., The Geography of Strabo, trans. Jones, H. L., 3 vols., Loeb Classical Library (London, 1917–32).
Drew-Bear, T., ed. Nouvelles inscriptions de Phrygie (Zutphen, 1978).
Tabbernee, W. Montanist inscriptions and testimonia. Epigraphic sources illustrating the history of Montanism (Macon, 1997).
The life of St. Nicholas of Sion, eds. Ševčenko, I. and Ševčenko, N. (Brookline, MA, 1984).
Trombley, F. R.Christianisation of rite in Byzantine Anatolia: F. W. Hasluck and continuity’, in Shankland, D., ed., Anthropology, archaeology and heritage in the Balkans and Anatolia: The life and times of F. W. Hasluck 1878–1920 (Istanbul, 2004), 11.Google Scholar
Trombley, F. R.Monastic foundations in sixth-century Anatolia and the role in the social and economic life of the countryside’, Greek Orthodox theological review 30 (1985); reprinted with corrections in Vaporis, N. M., ed., Byzantine saints and monasteries (Brookline, MA, 1985).Google Scholar
Trombley, F. R.Paganism in the Greek world at the end of antiquity: The case of rural Anatolia and Greece’, Harvard theological review 78 (1985).Google Scholar
Trombley, F. R.Religious experience in late antiquity: Theological ambivalence and Christianization’, Byzantine and modern Greek studies 24 (2000).Google Scholar
Trombley, F. R.Religious transition in sixth-century Syria’, Byzantinische Forschungen 20 (1994).Google Scholar
Trombley, F. R. Hellenic religion and Christianization c. 370–529 (Leiden, 1993–4; reprint: 1995, 2001).
von Harnack, A.. Die Mission und Ausbreitung des Christentums in den ersten drei Jahrhunderten (Leipzig, 1924).
Whitby, M.John of Ephesus and the pagans: Pagan survivals in the sixth century’, in Salomon, M., ed., Paganism in the later Roman empire and in Byzantium (Cracow, 1991).Google Scholar
Wischmeyer, W.M. Iulius Eugenius. Eine Fallstudie zum Thema “Christen und Gesellschaft im 3. und 4. Jahrhunderte”’, Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft 81 (1990).Google Scholar

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure [email protected] is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×