The relationship between the modulation of electron beams at optical frequencies (the Schwarz-Hora effect) and at microwave frequencies is discussed. At optical frequencies the interaction between the modulating field and the electron beam must be described quantum mechanically, although the field itself may be described classically; in the microwave case the process may be described entirely classically. The interaction modifies the state functions of the individual electrons, but the observable modulation of the total electron beam results from the coherence of the modulating field. The main features of the Schwarz-Hora effect result from ‘single photon’ processes, but the beam modulation in the klystron is a ‘multi-photon’ process.
The exponential decay of the depth of modulation with distance from the interaction region, observable in the optical frequency case but not in the klystron, is not an inherently quantal effect. The periodic variation of the depth of modulation with distance along the beam, observed in the optical frequency case, is an essentially quantum mechanical effect, and is different, in its origins and in its dependence on the modulation frequency, from the space-charge waves which are observed on a klystron beam.