This article demonstrates how cultural ideologies of language, and the
semiotic processes that mobilize them, manifest in contemporary American
drug treatment. Drawing from an ethnographic study of an outpatient
program in the Midwestern United States, it focuses on therapists'
claims about what constitutes “healthy language.” It is argued
that these claims both stem from and actively reproduce an “ideology
of inner reference,” which presumes that “healthy”
language refers to preexisting phenomena, and that the phenomena to which
it refers are internal to speakers. By formally discouraging talk that
could point outside the parameters of the individual psyche, the treatment
program effectively insulates itself from clients' critiques and
challenges. A broad attempt is made to elucidate the connection between a
language ideology that enjoys wide cultural circulation as well as
significant currency in contemporary clinical practice, and a particular
political effect called “institutional insulation.”My thanks to Barbara Johnstone and two anonymous
reviewers for their insightful, critical comments on an earlier version of
this article. I am especially grateful to James Wilce for his keen advice
on how to refine central elements of the argument and his guidance toward
relevant, fruitful literature. The following people contributed
significantly to the essay's development (though its remaining flaws
are very much my own): Giorgio Bertellini, Webb Keane, Daniel Listoe, Beth
Reed, Douglas Rogers, Michael Sosin, and Sarah Womack. I'd also like
to thank the University of Chicago Anthropology Department, Center for
Gender Studies, Committee on Human Development, and School of Social
Service Administration for opportunities to present (and rethink) earlier
versions. The research reported here was conducted with the support of a
training fellowship from the National Institute of Mental Health and
various grants from the Department of Anthropology, the Institute for
Research on Women and Gender, the Program in Women's Studies, Rackham
Graduate School, and the School of Social Work, all at the University of
Michigan. This essay is for “Lila.”