This paper describes the development and testing of a European version of
the Appropriateness Evaulation Protocol (AEP). It stemmed from the original
U.S. version and the multiple adaptations and modifications made previously
and separately by researchers in European countries. The group was
particularly concerned with developing a common list of reasons for
inappropriate admissions and days of stay, since the principal goal was to
enable an understanding of inappropriate hospital use and potential solutions
within local health and social care systems. Developing a common EU-AEP
included several steps. First, each national instrument was translated from
the national language to English. These back translations were compared with
each other and with the US-AEP. A working group analyzed the content of the
lists of reasons published in the literature and proposed a novel conceptual
approach. On the basis of workshop discussions, a draft of a common European
version was circulated to each participant for agreement. In the EU-AEP, the
clinical criteria for the appropriateness of admission include 10 related to
patient condition and five to clinical services. The criteria for the
appropriateness of days of care include 10 covering medical services, six for
life support/nursing services, and eight related to patient condition. The
proposed core list of reasons of inappropriateness distinguish clearly between
two concepts: a) the level of care required by the patient; and b) the reason
why this level of care was not used. The first list would thus refer to the
nature of resources and facilities required, while the second would focus more
on the efficient organization of those resources. A validated European tool to
assess inappropriate hospital admissions and hospital days of stay and their
causes might be used to assess the need for resources for inpatient care as
well as for outpatient care. Assessing the reasons for inadequacies might lead
also to the examination of organizational questions. Finally, a common tool
allows comparisons between countries concerning the frequency of inappropriate
admissions and days of stay and their reasons in relation to the different
organizations of health care across Europe.