Article contents
The Retransition as Sign: Listener-Orientated Approaches to Tonal Closure in Haydn's Sonata-Form Movements
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 January 2020
Extract
Music psychologists interested in the perception of tonal closure might do worse than investigate the Classical retransition as a sign of impending resolution. Haydn tends to attract more than his fair share of ‘listener-orientated’ approaches, perhaps on account of his attested sensitivity to his audience's cognitive ‘processing limits’. His well-known remark to Griesinger that, isolated at Eszterháza, he ‘could make experiments, observe what elicited or weakened an impression, and thus correct, add, delete, take risks’ conveys the impression of an artist clearly in touch with his public. And yet this most playful of composers exploited this rapport to mislead his listeners, making aesthetic capital out of systematic disinformation.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Royal Musical Association, 1996
References
1 See Bonds, Mark Evan, Wordless Rhetoric Musical Form and the Metaphor of the Oration (Cambridge, Mass, 1991).Google Scholar
2 Edited and translated in Vernon Gotwals, Joseph Haydn. Eighteenth-Century Gentleman and Genius (Madison, 1963), 17Google Scholar
3 See Rosen, Charles, The Classical Style (New York, 1972), 337 ‘A great deal of ingenuity is expended upon the return of the theme, almost always with rollicking effect the trick is to keep suggesting the return but to delay it until the listener no longer knows when to expect it.‘Google Scholar
4 See Clarke, Eric, ‘Mind the Gap Formal Structures and Psychological Processes in Music’, Contemporary Music Review, 3 (1989), 1–13 For a broad survey, see Cook, Nicholas, ‘Perception A Perspective from Music Theory’, Musical Perceptions, ed Rita Aiello (Oxford, 1994), 64–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar
5 Cook, Nicholas, ‘The Perception of Large-Scale Tonal Closure’, Music Perception, 5 (1987), 197–205CrossRefGoogle Scholar
6 B S Rosner and Leonard B Meyer, ‘The Perceptual Roles of Melodic Process, Contour and Form’, Music Perception, 4 (1986), 1–39 In Meyer's theory of gap-fill motion, disjunct intervals in a melody may be resolved by countervailing conjunct progressionsGoogle Scholar
7 Sloboda, John, ‘Psychological Structures in Music Core Research 1980–1990’, Companion to Contemporary Musical Thought, ed John Paynter et al (London, 1992), 803–39 ‘Implicit in the work of Cook and Rosner and Meyer is the notion that there are processing limits on human cognitive capacity that limit what can be extracted from music, at least on early hearings Their findings do not show that people cannot hear out large-scale structure They simply show that they do not usually do so in early listening given the experimental tasks required of them […] With longer exposure and/or different tasks, it is still quite possible that we may find evidence of large-scale psychological representations' (p 833)Google Scholar
8 Meyer, Leonard B, Style and Music Theory, History and Ideology (Philadelphia. 1989) ‘In the tonic version of the changing-note schema, the melody revolves around the first degree of the scales, usually moving 1–7/2–1, but sometimes using the opposite order (1–2/7–1)’ (p 227) Meyer thinks that the former version makes a good opening theme, because it ‘rises sequentially, implying continuation to the third of the scale or beyond’ The latter version is more suitable for cadential gestures, since ‘the closure that the leading-tone-to-tonic motion (7–1) creates is too strong for the generation of more extensive melodic structures’.Google Scholar
9 V. Kofi Agawu, Playing with Signs A Semiotic Interpretation of Classic Music (Princeton, 1991), 51–72.Google Scholar
10 See Trehub, Sandra E. and Trainor, Laurel J, ‘Listening Strategies in Infancy The Roots of Music and Language Development’, Thinking in Sound The Cognitive Psychology of Human Audition, ed Stephen McAdams and Emmanuel Bigand (Oxford, 1993), 278–327Google Scholar
11 See Jerry Fodor and Ernest Lepore, Holism A Shopper's Guide (Oxford, 1993), 209Google Scholar
12 Ibid.Google Scholar
13 Ibid., 27.Google Scholar
14 Fodor, Jerry, The Modularity of Mind (Cambridge, Mass., 1983) See also his The Language of Thought (New York, 1975)Google Scholar
15 The distinguishing features of modules are informational encapsulation, domain specificity, mandatory operation and innateness. This means that modules function independently of one another, are charged with specific tasks (‘language’ modules are independent of ‘thought’ modules), and are not subject to voluntary control or change they are inborn.Google Scholar
16 Fred Lerdahl and Ray Jackendoff, A Generative Theory of Tonal Music (Cambridge, Mass., 1983).Google Scholar
17 Ibid., 222Google Scholar
18 Sisman, Elaine, ‘Small and Expanded Forms Koch's Model and Haydn's Music’, Musical Quarterly, 68 (1982), 444–75 Sisman shows how Koch and Haydn employ similar expansion techniques to arrive at larger sonata-form structures from a small period. See also Rosen, The Classical Style, 83–8 ‘The second variation of this second theme is a complete sonata movement, and it is amusing to see how Haydn expands a 20-measure theme into a larger work’ (p. 83).Google Scholar
19 Dahlhaus, Carl, ‘Harmony’, The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians (London, 1980), viii, 175–88 (p 181)Google Scholar
20 See Dowling, W Jay, ‘Context Effects on Melody Recognition: Scale-Step versus Interval Representations’, Music Perception, 3 (1986), 281–96.Google Scholar
21 Davidson, Lyle, ‘Songsinging by Young and Old A Developmental Approach to Music’, Musical Perceptions, ed Aiello, 99–130 (p 109).Google Scholar
22 See Narmour, Eugene, Beyond Schenkerism (Chicago, 1977), 41–7Google Scholar
23 See Leonard B Meyer, Explaining Music (Chicago, 1973), 85 ‘A semicadence might be defined as one in which a mobile, goal-directed, harmonic process is temporarily stabilised by decisive rhythmic closure In other words, a semicadence is a case of parametric noncongruence which has become archetypal in the stylistic syntax of tonal music‘Google Scholar
24 Schachter, Carl, ‘Rhythm and Linear Analysis A Preliminary Study’, Music Forum, 5 (New York, 1976), 281–334 ‘There would be little drama in this phrase were it not for the conflict between durational and tonal groupings’ (p 332).Google Scholar
25 Mandler, Jean, ‘Categorical and Schematic Organization in Memory’, Memory Organization and Structure, ed. Richard Puff (New York, 1979), 259–99 (p. 263)Google Scholar
26 Gjerdingen, Robert, A Classic Turn of Phrase (Philadelphia, 1988)Google Scholar
27 Eco, Umberto, A Theory of Semiotics (Bloomington, 1979), 69Google Scholar
28 Style and Music, 140Google Scholar
29 Browne, Richmond, ‘Tonal Implications of the Diatonic Set’, In Theory Only, 5 (1981), 3–21Google Scholar
30 Lerdahl, and Jackendoff, , A Generative Theory, 245Google Scholar
31 William S Newman, ‘The Climax of Music’, Music Review, 13 (1952), 283–93Google Scholar
32 David Butler and Helen Brown, ‘Describing the Mental Representation of Tonality in Music’, Musical Perceptions, ed. Aiello, 191–212.Google Scholar
33 Baker, James, ‘Chromaticism in Classical Music’, Music Theory and the Exploration of the Past, ed. Christopher Hatch and David W Bernstein (Chicago, 1993), 233–307.Google Scholar
34 Ibid., 263Google Scholar
35 Ibid., 277.Google Scholar
36 Lerdahl, and Jackendoff, , A Generative Theory, 183Google Scholar
37 Ibid., 179Google Scholar
38 Kermode, Frank, The Sense of an Ending (New York, 1967), 18–19 ‘Peripeteia […] is present in every story of the least structural sophistication [It] depends on our confidence of the end, it is a disconfirmation followed by a consonance; the interest of having our expectations falsified is obviously related to our wish to reach the discovery or recognition by an unexpected and instructive route.‘Google Scholar
39 See Bonds, Mark Evan, ‘Haydn's False Recapitulations and the Perception of Sonata Form in the Eighteenth Century’ (Ph.D dissertation, Harvard University, 1988). See also Oliver Strunk, ‘Haydn's Divertimenti for Baryton’, Essays on Music in the Western World (New York, 1932), 126–70Google Scholar
40 Hatten, Robert S, Musical Meaning in Beethoven Markedness, Correlation, and Interpretation (Bloomington and Indianapolis, 1994)Google Scholar
41 Ibid., 34Google Scholar
42 Ibid., 36Google Scholar
43 Ibid., 79Google Scholar
44 See also the definition of Beethoven's heroic schema in Anthony Newcomb, ‘Once More “Between Absolute and Program Music” Schumann's Second Symphony’, 19th Century Music, 7 (1984), 233–50Google Scholar
45 Hatten, Musical Meaning in Beethoven, 92Google Scholar
46 Ibid., 96Google Scholar
47 Momigny's text is translated in Musical Analysis in the Nineteenth Century, ii, Hermeneutic Approaches, ed Ian Bent (Cambridge, 1994), 127–40 see also Cole, Malcolm, ‘Momigny's Analysis of Haydn's Symphony no 103’, Music Review. 30 (1969), 261–84Google Scholar
48 Music Analysis in the Nineteenth Century, ii, ed Bent, 129Google Scholar
49 Ibid., 140Google Scholar
50 Hatten, Musical Meaning in Beethoven, 119Google Scholar
51 Ibid., 120Google Scholar
52 Baker, ‘Chromaticism in Classical Music’, 266Google Scholar
53 Meyer, Explaining Music, 130Google Scholar
54 See Levy, Janet, ‘Texture as a Sign in Classic and Early Romantic Music’, Journal of the American Musicological Society, 35 (1982), 482–531 (p. 483)Google Scholar
55 Ibid., 519, 497.Google Scholar
56 Levy, Texture as a Sign', 498, 507Google Scholar
57 Ibid., 520Google Scholar
58 Ibid., 498.Google Scholar
59 Ibid., 526, 507Google Scholar
60 Ibid., 520Google Scholar
61 Donald Francis Tovey. ‘Beethoven Symphony in E flat Major’, Symphonies and Other Orchestral Works (Oxford, 1989), 44–52 (p. 46).Google Scholar
62 Levy, ‘Texture asa Sign’, 519Google Scholar
63 Shamgar, Beth, ‘On Locating the Retransition in Classic Sonata Form’, Music Review, 42 (1981), 130–43Google Scholar
64 Heinrich C. Koch, Versuch einer Anleitung zur Composition (Leipzig, 1797), 224Google Scholar
65 Five swings of a cycle of fifths (F♯–B; E–A, D–G, C–F♯, B–E) climax at bar 203 on the dominant of II. The passage at bars 206–15 may appear to be a false reprise, but it is really a disguised retransition, complementing the previous cycle of fifths with five swings in the opposite direction G–C, B–E; D–G; F♯–B; A–DGoogle Scholar
66 Versuch enter Anleitung, 224Google Scholar
67 ‘Moving ahead to nineteenth-century treatises, we discover a significant change in the harmonic role of the retransition For the first time, theorists associate the retransition with the dominant pedal This linkage coincides with two basic changes in the nature of the opening border theorists no longer identify the end of the development with a cadence, and […] they now locate the start of the retransition at the onset of the dominant pedal’ (Shamgar, ‘On Locating the Retransition’, 133)Google Scholar
68 For another example of a double retransition, see Haydn's Piano Sonata in A♭, Hob. XVI:43, bars 77–100 A half close in F minor (bar 87) rhymes with a cadenza on V of A♭ (bars 93ff.) The two dominants, C and E♭, are prepared with an identical bass line E–F–A–B♭–B–C (bars 77–83) and G–A♭–C–D♭–D–E♭ (bars 90–3). The F/E♭, melodic crux at the halfway stage, bar 87, is reinterpreted as F–E♭ immediately before the reprise, bar 99 At 11 and 13 bars respectively, the two retransitions are broadly parallelGoogle Scholar
69 Schenker, Heinrich, Five Graphic Music Analyses (New York, 1969), 40–3.Google Scholar
70 Goodman, Nelson, Languages of Art (Indianapolis, 1968), 71 ‘A label along with others constituting a schema is in effect detached from the home realm of that schema and applied for the sorting and organizing of an alien realm’ (p. 72)Google Scholar
71 Playing with Signs, 90Google Scholar
72 Gasparini, Francesco, The Practical Harmonist at the Harpsichord, trans. Frank S. Stillings, ed. David L Burrows (New Haven, 1963), 39.Google Scholar
73 Hunter, Mary, ‘Text, Music, and Drama in Haydn's Italian Opera Arias’, Journal of Musicology, 7 (1989), 29–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
74 Webster, James, Haydn's ‘Farewell’ Symphony and the Idea of Classical Style (Cambridge, 1991), 142.Google Scholar
75 See Rosen, , The Classical Style, 382–3. ‘By op. 31 no. 1 [Beethoven] ventures to dispense with the dominant as a secondary tonality altogether: from G major he goes to the mediant B.’ The ‘Waldstein’ also modulates to the mediant (from C to E)Google Scholar
76 Mark Evan Bonds, ‘Haydn, Laurence Sterne, and the Origins of Musical Irony’, Journal of the American Musicological Society, 44 (1991), 57–91 (p 58).Google Scholar
77 For a disruption-orientated analysis of this symphony, see Bonds, Wordless Rhetoric, 192–204. Webster (Haydn's ‘Farewell’ Symphony, 267–87) offers another interpretation, based on ‘the meaning of musical reminiscence’.Google Scholar
78 Bonds, ‘Haydn, Laurence Sterne, and the Origins of Musical Irony’, 63Google Scholar
79 Abrams, Meyer Howard, The Mirror and the Lamp Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition (New York, 1953), introductionGoogle Scholar
80 Similarly, Beethoven recalls Haydn's II–I retransition (Symphony no 43 in E♭) in two other E♭ works. His Piano Sonata op. 31 no 3 and String Quartet op 127 both approach their recapitulations from F minor.Google Scholar
81 Beach, David, ‘A Recurring Pattern in Mozart's Music’, Journal of Music Theory, 27 (1983), 1–30Google Scholar
82 Ibid., 1.Google Scholar
83 Haydn's ‘Farewell’ Symphony, 138.Google Scholar
84 Ibid., 144.Google Scholar
85 See Clarke, Eric, ‘Improvisation, Cognition and Education’, Companion to Contemporary Musical Thought, ed. Paynter et al., 787–802Google Scholar
86 See Marsden, Alan and Pople, Anthony, ‘Modelling Musical Cognition as a Community of Experts’, Contemporary Music Review, 3 (1989), 29–42Google Scholar
87 Ricoeur, Paul, ‘The Metaphorical Process as Cognition, Imagination, and Feeling’, Philosophical Perspectives on Metaphor, ed Mark Johnson (Minneapolis, 1985), 228–47 (p 241)Google Scholar
88 Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, trans Elizabeth Anscombe (Oxford, 1984), 193–208 ‘“Now he's seeing it like this”, “now like that” would only be said of someone capable of making certain applications of the figure quite freely The substratum of this experience is the mastery of a technique’ (p 208)Google Scholar
89 Marcus B. Hester, ‘Metaphor and Aspect Seeing’, Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 25 (1966), 205–12 (p 207)Google Scholar
90 Agawu, Playing with Signs, 30.Google Scholar
91 Gal, Susan, ‘The Political Economy of Code Choice’, Codeswitching, ed. Monica Heller (Berlin, 1988), 245–64 (p. 247)Google Scholar
92 Wardhaugh, Ronald, An Introduction to Sociolinguistics (Oxford, 1994), 258–81 (p 260)Google Scholar
- 9
- Cited by