Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- Following the Traces: Reassessing the Status Quo, Reinscribing Trans and Genderqueer Realities
- Peripheral Vision(s): Objects, Images, and Identities
- Genre, Gender, and Trans Textualities
- Epilogue: Beyond Binaries: A Reflection on the (Trans) Gender(s) of Saints
- Appendix: Trans and Genderqueer Studies Terminology, Language, and Usage Guide
- Index
10 - The Authentic Lives of Transgender Saints: Imago Dei and imitatio Christi in the Life of St Marinos the Monk
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 May 2021
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- Following the Traces: Reassessing the Status Quo, Reinscribing Trans and Genderqueer Realities
- Peripheral Vision(s): Objects, Images, and Identities
- Genre, Gender, and Trans Textualities
- Epilogue: Beyond Binaries: A Reflection on the (Trans) Gender(s) of Saints
- Appendix: Trans and Genderqueer Studies Terminology, Language, and Usage Guide
- Index
Summary
Abstract
In this chapter, the author unpacks an entry in Magnus Hirschfeld's Transvestites (1910) on the Life of St Marinos the Monk to argue that his theories of the soul may be useful to flip the understanding of medieval trans saints from a frame of cisgender artifice, fears and desires to the frame of authenticity. In the process, the tradition of describing the subjects of these hagiographies as ‘transvestite’ saints is thoroughly critiqued by critically historicizing and reclaiming the term. Imago transvesti and imitatio transvesti are proposed as theoretical lenses that combine the medieval discourses of imago Dei and imitatio Christi with insights from trans studies in order to improve our understanding of medieval transgender saints.
Keywords: transgender, saints, transvestites, hagiography, medieval, Monks
From the beginning, trans studies has invoked the lives of medieval saints. In a foundational ‘trans’ text, Transvestites (Die Transvestiten) (1910), Magnus Hirschfeld drew from medieval hagiography to historicize the phenomenon he calls ‘transvestitism’. In current usage, ‘transvestite’ is synonymous with ‘cross-dresser’ – someone who wears clothing associated with another gender – and has largely diminished in usage as it is considered out of date or derogatory. Yet in 1910, the word ‘transvestite’ was new, and had not yet developed its more narrow or negative connotations. Indeed, the word was intended to combat confusing associations with other traits or populations. In his book-length study, Hirschfeld describes a distinct population of people that differ from the homosexuals, narcissists, and schizophrenics with whom they were too often lumped: transvestites. While focusing on clothing as a key marker of trans-ness in defining his term ‘transvestite’, Hirschfeld seems to use the term more broadly to refer to a wider group of people, akin to how ‘trans’ or ‘transgender’ is used today. Based on his articulation of trans theory to examine pre-modern saints, Hirschfeld may be considered not only one of the founders of transgender studies in general, but also of medieval transgender studies specifically.
Among the lives he examines from the ancient to the modern world to define his term for trans-ness, Hirschfeld considers the case of St Marinos the Monk:
There was a widespread legend during the Middle Ages about Saint Marina.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Trans and Genderqueer Subjects in Medieval Hagiography , pp. 245 - 266Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2021