Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Acknowledgements
- Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction: A Case Study of Symbolic Cognition
- 2 Conjugal and Nuptial Symbolism in Medieval Christian Thought
- 3 Marriage Symbolism and Social Reality in the New Testament: Husbands and Wives, Christ and the Church
- 4 Single Marriage and Priestly Identity: A Symbol and its Functions in Ancient Christianity
- 5 ‘Put on the Dress of a Wife, so that you Might Preserve your Virginity’: Virgins as Brides of Christ in the Writings of Tertullian
- 6 Veiled Threats: Constraining Religious Women in the Carolingian Empire
- 7 Double Standards?: Medieval Marriage Symbolism and Christian Views on the Muslim Paradise
- 8 Marriage, Maternity, and the Formation of a Sacramental Imagination: Stories for Cistercian Monks and Nuns around the Year 1200
- 9 Marriage Symbolism in Illuminated Manuscripts of the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries: Visualization and Interpretation
- 10 ‘His Left Arm is under my Head and his Right Arm shall Embrace me’: The Bride and the Bridegroom in Trastevere
- 11 Marriage in the Divine Office: Nuptial Metaphors in the Medieval Conception of the Officium
- 12 What Kind of Marriage did Pope Innocent III Really Enter into?: Marriage Symbolism and Papal Authority
- 13 ‘Please don't Mind if i got this Wrong’: Christ's Spiritual Marriage and the Law of the Late Medieval Western Church
- Index of Biblical Passages
- Index of Names
13 - ‘Please don't Mind if i got this Wrong’: Christ's Spiritual Marriage and the Law of the Late Medieval Western Church
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 November 2020
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Illustrations
- Acknowledgements
- Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction: A Case Study of Symbolic Cognition
- 2 Conjugal and Nuptial Symbolism in Medieval Christian Thought
- 3 Marriage Symbolism and Social Reality in the New Testament: Husbands and Wives, Christ and the Church
- 4 Single Marriage and Priestly Identity: A Symbol and its Functions in Ancient Christianity
- 5 ‘Put on the Dress of a Wife, so that you Might Preserve your Virginity’: Virgins as Brides of Christ in the Writings of Tertullian
- 6 Veiled Threats: Constraining Religious Women in the Carolingian Empire
- 7 Double Standards?: Medieval Marriage Symbolism and Christian Views on the Muslim Paradise
- 8 Marriage, Maternity, and the Formation of a Sacramental Imagination: Stories for Cistercian Monks and Nuns around the Year 1200
- 9 Marriage Symbolism in Illuminated Manuscripts of the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries: Visualization and Interpretation
- 10 ‘His Left Arm is under my Head and his Right Arm shall Embrace me’: The Bride and the Bridegroom in Trastevere
- 11 Marriage in the Divine Office: Nuptial Metaphors in the Medieval Conception of the Officium
- 12 What Kind of Marriage did Pope Innocent III Really Enter into?: Marriage Symbolism and Papal Authority
- 13 ‘Please don't Mind if i got this Wrong’: Christ's Spiritual Marriage and the Law of the Late Medieval Western Church
- Index of Biblical Passages
- Index of Names
Summary
Abstract
Twelfth-century church lawyers employed concepts like spiritual marriage to justify norms regulating Christian life. In Medieval Marriage (2005), David d’Avray has argued that spiritual marriage was key to the notion of marriage as an unbreakable bond and exerted real influence on the domestic partnerships of Western Christians. The present chapter challenges this assertion, questioning (1) the contention that the related idea of canonical bigamy assumed shape under the decisive influence of theological tenets. The principle of matrimonial indissolubility is also discussed (2), again suggesting that spiritual marriage furnished juristic theory with just one rationale among many. Canonists drew on biblical imagery to reason by way of analogy but maintained much of their interpretive freedom in doing so.
Keywords: canon law; marriage; indissolubility; bigamy; bishops
Spiritual marriage symbolism takes center stage in the present book. Most of its essays explore shades of meaning interpreters attached to the notion from Late Antiquity through the Middle Ages. This contribution does not add to the conceptual analysis of previous chapters, but addresses instead the issue of relative historical significance. Visitors to the Roman church of Santa Maria in Trastevere just need to look up to the splendidly decorated apse (described by Lasse Hodne in Chapter 10) in order to appreciate the centrality of spiritual marriage imagery in that space. But what about the relative importance of the same motif in other contexts? Before the advent of scholastic culture in the twelfth century, it is difficult to weigh the impact of an idea beyond assertions that a particular understanding of it was more or less widespread. Scholastic thinkers, on the other hand, were quite explicit in assigning degrees of relevance to traditional concepts such as spiritual marriage as they engaged in novel efforts to harmonize and systematize ecclesiastical doctrine. The first few generations of canon lawyers, I will argue, attributed only a marginal role to Christ's union with the Church when crafting the laws of sacramental marriage and priestly ordination.
From the twelfth century onward, the idea that there existed an unbreakable matrimonial bond between Christ and his Church permeated the thought of ecclesiastical lawyers (also known as canonists) no less than it affected the reflections of theologians.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Symbolism of Marriage in Early Christianity and the Latin Middle AgesImages, Impact, Cognition, pp. 329 - 348Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2019