Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Table of Contents
- Note on Transliteration
- Abbreviations
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction: US-China Relations at a Historic Crossroad
- Part One Background and Lost Voices
- 1 From Admirer to Critic: Li Dazhao’s Changing Attitudes toward the United States
- 2 Legacy of the Exclusion Act and Chinese Americans’ Experience
- 3 Disillusioned Diplomacy: US Policy towards Wang Jingwei’s Reorganized National Government, 1938–1945
- Part Two Did America Lose China?
- 4 Lost Opportunity or Mission Impossible: A Historiographical Essay on the Marshall Mission to China, December 1945–January 1947
- 5 Negotiating from Strength: US-China Diplomatic Challenges at the Korean War Armistice Conference, 1951–1953
- 6 Mao Zedong and the Taiwan Strait Crises
- Part Three Rapprochement and Opportunities
- 7 Media and US-China Reconciliation
- 8 Sino-American Relations in the Wake of Tiananmen, 1989–1991
- 9 Jiang Zemin and the United States: Hiding Hatred and Biding Time for Revenge
- Part Four Did China Lose America?
- 10 China’s Belt-Road Strategy: Xinjiang’s Role in a System without America
- 11 The East and South China Seas in Sino-US Relations
- Conclusion: The Coming Cold War II?
- Index
4 - Lost Opportunity or Mission Impossible: A Historiographical Essay on the Marshall Mission to China, December 1945–January 1947
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 March 2023
- Frontmatter
- Dedication
- Table of Contents
- Note on Transliteration
- Abbreviations
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction: US-China Relations at a Historic Crossroad
- Part One Background and Lost Voices
- 1 From Admirer to Critic: Li Dazhao’s Changing Attitudes toward the United States
- 2 Legacy of the Exclusion Act and Chinese Americans’ Experience
- 3 Disillusioned Diplomacy: US Policy towards Wang Jingwei’s Reorganized National Government, 1938–1945
- Part Two Did America Lose China?
- 4 Lost Opportunity or Mission Impossible: A Historiographical Essay on the Marshall Mission to China, December 1945–January 1947
- 5 Negotiating from Strength: US-China Diplomatic Challenges at the Korean War Armistice Conference, 1951–1953
- 6 Mao Zedong and the Taiwan Strait Crises
- Part Three Rapprochement and Opportunities
- 7 Media and US-China Reconciliation
- 8 Sino-American Relations in the Wake of Tiananmen, 1989–1991
- 9 Jiang Zemin and the United States: Hiding Hatred and Biding Time for Revenge
- Part Four Did China Lose America?
- 10 China’s Belt-Road Strategy: Xinjiang’s Role in a System without America
- 11 The East and South China Seas in Sino-US Relations
- Conclusion: The Coming Cold War II?
- Index
Summary
Abstract
As Truman’s representative, George Marshall mediated the CCP-GMD conflicts in China between 1945 and 1947. A cornerstone of Truman’s China policy, the Marshall Mission has been studied by American scholars in the context of the emerging Cold War. Investigating it from a different angle and perspective, however, Chinese historians in both mainland China and Taiwan are more focused on its impact on the CCP-GMD power balance and the outcome of the Chinese civil war. A historiographical overview of their interpretations and analysis, this chapter discusses the most recent Chinese scholarship on the Marshall Mission and argues that the theoretical framework and research agendas of the Chinese scholars remain fundamentally China-centred or Taiwan-centred even after the Cold War.
Keywords: Patrick Hurley, Truman’s China Policy, the Marshall Mission, Jiang Jieshi, Mao Zedong, Manchuria
When Henry Truman became the thirty-third president of the United States on April 12, 1945, he inherited from the FDR administration a China policy the purpose of which his Secretary of State James Byrnes defined as to build ‘a strong, united, and democratic China’ (May 1974, 10). However, when Truman passed the presidency to Dwight Eisenhower on January 20, 1953, not only did China remain divided between the People’s Republic of China (PRC) on the mainland and the Republic of China (ROC) in Taiwan, but the United States had done its share in perpetuating such a division by fighting the Korean War with the PRC under the rule of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and by forging a political and military alliance with Taiwan under the rule of the Nationalist Party (Guomindang, GMD). Examining this episode of Sino-US relations in the context of the twentieth-century US China policy that began with John Hay’s Open Door Notes, Warren Cohen, a renowned historian of modern China and US foreign relations, calls the Truman administration’s China policy after 1950 the ‘great aberration’ caused by the fear of Communism that made the American people and their leaders forget ‘the sound geopolitical, economic, and ethical basis of their historic desire for China’s well-being’ (Cohen 2019, 198).
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Sino-American RelationsA New Cold War, pp. 113 - 134Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2022