Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Content
- Note on Terminology
- About the Author
- Acknowledgements
- Preface
- Beyond the Wall
- 1 Reimagining a Black Art Infused Criminology
- 2 The People Speak: The Importance of Black Arts Movements
- 3 Shadow People: Black Crime Fiction as Counter-Narrative
- 4 Staging the Truth: Black Theatre and the Politics of Black Criminality
- 5 Beyond The Wire: The Racialization of Crime in Film and TV
- 6 Strange Fruit: Black Music (Re)presenting the Race and Crime
- 7 Of Mules and Men: Oral Storytelling and the Racialization of Crime
- 8 Seeing the Story: Visual Art and the Racialization of Crime
- 9 Speaking Data and Telling Stories
- 10 Locating the Researcher: (Auto)-Ethnography, Race, and the Researcher
- 11 Towards a Black Arts Infused Criminology
- Bibliography
- Index
3 - Shadow People: Black Crime Fiction as Counter-Narrative
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 December 2021
- Frontmatter
- Content
- Note on Terminology
- About the Author
- Acknowledgements
- Preface
- Beyond the Wall
- 1 Reimagining a Black Art Infused Criminology
- 2 The People Speak: The Importance of Black Arts Movements
- 3 Shadow People: Black Crime Fiction as Counter-Narrative
- 4 Staging the Truth: Black Theatre and the Politics of Black Criminality
- 5 Beyond The Wire: The Racialization of Crime in Film and TV
- 6 Strange Fruit: Black Music (Re)presenting the Race and Crime
- 7 Of Mules and Men: Oral Storytelling and the Racialization of Crime
- 8 Seeing the Story: Visual Art and the Racialization of Crime
- 9 Speaking Data and Telling Stories
- 10 Locating the Researcher: (Auto)-Ethnography, Race, and the Researcher
- 11 Towards a Black Arts Infused Criminology
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
Chapter summary
Within this chapter I explore how black crime fiction operates much the same as a researcher investigating the complexities of black life through immersive observation such as ethnography. Black crime fiction, I would argue, lifts the veil on black criminality, victimhood, and offending, much the same as any other crime fiction genre. However, additionally, what black crime fiction does, through character interaction, plot construction, propelled by a black vernacular, is to shine a light on the nuances of race, that shape elements of black criminality obscured by much of so-called mainstream criminology, which at times fails to capture, engage with, or represent black life, and its relationship with society and history.
Troubling thoughts
Out of all the chapters in this book, this one has proved to be the most challenging, mainly because of a lack of clarity. However, Ramdarshan (2019), when writing about the lack of representation of people of colour among children's book authors and illustrators, enabled me to reframe my focus:
Take collective action to break down the systemic barriers to representation of creators of colour. We know that people of colour are under-represented in the creative and cultural sectors. In this report we argue that one of the challenges to changing this is to confront a negative cycle of barriers which are reflective of those seen within our society more generally. (Ramdarshan, 2019: 15)
Similarly, I would argue that criminology, in its vision, should seek to provide for, and validate, new routes of access for stories of crime, be they fiction, or non-fiction, as a way of embedding and validating more diverse epistemological lenses from which to view the racialization of crime. Mordhorst (2008) argues for the reintroduction of experimental elements into academic approaches to criminological history. Mordhorst further argues that the story as counter-narrative method, may provide us with new insights into why some narratives attain hegemonic status, and how this can help us to understand the construction and function of historical consciousness. Colvin (2015) similarly sees the power of the dominant discourse is to include some stories as tellable and exclude others as marginal and abnormal.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Reimagining Black Art and CriminologyA New Criminological Imagination, pp. 27 - 42Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2021