Book contents
- Frontmatter
- CONTENTS
- List of Contributors
- Introduction: The Northwest Passage and the Imperial Project: History, Ideology, Myth
- Part I The Earliest Attempts: Texts and Contexts
- Part II Ice and Eskimos: Dealing with a New Otherness
- 4 George Best's Arctic Mirrors: A True Discourse of the Late Voyages of Discoverie … of Martin Frobisher (1578)
- 5 ‘A People of Tractable Conversation’: A Reappraisal of Davis's Contribution to Arctic Scholarship (1585–7)
- 6 Booking a Northwest Passage: Thomas James and The Strange and Dangerovs Voyage (1633)
- Part III The Shift in Methods: Towards Overland Exploration
- Notes
- Index
5 - ‘A People of Tractable Conversation’: A Reappraisal of Davis's Contribution to Arctic Scholarship (1585–7)
from Part II - Ice and Eskimos: Dealing with a New Otherness
- Frontmatter
- CONTENTS
- List of Contributors
- Introduction: The Northwest Passage and the Imperial Project: History, Ideology, Myth
- Part I The Earliest Attempts: Texts and Contexts
- Part II Ice and Eskimos: Dealing with a New Otherness
- 4 George Best's Arctic Mirrors: A True Discourse of the Late Voyages of Discoverie … of Martin Frobisher (1578)
- 5 ‘A People of Tractable Conversation’: A Reappraisal of Davis's Contribution to Arctic Scholarship (1585–7)
- 6 Booking a Northwest Passage: Thomas James and The Strange and Dangerovs Voyage (1633)
- Part III The Shift in Methods: Towards Overland Exploration
- Notes
- Index
Summary
Compared to other Elizabethan mariners who also engaged in exploratory voyages and maritime expeditions, such as Martin Frobisher, Sir Francis Drake or Sir Walter Ralegh, John Davis has received surprisingly little attention in recent years. In her recent book about early modern voyages and English travel narratives, Mary Fuller devotes ample space to Frobisher's voyages but makes only two passing remarks about John Davis, whose name features only once in her introductory chapter about ‘the English Worthies’ in a similar fashion, Robert McGhee acknowledges that Davis outmatched Frobisher in terms of both his sailing and cartographic skills, and yet his brief comments on Davis's three expeditions are confined to the end of his chapter on ‘Martin Frobisher's Gold Mines’. If, as Fuller explains, ‘the celebration of a “heroic Age of Discovery” depends on a number of deliberate and specific omissions – in other words on remembering some things and forgetting others’, then it seems fair to say that John Davis's early contribution to the discovery of the Northwest Passage has often been ‘forgotten’ by the historians of the field. Fuller goes on to remind her readers that:
Forgetting may be ideological, and operate along the lines of particular interests; it can result from a deliberate suppression of certain memories or histories. It is also a function of narrative. To tell a story, one creates a frame, a beginning and end and a central line that moves from one to the other.
[…]
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Quest for the Northwest PassageKnowledge, Nation and Empire, 1576–1806, pp. 71 - 88Publisher: Pickering & ChattoFirst published in: 2014