Book contents
- Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface and Acknowledgments
- Part I The Contours of Dignitarian Humanism
- Part II Against Traditional Accounts of Human Dignity
- Part III A Revisionist Approach
- 8 Dignity-Revisionism: Challenges and Opportunities
- 9 Commercial and Human Economies
- 10 Marx on Value and Valorization
- 11 Love and Respect: Attentional Currencies
- 12 Attentional Precedence
- 13 Human Dignity
- 14 After Respect
- 15 Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Bibliography
- Index
8 - Dignity-Revisionism: Challenges and Opportunities
from Part III - A Revisionist Approach
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 September 2021
- Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface and Acknowledgments
- Part I The Contours of Dignitarian Humanism
- Part II Against Traditional Accounts of Human Dignity
- Part III A Revisionist Approach
- 8 Dignity-Revisionism: Challenges and Opportunities
- 9 Commercial and Human Economies
- 10 Marx on Value and Valorization
- 11 Love and Respect: Attentional Currencies
- 12 Attentional Precedence
- 13 Human Dignity
- 14 After Respect
- 15 Human Dignity and Political Criticism
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
The second half of this book attempts to reconstruct an alternative account of human dignity and to evaluate how far its critical credentials in political reflection can be vindicated. The account I will offer is revisionary in that it drops any presumption that human dignity is a preset value standing apart from the transactions and routines of everyday life. It aims to liberate the central dignitarian intuition that all lives matter, and should be valued accordingly, from the two traditionalist mainstays rejected in earlier chapters: on the one hand, the assumption that human dignity is immutably possessed by persons; and on the other, that it consists in an idealized relation of equality defining a kind of dignitarian kallipolis like Kant’s “kingdom of ends.” Instead, the revisionist proposes that human dignity is a transient, vulnerable, and socially extended quality whose emergence depends on the character of concrete, organized, interaction under actually existing regimes.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Human Dignity and Political Criticism , pp. 113 - 125Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2021