Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- INTRODUCTION
- SECTION I TORT LAW IN THE NEW MILLENNIUM: PAST AS PROLOGUE
- 1 TORT LAW THROUGH TIME AND CULTURE: THEMES OF ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY
- 2 PAST AS PRELUDE: THE LEGACY OF FIVE LANDMARKS OF TWENTIETH-CENTURY INJURY LAW FOR THE FUTURE OF TORTS
- SECTION II COMPENSATION AND DETERRENCE IN THE MODERN WORLD
- SECTION III DUTY RULES, COURTS, AND TORTS
- SECTION IV TORTS IN A SHRINKING WORLD
- Index
2 - PAST AS PRELUDE: THE LEGACY OF FIVE LANDMARKS OF TWENTIETH-CENTURY INJURY LAW FOR THE FUTURE OF TORTS
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Contributors
- Preface
- INTRODUCTION
- SECTION I TORT LAW IN THE NEW MILLENNIUM: PAST AS PROLOGUE
- 1 TORT LAW THROUGH TIME AND CULTURE: THEMES OF ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY
- 2 PAST AS PRELUDE: THE LEGACY OF FIVE LANDMARKS OF TWENTIETH-CENTURY INJURY LAW FOR THE FUTURE OF TORTS
- SECTION II COMPENSATION AND DETERRENCE IN THE MODERN WORLD
- SECTION III DUTY RULES, COURTS, AND TORTS
- SECTION IV TORTS IN A SHRINKING WORLD
- Index
Summary
abstract. This chapter offers some thoughts on prospective developments in injury reparation through the prism of what are, in my view, the principal landmarks of twentieth-century American tort and compensation law. I discuss, in roughly chronological order, the four developments that seem to me most critical in restructuring the very foundations of tort law in the twentieth century: First, Judge Benjamin Cardozo's opinion in the landmark case of MacPherson v. Buick Motor Co.; second, the Progressive Era adoption of workmen's compensation legislation; third, the concurring opinion of Justice Roger Traynor in Escola v. Coca Cola Bottling Co.; and fourth, the primarily legislative movement from contributory to comparative fault.
The chapter then turns to a fifth landmark, United States v. Carroll Towing Co., which attained its status by serving as a catalyst for intellectual ferment, rather than through its direct impact on the tort system. In this last instance, I depart from chronological presentation because the noteworthiness of Carroll Towing came not in its immediate aftermath, but some twenty-five years later when Judge Learned Hand's opinion came to be recognized as a cornerstone of the law and economics movement. My focal point will be the themes that emerge from each of these developments, for it is the rich thematic influence in every instance that forced reexamination of the basic goals, as well as the appropriate domain, of tort law. Similarly, that rich thematic material creates continuing resonance for my corresponding discussion of future developments in the torts area.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Exploring Tort Law , pp. 52 - 78Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2005