4 - Eurocentrism in Research on Mass Violence
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 November 2020
Summary
Abstract
This chapter examines Eurocentrism in mass violence research, by focusing on two themes relevant to it: Holocaust uniqueness and Orientalism. Holocaust uniqueness is a moral position that privileges European perpetrators and victims over other, similarly destructive genocides. The chapter discusses how proportionality in scholarship and representation can rectify some of these imbalances. Orientalism in mass violence research manifests itself in Islamophobic biases against the violence of Islamist militants, especially in the twenty-first-century conflicts in Iraq and Syria. Both phenomena have deeply influenced research on mass violence, and both are critically examined in the broader context of Eurocentrism.
Keywords: mass violence, Holocaust, Orientalism
Introduction
Genocide can be defined as a complex process of systematic persecution and annihilation of a group of people by a government. In the twentieth century, approximately 40 to 60 million defenceless people became victims of deliberate genocidal policies. The twenty-first century has not begun much better, with genocidal episodes flaring up in Darfur, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Myanmar, and Syria. I understand genocide as the persecution and destruction of human beings on the basis of their presumed or imputed membership in a group, rather than on their individual properties or participation in certain acts. Although it makes little sense to quantify genocide, it is clear that a genocidal process always concerns a society at large, and that genocide often destroys a significant and often critical part of the affected communities. It also does not make much sense to discriminate between the types of groups that are being targeted: ethnic, religious, regional, political, sexual, etc. It can be argued that genocidal processes are particularly malicious and destructive because they are directed against all members of a group, mostly innocent and defenceless people who are persecuted and killed regardless of their behaviour. Genocide always denotes a colossal and brutal collective criminality. For this reason, genocide is a phenomenon that is distinct from other forms of mass violence such as war, civil war, or massacre.
Genocide is a complex process through and through. First of all, it can be approached from at least three analytical perspectives: macro (international), meso (domestic), and micro (local/individual). The macro level refers to the external, international context: interstate structures and the context of geopolitical power relations that could lead to war.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Eurocentrism in European History and Memory , pp. 65 - 78Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2019