Book contents
- Frontmatter
- PREFACE TO FIRST EDITION
- PREFACE TO SECOND EDITION
- Contents
- SOME INTRODUCTORY DATES
- INTRODUCTORY CHAPTER
- I THE PROBABILITIES FROM KNOWN CHARACTER AND EDUCATION OF THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS
- II THE INTERNAL EVIDENCE OF SHAKSPERE'S PLAYS AND BACON'S BOOKS
- III SPECIAL ILLUSTRATION
- IV WHETHER WERE THE POEMS AND PLAYS CLAIMED BY SHAKSPERE OR BACON?
- V EXTERNAL EVIDENCE
- VI THE HISTORY OF THE HERESY
- VII BACON'S CIPHERS
- APPENDIX
- INDEX
- PRESS NOTICES
II - THE INTERNAL EVIDENCE OF SHAKSPERE'S PLAYS AND BACON'S BOOKS
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 April 2011
- Frontmatter
- PREFACE TO FIRST EDITION
- PREFACE TO SECOND EDITION
- Contents
- SOME INTRODUCTORY DATES
- INTRODUCTORY CHAPTER
- I THE PROBABILITIES FROM KNOWN CHARACTER AND EDUCATION OF THE WRITER OF THE PLAYS
- II THE INTERNAL EVIDENCE OF SHAKSPERE'S PLAYS AND BACON'S BOOKS
- III SPECIAL ILLUSTRATION
- IV WHETHER WERE THE POEMS AND PLAYS CLAIMED BY SHAKSPERE OR BACON?
- V EXTERNAL EVIDENCE
- VI THE HISTORY OF THE HERESY
- VII BACON'S CIPHERS
- APPENDIX
- INDEX
- PRESS NOTICES
Summary
Distinctions of internal evidence can be drawn from the subjects of the writings, the treatment, the accessories, and the style in relation to the lives of the two men we are considering. Now, though it is too much to say that Bacon would not have chosen any of Shakspere's subjects, it is certainly permissible to assert he could not have chosen all of them; because Bacon never wrote without some intention, either didactic or practical. Therefore, while some of the histories might have been written as warnings, and others as glorifications of the reigning sovereign, nothing in his life or writings suggests a possibility of his having treated pure poetry for art's sake. There seems no cause likely to have tempted him to select subjects like Midsummer's Night's Dream, Romeo and Juliet, As You Like It. The same remark may be applied to the poems. One cannot imagine Bacon selecting either Venus or Lucrece as “inventions” worthy the devotion of his pen. A few masques, a New Atlantis, a few sonnets, a few psalms, are all he has acknowledged.
But the difference is more strongly exemplified when we turn to the treatment of the subjects. Bacon's criticisms of poetry, De Augmentis, book ii. chap, xiii., shows that he considers it has a right to go beyond Nature in treating life, and to introduce a moral and physical order higher than is found compatible with truth.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Bacon–Shakspere Question Answered , pp. 28 - 44Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2010First published in: 1889