Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- The G-24
- List of Contributors
- Foreword
- 1 Introduction
- 2 The Bretton Woods Institutions: Governance without Legitimacy?
- 3 Reforming the International Monetary Fund: Towards Enhanced Accountability and Legitimacy
- 4 Improving IMF Governance and Increasing the Influence of Developing Countries in IMF Decision-Making
- 5 Issues on IMF Governance and Representation: An Evaluation of Alternative Options
- 6 Making the IMF and the World Bank More Accountable
- 7 Purchasing Power Parities and Comparisons of GDP in IMF Quota Calculations
- 8 Measuring Vulnerability: Capital Flows Volatility in the Quota Formula
- 9 Enhancing the Voice of Developing Countries in The World Bank: Selective Double Majority Voting and a Pilot Phase Approach
- 10 Voting Power Implications of a Double Majority Voting Procedure in the IMF's Executive Board
- 11 Power versus Weight in IMF Governance: The Possible Beneficial Implications of a United European Bloc Vote
- 12 Changing IMF Quotas: The Role of the United States Congress
5 - Issues on IMF Governance and Representation: An Evaluation of Alternative Options
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 March 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- The G-24
- List of Contributors
- Foreword
- 1 Introduction
- 2 The Bretton Woods Institutions: Governance without Legitimacy?
- 3 Reforming the International Monetary Fund: Towards Enhanced Accountability and Legitimacy
- 4 Improving IMF Governance and Increasing the Influence of Developing Countries in IMF Decision-Making
- 5 Issues on IMF Governance and Representation: An Evaluation of Alternative Options
- 6 Making the IMF and the World Bank More Accountable
- 7 Purchasing Power Parities and Comparisons of GDP in IMF Quota Calculations
- 8 Measuring Vulnerability: Capital Flows Volatility in the Quota Formula
- 9 Enhancing the Voice of Developing Countries in The World Bank: Selective Double Majority Voting and a Pilot Phase Approach
- 10 Voting Power Implications of a Double Majority Voting Procedure in the IMF's Executive Board
- 11 Power versus Weight in IMF Governance: The Possible Beneficial Implications of a United European Bloc Vote
- 12 Changing IMF Quotas: The Role of the United States Congress
Summary
Abstract:
The current realities of the global economy are far from being reflected in the Fund's quota structure, with EM economies accounting for the bulk of the under- representation. This paper explores the characteristics of the representation distortions using cross-section regression analysis and the results indicate that economic growth, population, credit rating and dummies for the United States and China explain most of them. To the extent that the faster growing countries are not recognized as such in their IMF quotas, the distortions will continue to increase. Eliminating such distortions requires adjusting the quota structure in line with the relative participation in global economic activity, but to the extent that individual quotas cannot be reduced, a large increase in total IMF quotas would be required. Simulations performed under the assumption that all over-represented advanced economies would accept to reduce their quotas indicate that only about one-half of the rate of increase in total quotas would be required. As an initial step towards the elimination of distortions in representation, rules for a professional IMF board are proposed, including that all Executive Directors (EDs) should be elected and be independent from the influence of a permanent employer, that all countries with a common currency be represented by the same ED and that each chair should represent at least three member countries and at most fifteen. In a scenario using these rules and attempting to preserve the existing regional representation, advanced economies would lose three chairs, emerging markets would gain two and developing countries would gain the remaining one.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Reforming the Governance of the IMF and the World Bank , pp. 107 - 148Publisher: Anthem PressPrint publication year: 2005
- 1
- Cited by