Our Introduction traces the biography of John Cleland, the notorious and hitherto elusive eighteenth-century author, as we now see it through the letters and documents published in this volume. We follow his early career in Bombay, climbing the ranks of the East India Company, his prison writing of and subsequent re-arrest for Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure, his volatile relationship with his mother, his disappointment in writing for the stage, his patronage by the Delaval family, and – new to Cleland scholarship – his intriguing friendship with Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont and the French spy Thomas Pichon, which reveals new attributions to Cleland and his attempted assimilation amongst a literary Francophone community as ‘Jean de Cleland’.

Chapter 2 describes the divergence between 1790 and 1830 of British and American thought on privilege and truth and describes the emergence of the common-law offense of publishing an obscene libel. The legal questions central to Burdett v. Abbot (King’s Bench, 1811) about the extent to which the British common law courts could consider parliamentary law are discussed. In Massachusetts the Supreme Judicial Court in Coffin v. Coffin in 1808 had much less constitutional difficulty constraining legislative privilege. Much more challenging in Massachusetts was the role of evidence of truth in a libel trial, after it had come in the 1790s to be understood as an appropriate defense for a republican citizen, criticism being necessary to the functioning of a republic. Evidence of truth became admissible in an ever-growing set of circumstances in which the public needed to be informed.