Search

Skip to main content Accessibility help

Only show content I have access to (0)

Chapters (1)

Last 3 years (1)

From year:

To year:

Apply

Psychology (1)

Cambridge University Press (1)

1 results

Chapter 4 - The Role of Context in Belief Evaluation: Costs and Benefits of Irrational Beliefs
from Philosophical and Linguistic Approaches to Beliefs
- By Elly Vintiadis, Lisa Bortolotti
Edited by Julien Musolino, Rutgers University, New Jersey, Joseph Sommer, Rutgers University, New Jersey, Pernille Hemmer, Rutgers University, New Jersey
Book:

The Cognitive Science of Belief

Published online:

03 November 2022

Print publication:

17 November 2022, pp 92-110
- Chapter
- - Get access
    
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
    
    Log in Register
- Export citation
Summary

Irrational beliefs are often associated with poor mental health and are seen as costly beliefs that should be eliminated or replaced when possible. Building on decades of empirical research, we argue that irrational beliefs are widespread in human cognition and not confined to people with poor mental health. Moreover, recent philosophical research has emphasized that irrational beliefs can be beneficial to the person holding them, not only psychologically but also epistemically, which suggests that in some cases elimination or replacement is not the most appropriate course of action. The problem emerging is how we decide when an agent’s irrational belief needs to be challenged: in this chapter, we point to the importance of the social context surrounding the agent by discussing one case of everyday confabulation whose effects vary across contexts.