Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T10:12:23.008Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Archives and Late Nineteenth Century Ethiopia - Colonial Powers and Ethiopian Frontiers 1880–1884: Acta Aethiopica volume IV Edited by Sven Rubenson, Amsalu Aklilu, Shiferaw Bekele, and Samuel Rubenson. Lund University Press: Lund, 2021. Pp. 281. $37.73, hardcover (ISBN: 9789198469967); ebook (ISBN: 9789198469974).

Review products

Colonial Powers and Ethiopian Frontiers 1880–1884: Acta Aethiopica volume IV Edited by Sven Rubenson, Amsalu Aklilu, Shiferaw Bekele, and Samuel Rubenson. Lund University Press: Lund, 2021. Pp. 281. $37.73, hardcover (ISBN: 9789198469967); ebook (ISBN: 9789198469974).

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 August 2023

Jacob Wiebel*
Affiliation:
University of Durham
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Book Review
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press

Acta Aethiopica has established a well-deserved reputation as an indispensable resource for any serious student of nineteenth-century Ethiopian history. Among historians of Africa more widely, this extraordinary and accessible collection of sources remains insufficiently known. It would be to the detriment of our profession if the publication of this fourth volume in the series did not attract a much wider readership. The book not only offers compelling insights into African responses to the establishment of European colonial rule in the late nineteenth century, but also provides rich materials for any historians teaching on the subject.

The Acta Aethiopica series was brought into being through the painstaking editorial work of Sven Rubenson and Amsalu Aklilu, who over decades sought out and collected original documents from nineteenth-century Ethiopia in the archives of almost a dozen countries. Each volume in the series reproduces many of these sources, wherever possible through high-quality copies of the original, which are presented alongside first-rate translations and brief contextualising annotations. The primary focus remains on the correspondence of Ethiopian rulers and notables, but the volumes also cover a range of other concerns, particularly those pertaining to the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. Concise introductions provide an excellent overview of the documents included and explain the choices made in selecting, translating, and presenting them. While introductions and notes are written for expert readers and do presuppose a solid foundation of contextual knowledge, they are equally helpful to non-experts, especially if read alongside the secondary literature on the period.

This fourth volume in the series — Colonial Powers and Ethiopian Frontiers 1880–1884 — meets the high bar set by its predecessors’ quality and reputation. This has been achieved despite the deaths of both lead editors before this book was completed, thanks to the excellent work of Samuel Rubenson and Shiferaw Bekele, who capably took up the mantle of their predecessors and brought this ambitious project to completion. The volume presents 198 documents collected from archives in Ethiopia, Egypt, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Russia, Israel/Palestine, Greece, and Sweden. A majority were written in Amharic, almost a third in Arabic, and some in European languages, notably French but also English and Swedish. Collectively, these documents illustrate the growing influence of European interests in the region and highlight the diversity and complexity of local responses to it. It is noteworthy that, as the series works its way through the nineteenth century, the quantity of the documents it presents increases dramatically: whereas the first volume covered the 54 years from 1800 to the eve of Emperor Tewodros II's reign, and Volumes II and III presented documents taken from a span of 14 and 11 years, respectively, this latest iteration reproduces a comparable number of sources from just the first half of the eventful 1880s. A fifth volume, covering the remainder of the 1880s, is planned.

As with previous works in the series, the book's focus is primarily on official documents of Ethiopian rulers and notables. As the title indicates, the expanding economic and political presence of imperial European powers in the region looms large in the sources reproduced here. Many documents are addressed to Europeans, while others demonstrate Ethiopian officials’ concerns about — and responses to — Europeans’ growing presence in the region. Distinctive in this volume is the inclusion of many letters by officials of Afar and of the Red Sea littoral, which often highlighted the French and Italian influence and interest in a region that Europeans saw as a gateway to the interior. The emperor Yohannes IV wrote a plurality of the correspondence reproduced in the volume; second by quantity are letters — and two treaties — from the court of his eventual successor, Minilik, then the King of Shewa. Among these is a letter from his wife, Weyzero Taytu, to Queen Margherita of Italy — a rare female voice in the volume, and one that sheds unique light on the diplomatic role that women and feminine virtues could play.

Yet it is not only for the political histories of rival imperial projects that this volume merits close attention; much is also revealed about other themes. Religious concerns feature prominently. Three examples indicate the range of these: a letter in Swedish by the early Protestant convert Onesimus Nesib to the missionary Johannes Neander, regarding concerns about the trade in Oromo slaves that he witnessed; a stinging rebuke to Swedish Protestant missionaries by Ras Alula, echoed by an even more hostile assessment by Yohannes IV; and a warm letter from the same emperor to the Ethiopian monastic community in Jerusalem.

The introduction and the notes provide concise and helpful guidance to the documents, augmented by an overview and explanation of the seals used in the included correspondence. While some sources presented here have been published elsewhere before, it is the sheer range and the value of having them all bound together in a single volume — including originals, translations, and explanatory notes — that puts Acta Aethiopica in a category of its own.

Colonial Powers and Ethiopian Frontiers represents the entirely successful continuation of an important project. Like its predecessors, it will be welcomed and closely studied by researchers, teachers, and students of Ethiopian history. But in highlighting local responses to nascent European colonial ventures in Africa, it also appeals to a much wider audience, and it merits a place in a wide range of syllabi.

In recent decades, narratives about late-nineteenth-century Ethiopia have been central to regional politics of identity and representation. If there is a common danger in such accounts, it is a tendency to obscure the complexity and interconnectedness of the region's political, religious, and ethnic histories. Through the primary sources it presents, Colonial Powers and the Ethiopian Frontiers 1880-1884 provides a timely antidote to any such ideological streamlining of the past. More generally, the book is a great advert for a genre — the well-contextualised collection of essential primary documents — that deserves to be expanded.