Impact statement
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and ICD-11 complex PTSD (CPTSD) are considered under‐researched disorders in the older population, particularly factors associated with CPTSD in old age. This study is unique as it aims to provide insight into the differences between older adults suffering from PTSD with those suffering from CPTSD. The study focused on factors associated with current PTSD and CPTSD among older adults exposed to a traumatic event before the COVID-19 pandemic. This study differentiated between three groups of older adults at the end of the fifth wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in Israel: those with no diagnosis of PTSD, those who reached the PTSD cutoff, and those who exhibited CPTSD. Participants with PTSD reported higher levels of trauma exposure, COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness relative to those not reaching the PTSD cutoff level. Moreover, participants with CPTSD displayed higher levels of loneliness, COVID-19 worries, exposure to trauma, and depression relative to those not reaching the PTSD cutoff level. The study underscores that older adults suffering from trauma are at risk for adverse outcomes in the face of global disasters, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, there is a significant risk for those suffering from CPTSD, distinguishing them as particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of global disasters. It seems that complex trauma is significantly more related to mental health factors among older adults, which has clinical implications for practitioners. The study highlights the need for further research in the field of CPTSD among older adults to enhance suitable preventive interventions for the adverse mental outcomes of older adults faced with global disasters, with extra consideration for extended treatment protocols for those suffering from CPTSD.
Introduction
Older adults have been particularly affected by the adverse outcomes of the COVID-19 pandemic, with many being infected by the virus (Niu et al., Reference Niu, Tian, Lou, Kang, Zhang, Lian and Zhang2020). Consequently, studies focusing on older adults throughout the pandemic have reported declines in mental health (Shrira et al., Reference Shrira, Hoffman, Bodner and Palgi2020) including death anxiety (Ring et al., Reference Ring, Greenblatt-Kimron and Palgi2022), peritraumatic distress (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021), and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021). Moreover, older adults suffering from PTSD depression comorbidity before the outbreak of COVID-19 reported the highest risk of feeling depressed, anxious, and lonely relative to those with no symptoms before the pandemic (Cohn-Schwartz et al., Reference Cohn-Schwartz, Hoffman and Shrira2022). Furthermore, researchers have described COVID-19 as a persistent continuing traumatic stress, with a probability of being encountered as severe (Kira et al., Reference Kira, Shuwiekh, Ashby, Elwakeel, Alhuwailah, Sous, Baali, Azdaou, Oliemat and Jamil2021).
The ICD-11 broadened the knowledge of traumatic stress disorders with the new disorder of complex PTSD (CPTSD) (World Health Organization, 2018). CPTSD, linked with extended, recurrent, interpersonal, and unpreventable trauma exposure (Karatzias et al., Reference Karatzias, Shevlin, Fyvie, Hyland, Efthymiadou, Wilson, Roberts, Bisson, Brewin and Cloitre2017), comprises three PTSD clusters of re-experiencing the trauma, avoidance of traumatic reminders, and a continual sense of threat and also includes three clusters reflecting disturbances in self-organization (DSO), namely affective dysregulation, negative self-concept, and disturbances in relationships (World Health Organization, 2018). Researchers examined PTSD among older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021); nonetheless, PTSD and CPTSD are considered under‐researched disorders in the older population (World Health Organization, 2017), particularly factors associated with CPTSD in old age. This study is unique as it specifically aims at examining older adults while providing insight into the differences between older adults suffering from PTSD with those also suffering from CPTSD. We assume that under conditions of prolonged COVID-19 stressors, those with higher previous exposure to traumatic events will exhibit higher vulnerability to PTSD and CPTSD. In particular, the study examined factors associated with current PTSD and CPTSD among older adults at the end of the fifth wave of COVID-19 in Israel. These factors, discussed briefly as follows, include previous trauma exposure, COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness.
Prior trauma exposure and posttraumatic reactions
Previous data indicate that adults aged between 60 and 70 years have about 3.5 and 2.5 times less chance of reaching the diagnostic requirements for PTSD and CPTSD, respectively, than those younger than 60 years (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022). Nevertheless, data from samples from four different countries show that PTSD rates were generally lower among older adults, while inconsistent findings are found with regard to CPTSD (McGinty et al., Reference McGinty, Fox, Ben-Ezra, Cloitre, Karatzias, Shevlin and Hyland2021). Significantly, previous studies show a link between PTSD from previous trauma exposure with a heightened risk for PTSD succeeding a subsequent traumatic event (Breslau et al., Reference Breslau, Peterson and Schultz2008; Kessler et al., Reference Kessler, Aguilar-Gaxiola, Alonso, Bromet, Gureje, Karam, Koenen, Sing, Liu, Pennell, Petukhova, Sampson, Shahly, Stein, Atwoli, Borges, Bunting, de, Gluzman and Zaslavsky2018). Moreover, prior trauma exposure may amplify vulnerability during the COVID-19 pandemic and correlate with successive posttraumatic reactions (Lahav, Reference Lahav2020). Indeed, in a study among the general population in Israel, anxiety, depression, and peritraumatic stress symptoms linked with COVID-19 were higher among those with pre-exposure to traumatic events before the COVID-19 pandemic relative to those without trauma exposure, invariant of demographic characteristics, and pandemic stressors (Lahav, Reference Lahav2020). Furthermore, in the first study to examine COVID-19 vaccine-related stressors in the context of ICD-11 PTSD symptoms among older adults exposed to a traumatic event before the COVID-19 outbreak, results showed an exacerbation of PTSD symptoms due to depression, ageism, and COVID-19 vaccine-related factors (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021). On this basis, it is assumed that older adults with trauma exposure before the COVID-19 pandemic will exhibit higher levels of PTSD and CPTSD relative to older adults without trauma exposure.
COVID-19 worries and posttraumatic reactions
Researchers highlighted the adverse effects of COVID-19 worries on older adults’ mental health (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021). For example, a relationship was reported between perceived susceptibility to COVID-19 with worry, fear, and stress as an outcome of the pandemic (Inbar and Shinan-Altman, Reference Inbar and Shinan-Altman2021). Other researchers found correlations between COVID-19 health worries with death anxiety (Ring et al., Reference Ring, Greenblatt-Kimron and Palgi2022) and peritraumatic distress (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021). In this light, it is assumed that COVID-19 worries would be associated with current PTSD and CPTSD among older adults.
Depressive symptoms and posttraumatic reactions
It is well documented that untreated depressive symptoms may harm older adults’ physical and mental health (Agustini et al., Reference Agustini, Lotfaliany, Woods, McNeil, Nelson, Shah, Murray, Ernest, Reid, Tonkin, Lockery, Williams, Berk and Mohebbi2020). While sparse research examined ICD-11 PTSD comorbidity among older adults (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Power and Coogan2020), a recent study identified comorbidity with major depressive disorder (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Power and Coogan2020). With respect to the COVID-19 pandemic, numerous studies revealed depressive symptoms among older adults (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Shrira, Ring, Bodner, Avidor, Bergman, Cohen-Fridel, Keisari and Hoffman2020; Shrira et al., Reference Shrira, Hoffman, Bodner and Palgi2020) including those who had received the COVID-19 vaccination (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Ben-Ezra, Goodwin and Palgi2022). Despite vaccination programs being visualized as the “light at the end of the tunnel” (Hoffman et al., Reference Hoffman, Palgi, Goodwin, Ben-Ezra and Greenblatt-Kimron2022), it was reported in a sample of community-dwelling older adults that 23.8% reached the clinical level of ICD-11 PTSD despite receiving a second dose of the COVID-19 vaccine, with depressive symptoms identified as one of the main factors linked with PTSD (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021). Therefore, this study aimed to broaden the understanding of the relationship between depressive symptoms with traumatic reactions among older adults by including CPTSD in the examination of the adverse mental effects of COVID-19 on older adults who had experienced previous trauma before the outbreak of the pandemic.
Loneliness and posttraumatic reactions
Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic was described as the “loneliness pandemic” (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Shrira, Ring, Bodner, Avidor, Bergman, Cohen-Fridel, Keisari and Hoffman2020). Loneliness, defined as the personal perception of unfulfilled intimate, emotional, and social needs (Dykstra, Reference Dykstra2009), is known for its detrimental mental and physical health outcomes in the older population (Courtin and Knapp, Reference Courtin and Knapp2015). Previous studies reported associations between loneliness and PTSD (Shevlin et al., Reference Shevlin, McElroy and Murphy2015; Itzhaky et al., Reference Itzhaky, Stein, Levin and Solomon2017), with loneliness playing a significant role in contributing to or maintaining CPTSD symptoms (Murphy et al., Reference Murphy, Karatzias, Busuttil, Greenberg and Shevlin2021; Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022). Nevertheless, research regarding the association between loneliness and CPTSD is scarce (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022), particularly in the older population. Among the few existing studies, a correlation was reported between longitudinal changes in social and emotional loneliness with longitudinal changes in PTSD symptoms (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Power, Coogan, Beekman, van Tilburg and Hyland2021). Likewise, a longitudinal study of Israeli prisoners showed a link between those exhibiting CPTSD symptoms and an overall sense of loneliness later in life compared with those exhibiting PTSD symptoms or were without symptoms (Zerach et al., Reference Zerach, Shevlin, Cloitre and Solomon2019). Concerning the COVID-19 pandemic, loneliness was associated with higher levels of anxiety, depression, and peritraumatic distress symptoms among older adults, particularly among those who perceived themselves as older (Shrira et al., Reference Shrira, Hoffman, Bodner and Palgi2020). Hence, the present study sought to also examine the relationship between loneliness and current PTSD and CPTSD among older adults during the fifth COVID-19 wave in Israel, with an emphasis on those suffering from CPTSD.
The current study
Previous data indicated links between trauma exposure, COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness with PTSD symptoms. Aimed at extending the knowledge on ICD-11 PTSD and CPTSD among older adults, highlighted as under‐researched disorders in the older population (World Health Organization, 2017), this study examined the associations between these factors with PTSD and CPTSD among older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic. We hypothesized that previous trauma exposure would be positively associated with current PTSD. The second hypothesis, based on data highlighting the adverse mental outcomes of COVID-19 worries among older adults (Inbar and Shinan-Altman, Reference Inbar and Shinan-Altman2021), maintained that a positive relationship would be found between COVID-19 worries and current PTSD. The third hypothesis was assumed to confirm the reputed association previously found between depression with current PTSD among vaccinated older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021). The fourth hypothesis was elicited from the suggestion that the COVID-19 pandemic is a “loneliness pandemic” (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Shrira, Ring, Bodner, Avidor, Bergman, Cohen-Fridel, Keisari and Hoffman2020), hypothesizing a relationship between loneliness and current PTSD. Finally, we hypothesized that the associations with the study variables (previous trauma exposure, higher COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness) would be stronger among those exhibiting CPTSD.
Materials and methods
Using a Web-based survey company (Ipanel, Israel), data were collected at the end of the fifth wave in Israel during May 2022. During that time, over 95% of the older population had been vaccinated in Israel. Therefore, although we did not examine COVID-19 exposure, it would be fair to assume that almost all participants had received the vaccine. After omitting those who reported that they had not experienced any traumatic event, participants included 512 older Israeli adults aged 67 and older (average age = 72.67 ± 3.81, range 68–87). The inclusion criteria for the study included being fluent in Hebrew and being over the age of 67 (retirement age for males in Israel). The study was approved by the Ariel University IRB Committee. Participants signed an electronic informed consent form and completed self-report questionnaires. About half of the respondents were female (n = 257, 50.2%), 71.5% were in a committed relationship (n = 366), and 81.8% had tertiary education (n = 419) (see Table 1).
Table 1. Descriptive statistics for the study variables
Note: Total N = 512.
a woman.
b currently married or living with a partner.
c ranging on a scale from 0 = no formal education to 5 = high academic education.
d 1 = not good at all to 5 = very good.
e clinical level of PTSD.
* p < 0.05;
** p < 0.01;
*** p < 0.001.
Measurements
Background characteristics included age, gender, marital status (1 = not married, 2 = married/living as cohabitant), and years of education. Physical health was reported using the self-rated health item “In general, how do you rate your health?” on a scale ranging from 1 (not good at all) to 5 (very good) (Idler and Benyamini, Reference Idler and Benyamini1997).
Exposure to previous traumatic events was measured by the Potentially Traumatic Events Inventory adapted from Shmotkin and Litwin (Reference Shmotkin and Litwin2009). Participants were instructed to indicate if they experienced a particular event (yes/no) regarding 13 events (e.g. You were injured in a war or a terrorist attack). On average, participants reported that they were exposed to 3.50 (SD = 2.06) traumatic events. The most frequent events reported were the sudden death of a close person (78.7%) and life-threatening event of a close a person (e.g. illness, injury, and physical impairment) (53.1%). The sum of “yes” answers was used to determine the level of exposure.
COVID-19 worries were assessed by the Brief Coronavirus Threat Scale (Chiacchia et al., Reference Chiacchia, Greenglass, Antoniou, Begic, Buchwald, Chrousos, Dimopoulos, Fiksenbaum, Greenblatt-Kimron, Palgi, Ring, Sesé, Shi and Marjanovic2022). Participants were instructed to report how they felt about each of five statements (e.g. How much do you feel threatened about Coronavirus?) on a five-point Likert scale from 1 (not at all) to 5 (extremely/a great deal). A total score is computed by calculating the mean response to five items. Cronbach’s α in the current study was α = 0.920.
Depressive symptoms were assessed by the 9-item scale (PHQ-9, Kroenke et al., Reference Kroenke, Spitzer and Williams2001). Participants rated how often they felt depressive symptoms in the last month, on a four-point Likert scale from 0 (not at all) to 3 (nearly every day). Scores were computed by summing the items, and ranged from 0 to 24, with higher scores reflecting higher levels of depressive symptoms. Cronbach’s α in this study was α = 0.844.
Loneliness was assessed by the short version of the Revised UCLA Loneliness Scale (UCLA-8) (Hays and DiMatteo, Reference Hays and DiMatteo1987). This scale includes eight items (e.g. I lack companionship) that measure the participants’ level of subjective distress due to lack of relationships, on a scale ranging from 1 (never) to 4 (very often). Scores were computed by the sum of the item scores and ranged from 8 to 32, with higher scores indicating greater loneliness. Cronbach’s α in this study was α = 0.810.
Probable Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and Complex Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD) were assessed by the International Trauma Questionnaire (ITQ; Cloitre et al., Reference Cloitre, Shevlin, Brewin, Bisson, Roberts, Maercker, Karatzias and Hyland2018). Probable PTSD was measured by six items and was determined when participants reported a high or very high level of suffering (≥2) on a five-point Likert scale ranging from 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely) in at least one item of each of the three clusters of re-experiencing, avoidance, and sense of threat. In addition, they had to report that these symptoms caused significant functional impairment (≥2) as reported by three items of important areas of life. Probable CPTSD was determined when participants fit the probable PTSD criteria and also fit the disturbance of self-organization (DSO) criteria. The DSO was assessed with six items and was determined when participants reported a high or very high level of suffering (≥2) in at least one item of each of the three clusters, affective dysregulation, negative self-concept, and disturbed relationships. In addition, to determine probable CPTSD they had to report that these symptoms cause significant functional impairment (≥2) as reported by three items of important areas of life. For convenience purposes, we refer to those reaching clinical levels of PTSD or CPTSD, simply as PTSD or CPTSD. Cronbach’s α for the 12 items (PTSD+CPTSD) in this study was α = 0.897.
Data analysis
First, correlations were examined to establish preliminary associations between the study variables. Then, univariate logistic regressions were conducted to examine the association between COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness in older adults and PTSD (and CPTSD, together) cutoffs compared with those not reaching cutoff levels. Next, multinomial logistic regressions were conducted to examine the association between COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness in older adults reporting PTSD only compared with those with no diagnosis and CPTSD compared with those with no diagnosis. Using SPSS version 27.0, we calculated the odds ratio (OR) with 95% confidence intervals to quantify the strength of the associations.
Results
In our sample, 38 (7.4%) participants reached the clinical PTSD criteria level. Of these, 21 (4.1%) reported a clinical level of PTSD, while the other 17 (3.3%) also reported CPTSD. Participants with PTSD and CPTSD, compared with those without PTSD, showed higher levels of COVID-19 worries, higher levels of trauma exposure, and higher levels of depression (M = 2.20/2.59 vs. 1.11, F = 43.31, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.15; M = 4.81/6.00 vs. 3.35, F = 19.23, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.07; M = 8.29/13.47 vs. 4.48, F = 45.90, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.15, respectively). Moreover, only participants with CPTSD showed higher levels of loneliness compared with those without PTSD (M = 17.43/23.06 vs. 15.42, F = 25.32, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.09).
Next, we conducted a univariate logistic regression to examine differences between participants with PTSD (and CPTSD, together) compared with those who do not reach a cutoff level of PTSD. Results showed that higher levels of COVID-19 worries, trauma exposure, depression, and loneliness increased the risk of having PTSD (see Table 2). Finally, we examined whether there are differences in these associations between participants with PTSD and those who also suffered from CPTSD. Therefore, we conducted a multinomial logistic regression. Analysis showed that in the comparison between those suffering from PTSD relative to those who did not reach the PTSD cutoff level, only COVID-19 worries and trauma exposure were significantly associated with PTSD (OR = 2.97; 95% CI: 1.69–5.21, p < 0.001; OR = 1.30, 95% CI: 1.05–1.62, p < 0.05, respectively).
Table 2. Multinomial and univariate logistic regression analyses
Note: Total N = 512; Nagelkerke R2 = 0.47 and 0.44, respectively.
a Gender 1 = male, 2 = female.
b Marital status 1 = not married, 2 = currently married or living with a partner.
c = Five education levels from 1 = preprimary education to 5 = tertiary education.
d 1 = not good at all to 5 = very good.
* p < 0.05;
** p < 0.01;
*** p < 0.001.
However, in comparison with those who suffered from CPTSD with those who do not reach the PTSD cutoff level, those who were married (OR = 5.73, 95% CI: 1.10–29.67), and who had higher levels of COVID-19 worries (OR = 5.48, 95% CI: 1.88–16.02), exposure to trauma (OR = 1.83, 95% CI: 1.34–2.50), depression (OR = 1.25, 95% CI: 1.09–1.44), and loneliness (OR = 1.29, 95% CI: 1.08–1.53) also showed higher levels of CPTSD. Although no sex differences were found between men and women in the logistic regression, we conducted an additional t-test analysis to examine whether there were differences between males and females with the sum of PTSD and CPTSD symptoms. The results of the t-test revealed a significant difference between the sexes, with females (M = 9.03, SD = 6.93 vs. M = 7.29, SD = 6.94, t(510) = −264, p < 0.01, η2 = −0.23; M = 4.33 SD 4.22 vs. M = 3.49 SD 3.76; t (510) = −2.37, p < 0.05, η2 = −0.23, respectively) showing higher PTSD and CPTSD symptoms than males. The effect size was small.
Discussion
The current study assessed factors associated with current PTSD and CPTSD among older adults exposed to a traumatic event before the COVID-19 pandemic. The study was based on the ICD-11 definitions of PTSD and CPTSD, which are under‐examined disorders in the context of older adults (World Health Organization, 2017). In our sample, the prevalence of PTSD was 7.4%, of which 4.1% reported PTSD, while the other 3.3% also reported CPTSD. These findings coincide with those of a representative sample of older adults in the United States, where 6.1% met the criteria of ICD‐11 PTSD (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Power and Coogan2020). Compared to studies during the COVID-19 pandemic in which the percentages were higher (23.8%) (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021), it seems that the discovery of the vaccine, the decrease in morbidity, and the return to routine restored the level of trauma to its normal level.
The current study differentiated between three groups of older adults at the end of the fifth wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in Israel: those with no diagnosis of PTSD, those who reached the PTSD cutoff, and those who exhibited CPTSD. As hypothesized, participants with PTSD reported higher levels of trauma exposure, COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness. Moreover, participants with CPTSD displayed higher levels of loneliness than those with PTSD and higher levels of COVID-19 worries, exposure to trauma, depression, and loneliness compared with those without PTSD. These results will be further discussed.
In line with the first hypothesis, the results of the univariate logistic regression indicated a link between higher levels of trauma exposure with general PTSD. These results support previous studies showing a relationship between trauma exposure and PTSD and an increased risk of heightened PTSD after an additional traumatic event (Breslau et al., Reference Breslau, Peterson and Schultz2008; Kessler et al., Reference Kessler, Aguilar-Gaxiola, Alonso, Bromet, Gureje, Karam, Koenen, Sing, Liu, Pennell, Petukhova, Sampson, Shahly, Stein, Atwoli, Borges, Bunting, de, Gluzman and Zaslavsky2018). Moreover, as suggested by Lahav (Reference Lahav2020), trauma survivors, particularly those exposed to continuous traumatic stress, appear to be at heightened risk for psychological distress linked with COVID-19. In addition, our findings coincide with results showing a link between peritraumatic stress symptoms due to COVID-19 (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021) and elevated levels of PTSD among older adults who had experienced a traumatic event before the outbreak of the pandemic (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021).
Consistent with the second study hypothesis, a positive association was found between COVID-19 worries and PTSD. This finding may be understood by the adverse physical and mental outcomes of the COVID-19 pandemic on older adults (Niu et al., Reference Niu, Tian, Lou, Kang, Zhang, Lian and Zhang2020; Shrira et al., Reference Shrira, Hoffman, Bodner and Palgi2020) and supports a study in Israel, showing a link between COVID-19 worries and peritraumatic distress among older adults at the outbreak of the pandemic (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021).
Supporting the third hypothesis, the current data showed a relationship between higher levels of depression with PTSD among older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic. This is in line with a previous study revealing an association between depressive symptoms and clinical levels of ICD-11 PTSD among older adults who had received the COVID-19 vaccine (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Greenblatt-Kimron, Hoffman, Goodwin and Ben-Ezra2021). Likewise, the current finding affirms the conclusion that cumulative adversity increases the prospect of depressive symptoms in later life (Shmotkin and Litwin, Reference Shmotkin and Litwin2009) and is in consonance with the findings of ICD-11 PTSD comorbidity with major depressive disorder in a sample of community-dwelling older adults (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Power and Coogan2020).
In accordance with the fourth hypothesis, during the COVID-19 pandemic, described as the “loneliness pandemic” (Palgi et al., Reference Palgi, Shrira, Ring, Bodner, Avidor, Bergman, Cohen-Fridel, Keisari and Hoffman2020), older adults showing PTSD reported more loneliness. This finding is consistent with previous data showing a link between loneliness and higher levels of psychiatric symptoms, specifically anxiety, depression, and peritraumatic distress symptoms among older adults (Shrira et al., Reference Shrira, Hoffman, Bodner and Palgi2020).
In the univariate analysis, most variables were associated with PTSD. Nonetheless, the multinomial analysis showed that most of the effect actually comes from CPTSD. This finding strengthens the notion that CPTSD is associated with numerous forms of traumatic experiences, and while PTSD may be triggered by a single event, CPTSD is generally the outcome of exposure to prolonged or cumulative trauma (Karatzias et al., Reference Karatzias, Shevlin, Fyvie, Hyland, Efthymiadou, Wilson, Roberts, Bisson, Brewin and Cloitre2017). Furthermore, the current results support findings showing significant differences in the number of traumas experienced by a sample of Israeli adults, with the lowest number reported by those with no probable diagnosis and the highest number by those with probable CPTSD (Greenblatt‐Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt‐Kimron, Karatzias, Yonatan, Shoham, Hyland, Ben‐Ezra and Shevlin2023). Additionally, results of the current study showing higher levels of COVID-19 worries and depressive symptoms among those exhibiting CPTSD support previous results, indicating that those with probable CPTSD are the most affected and show a higher level of other comorbidities than those with PTSD, such as symptoms of depression and anxiety (Hyland et al., Reference Hyland, Karatzias, Shevlin, Cloitre and Ben-Ezra2020).
Moreover, our findings indicate that those with CPTSD reported higher levels of loneliness than those with PTSD. These results have significance in trauma studies among older adults. Previous research has underscored the loneliness–PTSD link (Shevlin et al., Reference Shevlin, McElroy and Murphy2015; Itzhaky et al., Reference Itzhaky, Stein, Levin and Solomon2017) and the role of loneliness in the contribution to and maintenance of CPTSD symptoms (Murphy et al., Reference Murphy, Karatzias, Busuttil, Greenberg and Shevlin2021; Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022). Nevertheless, insufficient research based on ICD-11 PTSD and CPTSD examined this relationship in older populations (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022). In this light, the current results add to those of a recent study among a nationally representative sample of US community-dwelling older adults between the ages of 60 and 70, showing a relationship between emotional loneliness with symptoms of ICD-11 PTSD and DSO (CPTSD) symptoms, while social loneliness was only associated with DSO symptoms (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022). The current results also support findings among treatment-seeking veterans, indicating a correlation between feelings of social isolation and loneliness with an anticipated CPTSD diagnosis (Murphy et al., Reference Murphy, Karatzias, Busuttil, Greenberg and Shevlin2021).
The present data indicated no significant differences between those with PTSD compared with those without PTSD and those with CPTSD compared with those without PTSD in terms of age or education. However, t-test analysis revealed a significant difference between the sexes, with females reporting higher PTSD and CPTSD symptoms than males. Our finding supports previous findings, showing higher rates of PTSD among women in the DSM criteria of PTSD (e.g. Olff, Reference Olff2017) and in the PTSD diagnostic criteria in the ICD-11 (e.g. McGinty et al., Reference McGinty, Fox, Ben-Ezra, Cloitre, Karatzias, Shevlin and Hyland2021). Nevertheless, in a recent study of four representative samples from the United Kingdom, the Republic of Ireland, the United States, and Israel, women met the criteria for CPTSD more than men only in the US sample (McGinty et al., Reference McGinty, Fox, Ben-Ezra, Cloitre, Karatzias, Shevlin and Hyland2021). The researchers recommend further studies on CPTSD, as data reveal inconsistent findings of sex and age differences, and perhaps even an interaction between the two (McGinty et al., Reference McGinty, Fox, Ben-Ezra, Cloitre, Karatzias, Shevlin and Hyland2021).
Additionally, our results suggest that in comparison with those suffering from CPTSD with those who do not reach the PTSD cutoff level, married older adults reported higher levels of CPTSD. This finding was unexpected as previous research focusing on the benefits of marriage reported links between marriage with better mental health, including higher life satisfaction (Fu and Noguchi, Reference Fu and Noguchi2016) and lower depression and anxiety (Purba and Fitriana, Reference Purba and Fitriana2019). Nonetheless, the current findings may be understood in light of the pandemic era, whereby researchers questioned whether being married served as a buffer to the stresses and policies foisted by COVID-19 (Purba et al., Reference Purba, Kumalasari, Novianti, Kendhawati, Noer and Ninin2021), as fear, worry, and fundamental existential survival became paramount, which may result in the loss of the essential support provided by marital bonding (Maiti et al., Reference Maiti, Singh, Innamuri and Hasija2020). Likewise, previous studies examining ICD-11 CPTSD showed mixed results with regard to relationship status, with some researchers reporting a link between CPTSD and living alone or not being married (Karatzias et al., Reference Karatzias, Shevlin, Fyvie, Hyland, Efthymiadou, Wilson, Roberts, Bisson, Brewin and Cloitre2017), while others found no differences in relationship status and CPTSD (Greenblatt‐Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt‐Kimron, Karatzias, Yonatan, Shoham, Hyland, Ben‐Ezra and Shevlin2023). Nonetheless, the current findings need to be interpreted with caution as most of the sample was married.
Altogether, the current study underscores that those suffering from trauma are at risk for adverse outcomes in the face of continuous stress, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. This is accentuated by the current study taking place during the fifth wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, with an emphasis on examining COVID-19 worries among older adults with previous trauma exposure. In this light, the result highlights the vulnerability of older adults with previous trauma in the face of global disasters. Furthermore, the current study underscores that there is a significant risk for those suffering from CPTSD during global disasters, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, distinguishing them as particularly vulnerable.
The present study has limitations. First, due to the cross-sectional nature of the study causality cannot be inferred. Second, the data were collected through a Web-based online survey company and may be biased toward older adults with high education and technological skills. Third, the study was based on self-report questionnaires, which may limit the ability to generalize the findings. Fourth, a major limitation of the study is that the PTSD and CPTSD groups are very small; therefore, caution should be given in generalizing the results. Future studies examining PTSD and CPTSD among the older population during global crises are thus recommended. Fifth, we did not measure participants’ exposure level to COVID-19. Finally, there are no data regarding response rates, limiting the finding’s generalizability.
Conclusions
Despite the above limitations, the present study is among the first to examine ICD-11 PTSD and CPSTD among older adults, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic. These findings have theoretical and practical implications for the risk factors associated with PTSD and CPTSD in the older population during the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as other natural disasters. Theoretically, the findings enhance previous results by revealing the relationships between increased exposure to trauma, COVID-19 worries, depression, and loneliness with PTSD and CPTSD. The findings underscore that those suffering from CPTSD may be at risk and vulnerable to the adverse effects of the pandemic. Nevertheless, due to the study’s cross-sectional nature, future longitudinal studies should examine directionality, namely whether those with CPTSD suffer more from the pandemic, or whether the pandemic exacerbates their conditions. Overall, the current study adds to the existing knowledge concerning the adverse outcomes of pandemics on the mental health of older adults by underscoring the association between COVID-19 worries with higher levels of PTSD and CPTSD among those exposed to a traumatic event before the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. As the development of suitable interventions for the treatment of PTSD, particularly for CPTSD, is necessary for older adults (Fox et al., Reference Fox, Hyland, Coogan, Cloitre and McHugh Power2022), specifically in the context of ongoing global natural and man-made disasters, future studies are recommended to examine the directionality of this relationship and its contribution to mental health among older adults during global crises and catastrophes.
On a practical level, the findings offer preliminary support for suitable interventions for older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic, aimed at reducing health worries. In particular, the findings add to previous data (Greenblatt-Kimron et al., Reference Greenblatt-Kimron, Ring, Hoffman, Shrira, Bodner and Palgi2021), which underscore the importance of identifying health worries among older adults, and more so among those with prior trauma exposure. The results support the suggestion that individuals exposed to trauma are at a heightened risk of the harmful effects of persistent stress, such as the COVID-19 pandemic (Lahav, Reference Lahav2020). Significantly, the study underscores that older adults suffering from CPTSD are particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of global disasters. In this light, preventive interventions for adverse mental outcomes should be tailored for older adults, with extra consideration for extended treatment protocols specific for CPTSD, due to the higher number and types of symptoms and the increased functional impairment (Karatzias et al., Reference Karatzias, Shevlin, Fyvie, Hyland, Efthymiadou, Wilson, Roberts, Bisson, Brewin and Cloitre2017).
Open peer review
To view the open peer review materials for this article, please visit http://doi.org/10.1017/gmh.2023.42.
Data availability statement
Not available to ensure participants’ confidentiality.
Author contribution
Lee Greenblatt-Kimron and Yuval Palgi provided substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; acquired, analyzed, and interpreted the data. Lee Greenblatt-Kimron drafted the data. Lee Greenblatt-Kimron, Menachem Ben-Ezra, Maayan Shacham, Yaira Hamama-Raz, and Yuval Palgi3 revised the manuscript critically for important intellectual content. Lee Greenblatt-Kimron, Menachem Ben-Ezra, Maayan Shacham, Yaira Hamama-Raz, and Yuval Palgi3 approved the final version of the article to be published. Lee Greenblatt-Kimron, Menachem Ben-Ezra, Maayan Shacham, Yaira Hamama-Raz, and Yuval Palgi3 agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.
Financial support
This study was supported by an internal research grant from Ariel University, given to Lee Greenblatt-Kimron.
Competing statement
The authors declare none.
Ethics standard
This study received ethical approval from the Ariel University IRB Committee, Number: AU-SOC-LG-20220424.
Open access
Comments
April 9, 2023
Professor Gary Belkin
Editor
Global Mental Health
Dear Professor Belkin,
We herewith submit our paper entitled “Factors associated with ICD-11 posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and complex PTSD among older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic" for consideration for publication in your journal, Global Mental Health.
We declare that the contents of this manuscript have not been copyrighted or published previously and are not under consideration for publication elsewhere.
The contents of this manuscript will not be copyrighted, submitted or published elsewhere while acceptance by the journal is under consideration.
Sincerely,
Lee Greenblatt-Kimron, Menachem Ben-Ezra, Maayan Shacham, Yaira Hamama-Raz & Yuval Palgi
Corresponding Author:
Lee Greenblatt-Kimron
School of Social Work, Ariel University, Ariel, Israel University.
E-mail: [email protected]