Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T15:28:09.216Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Immediate Injury Deaths Related to the Remnants From Hurricane Ida in New York City, September 1-2, 2021

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 April 2024

Ariel Yuan*
Affiliation:
Bureau of Environmental Surveillance and Policy, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, New York, NY, USA
Ariel Spira-Cohen
Affiliation:
Bureau of Environmental Surveillance and Policy, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, New York, NY, USA
Carolyn Olson
Affiliation:
Bureau of Environmental Surveillance and Policy, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, New York, NY, USA
Kathryn Lane
Affiliation:
Bureau of Environmental Surveillance and Policy, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, New York, NY, USA
*
Corresponding author: Ariel Yuan; Email: [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The remnants from Hurricane Ida in September 2021 caused unprecedented rainfall and inland flooding in New York City (NYC) and resulted in many immediate deaths. We reviewed death records (electronic death certificates and medical examiner reports) to systematically document the circumstances of death and demographics of decedents to inform injury prevention and climate adaptation actions for future extreme precipitation events. There were 14 Ida-related injury deaths in NYC, of which 13 (93%) were directly caused by Ida, and 1 (7%) was indirectly related. Most decedents were Asian (71%) and foreign-born (71%). The most common circumstance of death was drowning in unregulated basement apartments (71%). Themes that emerged from the death records review included the suddenness of flooding, inadequate exits, nighttime risks, and multiple household members were sometimes affected. These deaths reflect interacting housing and climate crises, and their disproportionate impact on disadvantaged populations needing safe and affordable housing. Climate adaptation actions, such as improving stormwater management infrastructure, informing residents about flood risk, implementing Federal Emergency Management Agency recommendations to make basements safer, and expanding emergency notification measures can mitigate risk. As climate change increases extreme precipitation events, multi-layered efforts are needed to keep residents safe.

Type
Report from the Field
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Society for Disaster Medicine and Public Health, Inc

Hurricane Ida made landfall as a Category 4 hurricane in Louisiana on August 29, 2021, downgrading to a post-tropical storm when it hit New York City (NYC) the night of September 1, 2021. 1,2 The National Weather Service issued NYC’s first-ever flash flood emergency declaration at 9:28 pm that evening. 2 City officials declared a state of emergency and issued a travel ban at 11:45 pm. The Ida Remnants Cloudburst (sometimes referred to as “Hurricane Ida” or “Ida”) marked a historic event for NYC, an urban area that has faced coastal flooding, but had not yet experienced inland flooding to the extent caused by Ida. Reference Lane, Charles-Guzman and Wheeler3,Reference Seil, Spira-Cohen and Marcum4 Nine inches of rainfall were recorded, with a record-breaking 3.5 inches/hour of maximum rainfall in some areas, exceeding NYC’s sewer capacity of 1.75 inches/hour. 1,2 The storm resulted in many immediate injury deaths. We reviewed death records identified by the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s (DOHMH) Office of Vital Statistics to systematically collect and document the circumstances of death and demographics of NYC decedents to inform injury prevention and climate adaptation actions for future extreme precipitation events.

Methods

We examined immediate injury deaths, defined as external-cause deaths of unintentional manner, from September 1-2, 2021, in NYC. This case definition was chosen because the NYC Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (OCME) investigates all external-cause deaths, thus providing detailed information (eg, circumstances of death) on these cases. Intentional injury deaths (suicide or homicide) were not assessed due to differing potential prevention pathways.

We used death data from 2 sources: (1) NYC DOHMH’s Office of Vital Statistics electronic death certificate data; and (2) NYC OCME records data—death certificates; case worksheets; investigation, autopsy, and toxicology reports. The NYC DOHMH’s Office of Vital Statistics provided death certificate data on immediate injury deaths from its mortality surveillance system, identified by ICD-10 and text searches. Death records were searched for unintentional external cause of death ICD-10 codes (V01-X59). Text fields for injury and cause of death were searched for injury mechanisms known to be storm-related, and used in a NYC DOHMH review of injury deaths from Hurricane Sandy Reference Seil, Spira-Cohen and Marcum4 : drowning, asphyxiation, suffocation, electrocution, hypothermia, carbon monoxide or other gas poisonings, struck/crushed by blunt object, motor vehicle crash or collision related to road conditions, cut/puncture, and fire/burn.

We developed an abstraction form based on Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidance to collect detailed information from OCME records. 5 We reviewed OCME records for all deaths identified by ICD-10 code and text searches to determine connection to Ida, assign injury mechanism, and assess circumstances of death and other risk factors. Following criteria developed by Combs et al., Reference Combs, Quenemoen and Parrish6 an approach consistent with CDC guidance, 7 deaths were categorized as directly caused by Ida (ie, caused by environmental forces of the event and direct consequences of these forces), indirectly caused (ie, caused by unsafe or unhealthy conditions because of loss or disruption of usual services, personal loss, or lifestyle disruption), or unrelated.

To assess building characteristics for deaths occurring at home, we matched NYC Department of City Planning’s land use and building data to these death records by geocoded addresses. Death data and building characteristics were summarized in frequency tables and circumstances of death were reviewed in detail to identify shared themes. This research protocol was determined to be exempt by NYC DOHMH’s Institutional Review Board.

Results

Sixteen deaths were identified by the death record search from September 1-2, 2021. After reviewing the circumstances of these deaths, 14 were determined to be Ida-related, of which 13 (93%) were directly caused by Ida, 1 (7%) was indirectly related (Table 1), and 2 were unrelated. Most of the 14 decedents were Asian (71%), foreign-born (71%), and Queens County, NY residents (79%). All age groups were affected, with people 65 y and older (36%) most impacted.

Table 1. Demographic characteristics and circumstances of immediate injury deaths related to the remnants from Hurricane Ida, New York City (NYC), September 1-2, 2021

a Data source: NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s Office of Vital Statistics death certificate data.

b Data source: NYC Office of the Chief Medical Examiner records.

c Injury that occurred without intent to cause harm, also known as “accident”.

d Direct deaths are caused by environmental forces of the hurricane and direct consequences of these forces. Indirect deaths are caused by unsafe or unhealthy conditions because of loss or disruption of usual services, personal loss, or lifestyle disruption.

e Of the 14 Ida-related deaths, 10 (71%) drowning deaths occurred in unregulated (ie, cannot be lawfully occupied) basement apartments.

Of the 13 direct deaths, 11 were caused by drowning due to basement apartment flooding; 1 by drowning outdoors after falling into a body of water during the storm; and 1 by asphyxiation caused by a fire started from flooding in their motor vehicle. The indirect death was caused by a fall that occurred while the decedent was moving a large item out of a flooded basement.

Time of injury, available in 2 records, was between 11 pm (September 1) and 12 am (September 2). Time of death, which could be when decedent was found, ranged from 12 am to 7 pm on September 2 for all 14 decedents; most (n = 8) of the drowning deaths in basement apartments occurred between 12 am and 3 am.

The most common place of injury was the home, in the basement, with 12 deaths across 7 homes. Six homes were basement apartments, of which 5 were unregulated (ie, cannot be lawfully occupied) according to the NYC Department of Buildings Reference Haag and Bromwich8,9 ; 1 death occurred in the basement of a larger home (Table 2). Six basements were in 1-to-4-family, low-rise buildings; 1 was in a 50+ unit, high-rise building. Most basements were in older buildings built before 1938 (n = 3) or between 1938-1977 (n = 3) and in standalone (detached or semi-attached) buildings (n = 5). The 4 homes with basement grade information available had full, below-grade basements (basement is 75% or more of the first-floor area with walls that are fully submerged or less than 4 feet on at least 3 sides above grade).

Table 2. Building characteristics of homes with residential injury deaths related to the remnants from Hurricane Ida, New York City (NYC), September 1-2, 2021

a Data source: NYC Office of the Chief Medical Examiner records.

b Five of the 6 basement apartments were unregulated (ie, cannot be lawfully occupied), according to NYC Department of Buildings. Reference Haag and Bromwich8,9

c Data source: NYC Department of City Planning land use and building characteristics data.

d Basement is 75% or more of the first-floor area with walls that are fully submerged or less than 4 feet on at least 3 sides above grade.

Only 1 decedent lived alone—an older adult who drowned in a basement apartment. One decedent had an unstable housing situation.

Overlapping themes emerged from the OCME records review of the 11 decedents who drowned in basement apartments. All 11 decedents experienced 1 or more of the following themes (counts are not mutually exclusive): (1) The suddenness of flooding (n = 7); (2) Individuals noticed signs of flooding, but the decedent could not be reached in time (n = 6); (3) Decedent unable to evacuate due to blocked exits (door or stairway) or flood-induced structural damage (n = 6); and (4) Emergency responders unable to easily access the basements (n = 6).

Each theme is illustrated by the following examples: (1) Family members living nearby noticed signs of flooding and went to check on 1 decedent, who was unrevivable when found. (2) Household members noticed basement flooding and woke up the sleeping decedent. The decedent could not open the door due to the water pressure, and household members could not assist because the stairway exit was impassable due to flooding. The decedent was pronounced dead less than an hour later. (3) Two decedents were unable to evacuate when flooding caused the house foundation to collapse, causing rapid flooding into their basement apartment. Less than an hour passed between times of injury and death. (4) A neighbor called 911 after seeing water coming from a basement and hearing people inside. Five feet of water prevented responders from entering through windows or doors. In another basement apartment, responders had to remove metal bars from the only window to access the decedents—the only door was blocked by household items. Draining was required to access decedents in both households.

Discussion

Fourteen people died due to inland flooding caused by Ida’s extreme rainfall in NYC. Most decedents were individuals of color, primarily foreign-born and Asian New Yorkers. The most common circumstance of death was drowning in unregulated basement apartments.

Flooding occurred rapidly in basement apartments during the night—when decedents were home—with little time to evacuate. Records indicate how quickly flooding overtook people and, in several cases, decedents were actively trying to evacuate and could not escape. In at least 1 case, the decedent was sleeping. In both cases with injury time available, deaths occurred before the state of emergency declaration, which also lacked basement-specific safety messaging. Many decedents spoke limited English. 10 The circumstances of these Ida-related deaths illustrate the importance of issuing early weather and basement-specific warnings in multiple languages, as well as installing basement flood alarms to mitigate risk for residents who are sleeping or have not yet noticed signs of flooding (if any).

Apartments more than 50% subgrade are at higher flood risk and are, by definition, unregulated in NYC. 11,12 They often lack adequate egress (exits). 11 Estimates suggest that at least 100,000 New Yorkers live in unregulated basements, although getting an accurate census of this population is difficult. Reference Sheth and Neuwirth13 NYC lacks enough affordable housing and has extremely expensive housing costs—half of the city’s renter households face rent burden, spending more than 30% of income on rent. 14 Many New Yorkers do not have access to safe and affordable housing options other than unregulated basement apartments, which are disproportionately located in rent-burdened communities of color where 1-to-4 family homes comprise most of the building stock. Reference Afridi and Morris15 Severe flooding is a fatality risk in other cities experiencing affordable housing crises where residents live in basements—in Seoul, South Korea, 4 people drowned in basement apartments following extreme rainfall in 2022. Reference Mackenzie16

Details on the deaths from Ida reinforce the importance of ensuring safe conditions in basements. Implementing recommendations from Federal Emergency Management Agency’s NYC study on building damage from Ida, such as modifications to improve egress from basements or keep surface flooding out, can provide safer basement conditions. 17 The recommendations also address reinforcing basement walls in older buildings—the 2 deaths associated with a collapsed foundation occurred in a building built before the 1938 NYC Building Code 18 required reinforced walls.

As climate change increases extreme precipitation events, NYC will experience more frequent inland flooding. 19 Climate adaptation actions such as increasing sewer capacity, installing green and blue infrastructure, and informing residents about flood risk can mitigate risk. Green (eg, rain gardens, permeable pavements) and blue (eg, bluebelts) infrastructure are stormwater management strategies that use or mimic natural systems to collect stormwater from impervious surfaces (eg, streets, sidewalks), reduce stormwater stress on NYC’s sewer system, and, as a result, reduce inland flooding. 20,21 Informing New Yorkers about flood risk can also help residents understand and prepare for this risk.

This review has several limitations. It may not include all deaths related to Ida because the review was limited to unintentional external-cause deaths from September 1-2, 2021. Event details leading up to the death were not always available in the records so themes and other circumstances may be undercounted (eg, number of decedents sleeping) or not recorded in the records (eg, health conditions that impact the ability to safely leave or avoid hazardous conditions). It was outside the scope of this review to assess non-external (natural) cause deaths from delays or disruptions of medical care or estimate statistical increases in morbidity or mortality at the population level (ie, excess morbidity or mortality).

NYC DOHMH will apply the results of this review to future surveillance by creating a standardized mortality surveillance protocol for significant extreme rainfall events to improve data collection and review processes. To inform injury prevention, storm abstraction forms will have additional standardized fields for relevant housing conditions, such as residing in a basement; whether the decedent was sleeping; or conditions that may affect decedent’s ability to safely leave or avoid hazardous conditions, including mobility impairing or other health conditions associated with storm-related mortality. Reference Yari, Ostadtaghizadeh and Ardalan22 Future mortality reviews could expand in scope with a longer time period post-event and a broader case definition by including intentional injury.

Conclusions

Ida’s extreme rainfall in NYC inequitably impacted foreign-born and Asian residents who lived in mostly unregulated basement apartments. These deaths reflect interacting housing and climate crises, and their disproportionate impact on disadvantaged populations. Reference Negret, Blackburn and Barrios23 Given NYC’s affordable housing crisis, people will continue to live in unregulated basements. Investments in safe and affordable housing are needed to reduce the number of people exposed to basement flash flooding. Climate adaptation actions, such as improving stormwater management infrastructure, informing residents about flood risk, and implementing Federal Emergency Management Agency recommendations to make basements safer can reduce inland flooding exposure. Emergency notification measures that reach basement residents, including those with limited English, can mitigate risk. As climate change increases extreme precipitation events, multi-layered efforts are needed to keep residents safe.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank our colleagues Wenhui Li, Subhani Gurung, and Kacie Seil at the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s (DOHMH) Office of Vital Statistics for providing the death certificate data, the NYC Office of Chief Medical Examiner for providing access to the medical examiner records, as well as our colleagues Melissa Umberger, Heather Roiter, Ahmad Shaibani, and Jason Phillips at NYC Emergency Management, and Erika Poulsen, Sarah Johnson, and Kazuhiko Ito at the NYC DOHMH’s Bureau of Environmental Surveillance and Policy. We gratefully acknowledge these colleagues for their critical input and support on this work.

Author contributions

Ariel Yuan and Kathryn Lane contributed to the conceptualization and design of the study and data collection. Kathryn Lane oversaw implementation. Ariel Yuan wrote the first draft and analyzed data. All authors contributed to interpretation of study results, as well as writing, editing, and reviewing of this article.

Funding statement

Not applicable.

Competing interests

None.

Ethical standards

Not applicable.

References

NYC Office of Management and Budget. NYC Community Development Block Grant Disaster Recovery Hurricane Ida Action Plan. 2022. Accessed June 12, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/cdbgdr/documents/Executive_Summary.pdf Google Scholar
National Weather Service New York, NY. Post Tropical Depression Ida. Accessed May 2, 2023. https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/2bb3162ec37e43e791020d9d8f093bbf Google Scholar
Lane, K, Charles-Guzman, K, Wheeler, K, et al. Health effects of coastal storms and flooding in urban areas: a review and vulnerability assessment. J Environ Public Health. 2013;2013:913064. doi: 10.1155/2013/913064 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Seil, K, Spira-Cohen, A, Marcum, J. Injury deaths related to Hurricane Sandy, New York City, 2012. Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2016;10(3):378-385. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2016.36 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Death scene investigation after natural disaster or other weather-related events. 2017. https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/hsb/disaster/docs/DisasterDeathSceneToolkit-P.pdf Google Scholar
Combs, DL, Quenemoen, LE, Parrish, RG, et al. Assessing disaster-attributed mortality: development and application of a definition and classification matrix. Int J Epidemiol. 1999;28(6):1124-1129. doi: 10.1093/ije/28.6.1124 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
National Center for Health Statistics. A reference guide for certification of deaths in the event of a natural, human-induced, or chemical/radiological disaster. 2017. Accessed October 24, 2023. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvss/vsrg/vsrg01.pdf Google Scholar
Haag, M, Bromwich, JE. Most of the apartments where New Yorkers drowned were illegal residences. The New York Times. September 3, 2021. Accessed October 27, 2023. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/03/nyregion/nyc-illegal-basement-apartment-ida.html Google Scholar
NYC Department of Buildings. Personal communication. April 4, 2023.Google Scholar
Office of the New York State Attorney General. Attorney General James Calls on National Weather Service to increase language accessibility for severe weather warnings. 2022. Accessed October 30, 2023. https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2022/attorney-general-james-calls-national-weather-service-increase-language Google Scholar
NYC Housing Preservation and Development. Housing quality/safety: basements and cellars. Accessed October 24, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/services-and-information/basement-and-cellar.page Google Scholar
NYC Comptroller’s Office. Bringing basement apartments into the light. 2022. Accessed October 31, 2023. https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/bringing-basement-apartments-into-the-light/ Google Scholar
Sheth, R, Neuwirth, R. New York’s housing underground: a refuge and resource. 2021. Accessed October 30, 2023. https://prattcenter.net/uploads/0520/1589551661187062/Housing_Underground.pdf Google Scholar
NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development. 2021 New York City housing and vacancy survey selected initial findings. 2022. Accessed June 26, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/hpd/downloads/pdfs/services/2021-nychvs-selected-initial-findings.pdf Google Scholar
Afridi, L, Morris, R. New York’s housing underground: 13 years later. 2021. Accessed October 30, 2023. https://prattcenter.net/uploads/1021/1634833975615756/Pratt_Center_New_Yorks_Housing_Undergound_13_Years_Later_102121.pdf Google Scholar
Mackenzie, J. Seoul floods: at least eight dead amid heaviest rain in decades. BBC News. August 9, 2022. Accessed October 30, 2023. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-62462275 Google Scholar
Federal Emergency Management Agency. Hurricane Ida NYC Mitigation Assessment Team Technical Report. 2023. Accessed July 14, 2023. https://www.fema.gov/emergency-managers/risk-management/building-science/disaster-support Google Scholar
NYC Department of Buildings. 1938 Building Code §C26-391. Accessed October 30, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/buildings/building_code/1938BC_ARTICLE9.pdf Google Scholar
NYC Department of Environmental Protection. New York City Stormwater Flood Maps. Accessed October 24, 2023. https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/6f4cc60710dc433585790cd2b4b5dd0e Google Scholar
NYC Department of Environmental Protection. Green infrastructure. 2023. Accessed October 24, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/site/dep/water/green-infrastructure.page Google Scholar
NYC Department of Environmental Protection. The Bluebelt Program. 2023. Accessed October 24, 2023. https://www.nyc.gov/site/dep/water/the-bluebelt-program.page Google Scholar
Yari, A, Ostadtaghizadeh, A, Ardalan, A, et al. Risk factors of death from flood: findings of a systematic review. J Environ Health Sci Eng. 2020;18(2):1643-1653. doi: 10.1007/s40201-020-00511-x CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Negret, M, Blackburn, J, Barrios, V. Preventing another Ida: stormwater management and basement apartments in Central Queens. 2022. Accessed March 11, 2024. https://rpa.org/work/reports/hurricane-ida-stormwater-management-queens#overview Google Scholar
Figure 0

Table 1. Demographic characteristics and circumstances of immediate injury deaths related to the remnants from Hurricane Ida, New York City (NYC), September 1-2, 2021

Figure 1

Table 2. Building characteristics of homes with residential injury deaths related to the remnants from Hurricane Ida, New York City (NYC), September 1-2, 2021