To the Editor—Central-line–associated bloodstream infections (CLABSIs) result in roughly 28,000 preventable deaths each year at an average cost of $45,814 per infection. Reference Zimlichman, Henderson and Tamir1 Central-line bundles have been shown to achieve zero CLABSIs. Reference Gupta, Thomas and Patel2 The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidelines recommend dressings impregnated with chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) for patients aged ≥18 years to protect the site of insertion due to their effectiveness in preventing CLABSI. Reference Talbot, Stone, Irwin, Overholt, Dasti and Kallen3,Reference Timsit, Schwebel and Bouadma4
Our hospital reported no cases of CLABSI for 18 months between April 2019 and November 2020. However, from November 2020 to March 2021, we encountered at least 1 CLABSI each month for a total of 7 CLABSIs in this 5-month period. This report describes our investigation into the outbreak and its principal findings, which were largely related to changes in the use of CHG-impregnated dressings.
Methods
Infection preventionists at the Veterans Health Administration Nebraska-Western Iowa Health Care System Omaha Veterans Affairs Medical Center used the National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) CLABSI definition to conduct a retrospective chart review of patients with CLABSI amid the COVID-19 pandemic. They also interviewed relevant hospital staff. The data collected from the investigation included the line insertion date, date of bacteremia detection, species and susceptibility of organism, location of the patient, healthcare provider who had inserted the central line, and the physician and nursing staff responsible for the patient.
Results
The first case of CLABSI in the outbreak (Table 1) was detected in November 2020. Prior to that, no CLABSI had occurred since April 2019.
Table 1. Listing of Cases of Central-Line-Associated Bloodstream Infections
Note. TMP-SMX, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole.
a Indicates intermediate susceptibility.
The cases of CLABSI were associated with different microorganisms. Although 3 patients had COVID-19, none had been placed in the prone position. In February 2021, a nurse performing central-line dressing care noted that a CHG disc was not present at the insertion site. Further investigation revealed deviations in nursing training, documentation, and standard practices in central-line dressing care. The semiannual in-person nursing competency training sessions, which had included central-line dressing care, had continued through October 2019, but subsequently had been paused because of social-distancing concerns. The hospital had streamlined inpatient nursing documentation in March 2020 in anticipation of a new electronic health record and to reduce workload due to COVID-19 demands. Specifically, the streamlined documentation was less explicit regarding central-line care. Before November 2020, CHG-impregnated discs were included in central-line kits. Subsequently, new kits without these discs were used.
A weekly audit of dressing care began in March 2021. Among the changes made then was the reintroduction of CHG-impregnated discs in the central-line kits. No CLABSIs were identified in April 2021 nor the subsequent 7 months.
Notably, the number of patients hospitalized in the Omaha area with COVID-19 during this 5-month period peaked at 450 patients in November 2020 and decreased to ∼75 patients in March 2021. At times nursing staff were deployed to inpatient units with which they were unfamiliar, but patient:nurse staffing ratios did not change.
Discussion
Multiple factors might have contributed to an outbreak of CLABSIs in a hospital that had experienced none in the 18 months before November 2020. These factors include the introduction of central-line insertion kits that omitted CHG-impregnated discs; the presence of these discs was meant to act as a reminder for their use in central-line care. Reference Drews, Bakdash and Gleed5
Several randomized controlled trials have provided evidence that CHG dressings reduce the risk of central-line infection. Reference Timsit, Schwebel and Bouadma4 The omission of CHG conceivably may have contributed to the outbreak, especially given that the reintroduction of CHG in central-line kits in March 2021 was temporally associated with the cessation of CLABSIs.
Also, changes in health record documentation practice may have had unintended consequences of omitting components that serve to remind nurses of elements of central-line care. Because of the desire to minimize face-to-face contact, competency training which had been held in a large open room with multiple stations had been omitted, possibly at the cost of losing reinforcement of nursing skills. The first cases of the outbreak occurred at a peak of COVID-19 hospitalizations in Omaha. However, the hypothesis that the increased workload due to COVID-19 triggered the outbreak is not supported by its persistence into March 2021, at which point the number of COVID-19 patients hospitalized in Omaha was greatly reduced.
One hospital system has reported an increase in CLABSI rates >50% associated with the pandemic. Reference Fakih, Bufalino and Sturm6 Others have noted that prone positioning of COVID-19 patients interfered with regular inspections and ready access to central-line sites, compromising their care and increasing the frequency of CLABSI. Reference Stifter, Sermersheim and Ellsworth7 However, none of the patients had been placed in the prone position. Other hospitals reported an increase in CLABSIs secondary to changes in infection prevention protocol among nurses to reduce the frequency of contact with patients and to combat the shortage of PPE and supplies during the COVID-19 pandemic. Reference Patel, Weiner-Lastinger and Dudeck8
In contrast to our experience, some hospitals reported that the rate of CLABSI and other healthcare-associated infections decreased significantly due to stricter precautions put in place due to COVID-19. Reference Heidempergher, Sabiu, Orani, Tripepi and Gallieni9
The Swiss cheese model of error prevention hypothesizes that undesirable events occur when multiple measures intended to prevent errors are simultaneously compromised. Reference Reason10 In the face of COVID-19, this outbreak developed at a time that at least 3 separate barriers were compromised, which may be consistent with the Swiss cheese model.
Our conclusions have limitations. First, we do not know whether CHG discs were absent in all the CLABSI patients. However, we suspect that was the case. Several factors may have led to less use of discs during the ouotbreak, and efforts to reinforce the importance of discs were associated with termination of the outbreak. Second, changes in nursing staff deployment might explain the occurrence of the outbreak. Nonetheless, even though the number of patients hospitalized in Omaha with COVID-19 during the outbreak period decreased, the outbreak persisted for five months.
Acknowledgments
Financial support
No financial support was provided relevant to this article.
Conflicts of interest
All authors report no conflicts of interest relevant to this letter.
