Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T03:04:38.901Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Doctors' poor knowledge of nutritional supplementation in acutely unwell patients: no wonder recovery is slow!

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 April 2010

M. I. Butt
Affiliation:
Diabetes Centre, Southmead Hospital, Monks Park Avenue, Bristol BS10 5NB, UK
Katherine Barker
Affiliation:
Southmead Hospital, Monks Park Avenue, Bristol BS10 5NB, UK
Lynn Sawyer
Affiliation:
Southmead Hospital, Monks Park Avenue, Bristol BS10 5NB, UK
Andrew Johnson
Affiliation:
Southmead Hospital, Monks Park Avenue, Bristol BS10 5NB, UK
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Abstract
Copyright
Copyright © The Authors 2009

Aims: To assess the understanding of use of nutritional supplements by doctors.

Hypothesis: Doctors know when to appropriately prescribe nutritional supplements, when to discontinue their use and which supplements are clinically indicated.

Methods: We circulated the nutritional assessment questionnaire to all doctors irrespective of their grades working in our hospital through their hospital email addresses, distributing it at the grand round and journal club meetings.

Results: Sixty responses were received from a total of 132 giving a response rate of 46%. These included foundation year one (n=14, 23.33%), foundation year two (n=8, 13.33%), senior house officers (n=15, 25%), specialist registrars (n=14, 23.33%) and consultants (n=9, 15%). Twenty percent (n=12) of these responses were from geriatricians, 10% (n=6) from Endocrinologists, 6.67% (n=4) from Cardiologists, 5% (n=3) from Nephrologists and Respiratory physicians each and 53.33% (n=32) collectively from surgical, orthopaedics, haematology and ENT. Eighty-five percent (n=51) of doctors regularly prescribed nutritional supplements to acutely admitted hospitalised patients. On a scale of ten, with ten being very important, all the doctors rated the nutritional status of hospitalised patients as important in their clinical management (average score 9.1/10). A majority of 90% (n=46) prescribed Fortisip supplements and one-quarter of these doctors prescribed three supplements drinks per patient per day. Twenty-five percent of doctors (n=15) prescribed Fortijuce with twice daily dosing as the most popular prescription (47%). Eight percent (n=5) prescribed Ensure, which is a non-stock product. Thirteen percent of doctors could correctly identify the calorie content of the Fortisip, and 2% doctors were able to identify its protein content. None knew the macronutrients of Calshake or Calogen. Only 7% (n=4) of the doctors prescribed nutritional supplements following advice from a dietician. Poor dietary intake (85%, n=51), low albumin (65%, n=39) and evidence of weight loss (60%, n=36) were the most common reasons for prescription. Supplements were stopped following improved dietary intake (78.3%, n=47), patient's refusal (55%, n=33), albumin normalizing (28%, n=17) and dietician advice (3%, n=2). Seventy two percent of the participants (n=43) felt the need for further education to understand the nutritional needs of acutely ill patients.

Summary and conclusions: We identified that majority of doctors (93.77%) were prescribing the nutritional supplements without any prior discussions with the specialist dietician. Overwhelming majority did not know the caloric value and protein content of the prescribed supplements but were still prescribing them without the specialist dietician advice. Twenty percent of the doctors were prescribing Fortisip at a dose higher than the recommended daily dose. Majority of the participants felt further education about nutritional needs of patients.