Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T19:30:24.588Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“A BEAUTIFUL TRANSLATION FROM A VERY IMPERFECT ORIGINAL”: MABEL WOTTON, AESTHETICISM, AND THE DILEMMA OF LITERARY BORROWING

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 September 2009

Sigrid Anderson Cordell
Sigrid Anderson Cordell*
Affiliation:
Harvard University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In a pivotal moment in Mabel Wotton's short story, “The Fifth Edition” (1896), Janet Suttaby, a struggling writer unable to find a publisher for her novel, offers the rising literary star, Franklyn Leyden, her manuscript, telling him, “If you really think there is any good in it . . . it must either go back to the drawer until I have time to polish it, or . . . you must take it” (179). Miss Suttaby offers almost no explanation for her act, nor does she outline what she expects Leyden to do with the manuscript, so when Leyden accepts, re-writes, and then publishes it under his own name, he hasn't done anything that she has explicitly forbidden. Nevertheless, his appropriation of her work is clearly marked in the text as ethically compromised, especially when Miss Suttaby's subsequent death from starvation underscores her desperate need for the money that the sale of a novel would have brought. At the same time, the text offers a much more nuanced critique of Leyden's actions that reaches beyond the ethics of plagiarism and into the realm of literary invention itself; as Leyden revises the manuscript, his creative act is bound up with a parasitical translation of Miss Suttaby herself into text, and he is thus implicated as a fraud on the grounds of both literal and figurative appropriation. In this way, the appropriated manuscript becomes a metaphor for the uneasy relationship between art and life, a concern that is central to fin-de-siècle literary culture. As I will argue, the emphasis in this story, and elsewhere in Wotton's fiction, on what Susan Sontag has termed in another context the “shady commerce between art and truth” (6) makes visible concerns about the connection between inspiration and invention that emerge in the aesthetic theories of Pater, Wilde, and James, as well as in debates over plagiarism and New Woman fiction.

Type
Research Article
Information
Victorian Literature and Culture , Volume 37 , Issue 2 , September 2009 , pp. 427 - 445
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

WORKS CITED

Ardis, Ann. New Women, New Novels: Feminism and Early Modernism. New Brunswick: Rutgers UP, 1990.Google Scholar
Arnold, Matthew. Essays in Criticism. London: Macmillan, 1869.Google Scholar
B., W. “Does the Reciter Feel His Part?: A Study of Realism.” Werner's Voice Magazine (Nov. 1891): 300.Google Scholar
Benson, E. F. “Plagiarism.” The Nineteenth Century 46 (Dec. 1899): 974–81.Google Scholar
Case, Alison. Plotting Women: Gender and Narration in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth-Century British Novel. Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 1999.Google Scholar
Colby, Vineta. Vernon Lee: A Literary Biography. Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 2003.Google Scholar
Cotterell, George. “New Novels.” The Academy 1151(26 May 1894): 433–34.Google Scholar
Dixon, Ella Hepworth. “As I Knew Them”: Sketches of People I Have Met on the Way. London: Hutchinson, 1930.Google Scholar
Edel, Leon. “Henry James and Vernon Lee.” PMLA 69.3 (June 1954): 677–78.Google Scholar
Egerton, George [Mary Chavelita Dunne Clairmonte Bright]. “A Keynote to Keynotes.” Ten Contemporaries: Notes Toward Their Definitive Bibliography. Ed. Gawsworth, John. London: E. Benn, 1932. 57–60.Google Scholar
“The Ethics of Plagiarism.” Pall Mall Gazette (30 Mar. 1887): 3.Google Scholar
Fleissner, Jennifer L. “Dictation Anxiety: The Stenographer's Stake in Dracula.” Nineteenth-Century Contexts 22 (2000): 417–55.Google Scholar
Freedman, Jonathan. Professions of Taste: Henry James, British Aestheticism, and Commodity Culture. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1990.Google Scholar
Gagnier, Regenia. Idylls of the Marketplace: Oscar Wilde and the Victorian Public. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1986.Google Scholar
Gardner, Burdett. “An Apology for Henry James's ‘Tiger Cat.’” PMLA 68.4 (Sep. 1953): 688–95.Google Scholar
Heilmann, Ann. New Woman Fiction: Women Writing First-Wave Feminism. New York: St. Martin's, 2000.Google Scholar
James, Henry. “The Art of Fiction.” Longman's Magazine 23 (Sept. 1884): 502–21.Google Scholar
James, Henry. Letter to H. G. Wells. 29 Jan. 1900. Henry James: Letters. Ed. Edel, Leon. Vol. 4. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1982.Google Scholar
James, Henry. The Novels and Tales of Henry James: New York Edition. Vol. 5. The Princess Casamassima. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1908.Google Scholar
Lang, Andrew. “Literary Plagiarism.” The Contemporary Review 51 (1887): 831–40.Google Scholar
Licht, Merete. “Henry James's Portrait of a Lady: Vernon Lee in The Princess Casamassima.” A Literary Miscellany Presented to Eric Jacobsen. Ed. Caie, Graham and Nørgaard, Holger. Copenhagen: U of Copenhagen, 1988. 285–303.Google Scholar
“Literary and Art Notes, Etc.” Pall Mall Gazette (15 April 1887): 3.Google Scholar
Macfarlane, Robert. Original Copy: Plagiarism and Originality in Nineteenth-Century Literature. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2007.Google Scholar
McCann, Andrew. “Rosa Praed and the Vampire-Aesthete.” Victorian Literature and Culture 35 (2007): 175–87.Google Scholar
Moore, George. Confessions of a Young Man. New York: Brentano's, 1917. Google Books. Web. 20 Jan. 2009.Google Scholar
“Mr. Punch's Manual for Young Reciters.” Punch 92 (5 Mar. 1887): 109.Google Scholar
Nelsen, Carolyn Christensen, ed. A New Woman Reader: Fiction, Articles, Drama of the 1890s. Ontario: Broadview, 2001.Google Scholar
Pater, Walter. The Renaissance. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1986.Google Scholar
Poovey, Mary. “Forgotten Writers, Forgotten Histories: Charles Reade and the Nineteenth-Century Transformation of the British Literary Field.” ELH 71.2 (2004): 433–53.Google Scholar
Psomiades, Kathy Alexis. Beauty's Body: Femininity and Representation in British Aestheticism. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1997.Google Scholar
Reynolds, Nigel. “The Borrowers: Why Ian McEwan is No Plagiarist.” Daily Telegraph (7 Dec. 2006). Web. 24 Jan. 2007.Google Scholar
Robins, Elizabeth. Theatre and Friendship. New York: G. P. Putnam's Son, 1932.Google Scholar
Rochelson, Meri-Jane. “The Friendship of Israel Zangwill and Mabel Wotton: ‘Faithfully Yours, Margaret.’” English Literature in Translation 48.3 (2005): 305–23.Google Scholar
Saint-Amour, Paul K.The Copywrights: Intellectual Property and the Literary Imagination. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 2003.Google Scholar
Schaffer, Talia. The Forgotten Female Aesthetes: Literary Culture in Late-Victorian England. Charlottesville: UP of Virginia, 2000.Google Scholar
Schaffer, Talia. Introduction. Women and British Aestheticism. Ed. Schaffer, Talia and Alexis Psomiades, Kathy. Charlottesville: UP of Virginia, 1999. 1–22.Google Scholar
Schaffer, Talia. “Some Chapter of Some Other Story: Henry James, Lucas Malet and the Real Past of The Sense of the Past.” Henry James Review 17.2 (1996): 109–28.Google Scholar
Shafer, Jack. “What Did Ian McEwan Do? Nothing Wrong, Say the Big-Shot Novelists.” Slate (Friday, 8 Dec. 2006). Web. 24 Jan. 2007.Google Scholar
Showalter, Elaine, ed. Daughters of Decadence: Women Writers of the Fin de Siècle. New Brunswick: Rutgers UP, 1993.Google Scholar
“The Song of ‘Jess’ and How She Came by It: Mr. Rider Haggard's Explanation.” Pall Mall Gazette (19 April 1887): 5.Google Scholar
“The Song of ‘Jess’ and Who Wrote It.” Pall Mall Gazette (24 Mar. 1887): 1.Google Scholar
Sontag, Susan. On Photography. New York: Anchor/Doubleday, 1977.Google Scholar
Stetz, Margaret Diane. “Life's ‘Half-Profits’: Writers and their Readers in Fiction of the 1890s.” Nineteenth-Century Lives: Essays Presented to Jerome Hamilton Buckley. Ed. Lockridge, Laurence S., Maynard, John, and Stone, Donald. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1989. 169–87.Google Scholar
Stetz, Margaret Diane. “New Grub Street and the Woman Writer of the 1890s.” Transforming Genres: New Approaches to British Fiction of the 1890s. Ed. Manos, Nikki Lee and Rochelson, Meri-Jane. New York: St. Martin's, 1994. 21–45.Google Scholar
Stetz, Margaret Diane. “Turning Points: Mabel E. Wotton.” Turn-of-the-Century Women 3.2 (1986): 2–18.Google Scholar
“The ‘Strange Cases’ of ‘She’ and ‘Jess.’” Pall Mall Gazette (26 Mar. 1887): 3.Google Scholar
Weber, Carl. “Henry James and His Tiger Cat.” PMLA 68.4 (Sep. 1953): 672–87.Google Scholar
Whatmore, D. E.H. Rider Haggard. A Bibliography. London: Mansell, 1987.Google Scholar
“Who Is ‘She’ and Where Did ‘She’ Come From?” Pall Mall Gazette (Friday, 11 Mar. 1887): 1–2.Google Scholar
Wicke, Jennifer. “Vampiric Typewriting: Dracula and Its Media.” ELH 59.2 (Summer 1992): 467–93.Google Scholar
Wilde, Oscar. “The Critic as Artist.” Complete Works of Oscar Wilde. New York: HarperCollins, 1989. 1009–59.Google Scholar
Wilde, Oscar. “Some Literary Notes.” Rev. of Word-Portraits of Famous Writers, by Wotton, Mabel. Woman's World (Mar. 1889): 280.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. “Amongst Her Following.” Temple Bar 97 (1893): 417–23.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. “The Fifth Edition.” Day-Books. London: John Lane, 1896. 147–88.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 15 July [1896]. Central Zionist Archives A120/593.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 17 Oct. 1896. Central Zionist Archives A120/590.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 29 Mar. 190?. Central Zionist Archives A120/592.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 23 July [1900–1903]. Central Zionist Archives A120/594.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 7 Feb. [1901]. Central Zionist Archives A120/594.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. 9 Feb. [1901]. Central Zionist Archives A120/593.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. [1 Nov.] 1901. Central Zionist Archives A120/590.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Letter to Israel Zangwill. n.d. Central Zionist Archives A120/592.Google Scholar
Wotton, Mabel. Word-Portraits of Famous Writers. London: Bentley, 1887.Google Scholar
Wright, Edward. “The Art of Plagiarism.” Contemporary Review 85 (1904): 514.Google Scholar
Zorn, Christa. Vernon Lee: Aesthetics, History, and the Victorian Female Intellectual. Athens: Ohio UP, 2003.Google Scholar