Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T06:52:04.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

THE TROUBLES WITH A LOWER CASE t: UNDERGRADUATES AND BELFAST'S DIFFICULT HISTORY

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 November 2018

Sean O'Connell
Sean O'Connell*
Affiliation:
AT QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY BELFAST
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper explores the risks and rewards involved in directing undergraduate students engaged on an oral history project in Belfast. It advocates the role of oral history as a tool through which to encourage students’ engagement with research-led teaching to produce reflective assignments on the nature of historical evidence, particularly autobiographical memory. The particular challenges of conducting oral history in a city beset by ethno-sectarian divisions are discussed. This factor has ensured that the historiography of Belfast has focused extensively on conflict and violence. The city's social history is poorly understood, but employing oral history enables the exploration of issues that take undergraduate historians beyond the Troubles as a starting point. This project probed what is called the troubles with a lower case t, via an analysis of deindustrialisation and urban redevelopment in Sailortown (Belfast's dockland district). It provided evidence with which to offer a new assessment on existing historiographical discussions about working-class nostalgic memory and urban social change, one that supports those scholars that problematize attempts to categorise such memory. The testimony also differed in significant ways from previous oral history research on post-war Northern Ireland.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 28 , December 2018 , pp. 219 - 239
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For further discussion of this, see Graham Smith, Historical Insights: Focus on Research – Oral History (Coventry, [2010]), 4.

2 ‘Photography during the Northern Irish Troubles’, Ulster Museum exhibition (June – November 2017).

3 Connolly, Sean, Belfast 400: People, Place and History (Liverpool, 2012)Google Scholar.

4 Hepburn, A. C., A Past Apart: Studies in the History of Catholic Belfast 1850–1950 (Belfast, 1996)Google Scholar.

5 Munck, Ronnie and Rolston, Bill, Belfast in the Thirties: An Oral History (Belfast, 1987)Google Scholar.

6 Gray, John, City in Revolt: James Connolly and the Belfast Dock Strike of 1907 (Belfast, 1985)Google Scholar; Lynch, John, A Tale of Three Cities: Comparative Studies in Working-Class Life (Basingstoke, 1998)Google Scholar; Loughlin, C. J. V., Labour and the Politics of Disloyalty in Belfast, 1921–39 – the Moral Economy of Loyalty (Basingstoke, 2017)Google Scholar.

7 Barton, Brian, The Blitz: Belfast in the War Years (Belfast, 1990)Google Scholar.

8 Elliott, Marianne, The Catholics of Ulster (2000)Google Scholar; Elliott, Marianne, Hearthlands: A Memoir of the White City Housing Estate in Belfast (Belfast, 2017)Google Scholar.

9 Boal, Frederick W. and Royle, Steven A., Enduring City: Belfast in the Twentieth Century (Belfast, 2006)Google Scholar; Maguire, W. A., Belfast: A History (Lancaster, 2009)Google Scholar.

10 Morris, R. J., ‘Urban Ulster since 1600’, in Kennedy, Liam and Ollerenshaw, Philip, Ulster since 1600: Politics, Economy and Society (Oxford, 2013), 121–39Google Scholar.

11 A History of Irish Working-Class Writing, ed. Michael Pierse (Cambridge, 2017).

12 David Park, The Big Snow (2002); Campbell, John, The Disinherited (Belfast, 2006)Google Scholar.

13 See O'Connell, Sean, Credit, Class and Community: Working-Class Debt in the UK since 1880 (Oxford, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Interview with Mrs Rafferty (born 1904). Conducted by Sean O'Connell, 10 Oct. 2002. Where full names are used for interviewees, this is their real name. Pseudonyms are employed for interviewees that are still living. There is one exception, John Campbell, who is happy for his identity to be revealed.

15 O'Connell, Sean, The Motor Car in British Society, Class, Gender and Motoring 1896–1939 (Manchester, 1998)Google Scholar; O'Neill, Terry, Terry O'Neill's Belfast (Belfast, 1999)Google Scholar.

16 Interview with Terry O'Neill (born 1930). Conducted by Sean O'Connell, 15 Apr. 2001.

17 The Myths We Live By, ed. Raphael Samuel and Paul Thompson (1990), 9.

18 Joanna Bourke, Working-Class Cultures in Britain, 1890–1960: Class, Gender and Ethnicity (1994).

19 Waters, Chris, ‘Representations of Everyday Life: L. S. Lowry and the Landscape of Memory in Post-War Britain’, Representations, 65 (1999), 121–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Waters, C., ‘Autobiography, Nostalgia and the Changing Practices of Working-Class Self-Hood’, in Singular Continuities: Tradition, Nostalgia and Identity in Modern British Culture, ed. Behlmer, G. K. et al. (Stanford, 2000), 178–95Google Scholar.

20 Jones, Ben, ‘The Uses of Nostalgia: Autobiography, Community Publishing and Working-Class Neighbourhoods in Post-War England’, Cultural and Social History, 7 (2010), 335–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jones, Ben, The Working Class in Mid-Twentieth-Century England: Community, Identity and Social Memory (Manchester, 2012)Google Scholar.

21 Gunn, Simon, ‘The Rise and Fall of British Urban Modernism: Planning Bradford, circa 1945–1970’, Urban History, 49 (2010), 849–69Google ScholarPubMed.

22 Weiner, Ron, The Rape and Plunder of the Shankill: People and Planning (Belfast, 1976)Google Scholar.

23 Colin Coulter, Contemporary Northern Irish Society: An Introduction (1999), 88.

24 Ibid., 70.

25 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/8024702.stm.

26 Milne, Graeme, People, Place and Power on the Nineteenth-Century Waterfront: Sailortown (Basingstoke, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Lynch, A Tale of Three Cities, 35.

28 Loughlin, Labour and the Politics of Disloyalty, 79.

29 Hepburn, A Past Apart.

30 Interview with Sean H (born 1942). Interviewed 25 Mar. 2013 by Ryan Mallon.

31 Hepburn, A Past Apart, 48–54, 176–8.

32 Tin Bath Writers Co-op/Sailortown Cultural and Historical Society, Tin Baths and Mangles (Belfast, 2006); Denis Smyth, Sailortown: The Story of a Dockside Community (Belfast, n.d.).

33 Ibid., 2.

34 For those considering a similar module, reading might include Thompson, Paul and Bornat, Joanna, The Voice of the Past: Oral History (Oxford, 2017)Google Scholar; Yow, Valerie, Recording Oral History: A Guide for the Humanities and Social Sciences (Lanham, 2015)Google Scholar; Abrams, Lynn, Oral History Theory (Padstow, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Chandler, S., ‘Oral History across Generations: Age, Generational Identity and Oral Testimony’, Oral History, 33 (2005) 48–56Google Scholar; K'Myer, T. E. and Crothers, A. Glenn, ‘“If I See Some of This in Writing I Am Going to Shoot You”: Reluctant Narrators, Taboo Topics and the Ethical Dilemmas of the Oral Historian’, Oral History Review, 34 (2007), 71–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar; The Oral History Reader, ed. Rob Perks and Alistair Thomson (2016); Jessee, Erin, ‘Managing Danger in Oral History Fieldwork’, Oral History Review, 44 (2017), 322–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Bryson, Anna, ‘“Whatever You Say, Say Nothing”: Researching Memory and Identity in Mid-Ulster, 1945–1969’, Oral History, 45 (2007), 51Google Scholar.

36 Interview with John Clancy (born 1943). Interviewed by Tiarnán Ó Muilleoir, 12 Mar. 2013.

37 Interview with Mary H (born 1941). Interviewed by Francesca Owens, 25 Mar. 2013.

38 Chandler, ‘Oral History across Generations’.

39 Green, Anna, ‘Individual Memory and “Collective Memory”: Theoretical Presuppositions and Contemporary Debates’, Oral History, 32 (2004), 35–44Google Scholar.

40 Smith, Graham, ‘Beyond Individual/Collective Memory: Women's Transactive Memories of Food, Family and Conflict’, Oral History, 35 (2007), 75–90Google Scholar.

41 Interview with Kathy M (born 1933). Interviewed by Anne Donnelly, 26 Mar. 2013; Giles, Judy, ‘“Playing Hard to Get”: Working-Class Women, Sexuality and Respectability in Britain, 1918–1940’, Women's History Review, 1 (1992), 239–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Interview with John Campbell (born 1936). Interviewed by Rachel Sloan, 18 Mar. 2013; Campbell, John, Corner Kingdom (Belfast, 1999)Google Scholar; Campbell, The Disinherited.

43 Campbell, John, ‘Sailortown’, in The Rose and the Blade: New and Selected Poems (Belfast, 1997)Google Scholar. Note Sailorstown/Sailortown are both used with some claiming that Protestants are more likely to use the former.

44 Interview with Mary H.

45 Interview with Mary H, Emily H, Marie S, Briege H, and Annie G. Interviewed by Lindsay Johnston, 27 Mar. 2013.

46 Ayers, Pat, ‘The Making of Men: Masculinities in Interwar Liverpool’, in Working out Gender: Perspectives from Labour History, ed. Walsh, Margaret (Aldershot, 1999), 66–83Google Scholar.

47 Interview with Tommy M. Interviewed by Hannah McDade, 22 Mar. 2013.

48 Ibid.

49 Lynch, A Tale of Three Cities, 35. For a discussion of the issue of ethno-sectarian relations in the Belfast labour movement, see Loughlin, Labour and the Politics of Disloyalty.

50 Loughlin, Labour and the Politics of Disloyalty, 122

51 The Deindustrialized World: Confronting Ruination in Postindustrial Places, ed. Steven High, Lachlan MacKinnon and Andrew Perchard (Vancouver, 2017), 6.

52 Interview with Tommy M.

53 Jones, ‘The Uses of Nostalgia’, 358.

54 This documentary was broadcast on BBC Radio Ulster and BBC Radio 5 Live. It can be accessed on IPlayer: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05qg06b#play.

55 Critical commentary by Duncan (pseudonym), Mar. 2013.

56 T. G. Ashplant, ‘Anecdote as Narrative Resource in Working-Class Life Stories’, in Narrative and Genre: Contexts and Types of Communication, ed. M. Chamberlain and P. Thompson (1998), 99.

57 Critical commentary by Anthony (pseudonym), Mar. 2013.