¹ Kuttner, S., ‘Bernardus Compostellanus antiquus,’ Traditio 1 (1943) 280 n. 5; cf. also 285–6, 288 n. 50, 290 n. 64.Google Scholar

² Of the publications cited in the survey here given, many contain such information, Kejř, e.g. Kuttner-Rathbone, Rabotti, Weigand, Stickler, Vetulani, Fransen (‘MSS … en Espagne’). See further Gillmann, F. - Rosser, E., ‘Der Prager Codex XVII A 12 (früher I B I) und der Dekretapparat des Laurentius Hispanus ’, AKKR 126 (1953/54) 3–43 (also in Italian, SG 7 [1959] 392–445); Stickler, A. M., ‘Iter helveticum,’ this Bulletin for 1958, Trad. 14.463 (on Einsiedeln MS 193 [66]).Google Scholar

³ Only vol. 1 (pr.-C. 18 q. 2 c. 31) is listed in Repert. 37. Google Scholar

⁴ Cf. Fransen, G., ‘La date du Décret de Gratien,’ RHE 51 (1956) 531 n. 1, obiter; a full analysis of the MS has recently been sent to the Institute by Garc, A. ía; this supersedes his notice in SG 8.165–6. The texts omitted in the original abbreviatio are supplied in the margins by a slightly later 12th-cent. hand. It is out of the question that this MS could represent an early stage of the Decretum, a kind of ‘Ur-Gratian,’ as Pinedo, P. assumes (‘Decretum Gratiani: Dictum Gratiani,’ Ius canonicum 2 [1962] 160ff., with plates iv-vi).Google Scholar

⁵ The unusual division of pt. I of this MS into 61 distinctiones (Fransen, RHE 49.152, esp. 51.935–6) actually reproduces the division of the Introductio In prima parte agitur. Google Scholar

⁶ App. Ordinaturus (Bravislava 14, Munich lat. 27337, 28175, Toledo 4.5; for other MSS see Trad. 1.285 n. 33; Fransen, RHE 48.225; Stickler, Trad. 12.596; Kejř, SG 8.26, 33; Weigand, Bedingte Eheschliessung 229–31; and the Bodleian MS Lyell 41, infra). — Alanus, App. Ius naturale (Gniezno 27, Seo de Urgel 113; for MSS in general see Stickler, A. M. ‘Alanus Anglicus …,’ Salesianum 21 [1959] 348–9; Kuttner, this Bulletin for 1959, Trad. 15.499; a late copy of the prologue alone exists also in Stuttgart HB.VL95, fol. 267^r-v [paper, . an. 1457; photostat donated to the Institute by Dr. Autenrieth, J.]). — App. Animal est substantia (Liège 127E; for other MSS see Trad. 12.564, 599; 14.509). — Glossa Palatina (Munich lat. 28174). — An Apparatus by Bernard of Pavia? (Gniezno 28).Google Scholar

⁷ It should be noted that Eheim's descriptions of the Austrian MSS are not always reliable, not only as regards the recording of glosses, but also because of the omission of MSS (e.g. Innsbruck 10, Klagenfurt XXIX.a.4, Vienna ser. nova 2640) and the inclusion of the Abbreviatio in two volumes of Admont MSS 23 and 43 (given as two different MSS of Gratian, SG 7.129, 132). Google Scholar

⁸ Cf. Stickler, , Sales. 21.376; Kuttner, Trad. 15.499; on the attribution to R(otbertus) Modicipassus in Seo de Urgel MS 8 see Fransen, , Trad. 13.508–9; Kuttner, DDG 7.702.Google Scholar

⁹ The Fundación is of recent origin (ca. 1950); its vast collections of pictures, art objects, and books were assembled by the late José Lazaro Galdiano and bequeathed to the Spanish Government. No information on the provenance of any of the objects is available according to Fr. García. Google Scholar

¹⁰ Who also indicates that Saint-Mihiel 6 (Repert. loc. cit.) merely presents the Ordinaria of Barth. Brix. Google Scholar

¹¹ I am indebted to Mr. Kraus for having obtained Dr. Ludwig's permission to make his ownership known in this Bulletin. Google Scholar