No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Strategies for the Afterlife in Eighteenth-Century Malta
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
Extract
According to Protestant eschatology, the dead are no longer with us. In the forceful words of Eamon Duffy they are ‘gone beyond the reach of human contact, even of human prayer’. But if this was the most devastating change in the mind of Protestants, Catholics affirmed Tridentine teaching on the cult of the dead by an ‘obsessional multiplication’ of suffrages or intercessory prayers, especially post mortem masses. This belief was still strong in eighteenth-century Catholic Europe. Italy, Spain and south-west Germany all exhibited such religious ‘frenzy’. Only France may be cited as an example to the contrary. Michel Vovelle has successfully proved that in Provence the will became simply a legal act distributing fortunes, with no reference to the pious clauses. However, we cannot extend this thesis, as Philippe Aries has mistakenly done, to the entire Catholic West.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Studies in Church History , Volume 45: The Church, the Afterlife and the Fate of the Soul , 2009 , pp. 301 - 310
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2009
References
1 Duffy, Eamon, The Stripping of the Altars: Traditional Religion in England 1400–1580 (New Haven, CT, and London, 1992), 475 Google Scholar. For this cultural transformation, see also Koslofsky, Craig M., The Reformation of the Dead: Death and Ritual in Early Modern Germany, 1450–1700 (New York, 2000).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
2 Colapietra, R., Gli Aquilani d’antico regime davanti alla morte 1535–1780 (Rome, 1986)Google Scholar; Carroll, Michael P., Veiled Threats: The Logic of Popular Catholicism in Italy (Baltimore, MD, and London, 1996)Google Scholar, chs. 4 and 5. For Modena, see Nicassio, Susan V., ‘“For the Benefit of my Soul”: A Preliminary Study of the Persistence of Tradition in Eighteenth-Century Mass Obligations’, CathHR 78 (1992), 75–96.Google Scholar
3 Eire, Carlos M. N., From Madrid to Purgatory: The Art and Craft of Dying in Sixteenth-Century Spain (Cambridge, 1993).Google Scholar
4 Forster, Marc R., Catholic Revival in the Age of the Baroque: Religious Identity in Southwest Germany, 1550–1750 (Cambridge, 2001), 140–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
5 Vovelle, Michel, Piété baroque et déchristianisation en Provence au XVIIIe siècle (Paris, 1978), 114–19.Google Scholar
6 Ariès, Philippe, Western Attitudes towards Death: From the Middle Ages to the Present (Baltimore, MD, 1974), 64.Google Scholar
7 For wills and the religious attitudes of testators, see Hsia, R. Po-chia, ‘Civic Wills As Sources For The Study of Piety in Muenster, 1530–1618’, Sixteenth Century Journal 14 (1983), 321–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 For a detailed study of these ‘pious dispositions’, see Ciappara, Frans, ‘Intercessory Funerary Rites in Malta 1750–1797’, Nuova Rivista Storica, Anno 91 (2007), 145–71 Google Scholar. For England, see Coppel, Stephen, ‘Willmaking on the Deathbed’, Local Population Studies no. 40 (1988), 37–45.Google ScholarPubMed
9 Huizinga, J., The Waning of the Middle Ages (Harmondsworth, 1955), 140–52.Google Scholar
10 For an optimistic belief in this final hour, see Wunderli, Richard and Broce, Gerald, ‘The Final Moment before Death in Early Modern England’, Sixteenth Century Journal 20 (1989), 259–75.Google Scholar
11 Valletta, National Library, Library 48, pp. 362–67 [hereafter: NL and Libr.]
12 For this expression, see Bellarmine, Robert, ‘The Art of Dying Well’, ch. 1, in Spiritual Writings, trans, and eds Donnelly, J. P. and Teske, R. J. (Mahwah, NJ, 1989), 239–40 Google Scholar: ‘The first rule for dying well, which is that one who desires to die well should live well’.
13 Erasmus, , ‘Funus’, in Opera Omnia, 10 vols (Lyons, 1703), 1: 10 Google Scholar, cols 810–18.
14 The Catechism of the Council of Trent, trans. McHugh, John A. and Callan, Charles J. (Rockford, IL, 1982), 300–01.Google Scholar
15 Valletta, NL, Libr. 48, p. 536.
16 See his Preparation for Death, ed. Grimm, Eugene (Brooklyn, NJ, 1926), 444 Google Scholar. Note that the dead could be prayed Joras well as to. On this point, see Carroll, , Veiled Threats, 29–36.Google Scholar
17 Wzzino, F. II Purgatorio aperto alla Pietà de’ Viventi (Malta, 1766).Google Scholar
18 Valletta, Notarial Archives [hereafter: NA], Notary Tommaso Magri, 4 / 924, fol. 26r; 16 November 1728.
19 For one such incident see Mdina, Archives of the Inquisition, Malta, Proceedings 102A, fols 390r-95v [hereafter: AIM and Proc.]. On this subject, see Brown, Theo, The Fate of the Dead: A Study in Folk Eschatology in the West Country after the Reformation (Ipswich, 1979)Google Scholar; Caciola, Nancy, ‘Wraiths, Revenants and Ritual in Medieval Culture’, P&P no. 152 (August 1996), 3–45.Google Scholar
20 Lemaître, Jean-Loup, ‘La commémoration des défunts et les obituaires dans l’occident chrétien’, Revue d’Histoi re del’Églisede France 71 (1985), 131–45.Google Scholar
21 Carroll, , Veiled Threats, 125–29.Google Scholar
22 Swanson, R. N., Religion and Devotion in Europe, c. 1215-c. 1515 (Cambridge, 1995), 217–25 Google Scholar. For the granting of indulgences in return for prayers for the faithful departed, see idem, ‘Indulgences for Prayers for the Dead in the Diocese of Lincoln in the Early Four teenth Century’, JEH 52 (2001), 197–219 Google Scholar. The standard work on indulgences is idem, ed., Promissory Notes on the Treasury of Merits: Indulgences in Late Medieval Europe (Leiden and Boston, MA, 2006).Google Scholar
23 Floriana, Archbishop’s Palace, Archiepiscopal Archives, Malta, Registram Supplicationes 8, fols 49v-50r [hereafter: AAM and RS].
24 Black, Christopher C., Italian Confraternities in the Sixteenth Century (Cambridge, 1989), 104–07.Google Scholar
25 Floriana, AAM, RS 6, fols 523v-25r.
26 Floriana, AAM, RS 7, fols 1237v-38r; Valletta, NA, Not. Bernardo Azzopardi, 18 January 1631; Floriana, AAM, Conti (Qrendi) 17A, no. 18, 49.
27 Valletta, NA, Not. Tommaso Magri, 3 / 924, fols 59V-61V.
28 Mdina, Parish Archives, Liber Defunctorum 3, pp. 570–71 [hereafter: PA and Lib. Def.].
29 Mqabba, PA, Lib. Def. 4, p. 35.
30 Tarxien, PA, Lib. Def. 5, 10 May 1790.
31 Mdina, PA, Lib. Def. 3, p. 483.
32 Valletta, NA, Not. Tommaso Magri, 2 / 924, fols 75r-v; 19 May 1725.
33 B’Kara, PA, Lib. Def. 5, fol. 110v.
34 Siggiewi, PA, Lib. Def. 4 (10 July 1769, Anna Pace).
35 Valletta, NA, Not. Tommaso Magri, 6 / 924, fols 90r-92v.
36 Mdina, PA, Lib. Def. 4, fols 9v-10r.
37 Mqabba, PA, Lib. Def. 4, p. 79.
38 Tarxien, PA, Lib. Def. 5, fol. 12v.
39 Valletta, NA, Not. Gio. Francesco Farrugia, 21 / 816, fols 10r-11v.
40 Lija, PA, Lib. Def. 4, p. 126.
41 Valletta, NA, Not. Tommaso Magri, 2 / 924, fols 75r-v; 1725.
42 Mdina, PA, Lib. Def. 3, pp. 482–83.
43 Ghaxaq, PA, Lib. Def. (1747–1814), p. 128.
44 Floriana, AAM, RS 9, fols 1171 r-v.
45 Lija, PA, Lib. Def. 4, p. 128.
46 Catechism of the Council of Trent, 259.
47 Luqa, PA, Lib. Def. 3, fol. 120r; 27 May 1772.
48 Mdina, AIM, Reverenda Fabbrica (Incartamenti, 1783–1797), 32, fol. 5r.
49 See, for instance, Lija, PA, Lib. Def. 4, p. 6.
50 For the votive mass of the Five Wounds, see Duffy, Stripping of the Altars, 243–44.
51 Chiffoleau, Jacques, ‘Sur l’usage obsessionnel de la Messe pour les morts à la fin du Moyen Âge’, in Faire croire: Modalités de la diffusion et de la réception des messages religieux du XIIe au XVe Siècle, Collection de l’École française de Rome 51 (1981), 235–46.Google Scholar
52 Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fol. 4801:.
53 Ciappara, Frans, ‘Una Messa in Perpetuum: Perpetual Mass Bequests in Traditional Malta, 1750–1797’, CathHR 91 (2005), 278–99.Google Scholar
54 Strocchia, S. T., Death and Ritual in Renaissance Florence (London, 1992), 208.Google Scholar
55 Floriana, AAM, RS 6, fol. 530v.
56 Burgess, Clive, ‘A Service for the Dead: The Form and Function of the Anniversary in Late Medieval Bristol’, Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society 105 (1987), 183–211 Google Scholar; see also, in this volume, idem, ‘“An Afterlife in Memory”: Commemoration and its Effects in a Late Medieval Parish’, 196–217.Google Scholar
57 Valletta, NA, Not. Gio. Francesco Farrugia, 9/816, fols 61r-v (22 February 1738); AAM, RS 6, fol. 516r.
58 Floriana, AAM, RS 10, fols 316r-v. On St Joseph as a model of a man who died well, see Maher, Michael W., Devotion, the Society of Jesus, and the Idea of St. Joseph (Philadelphia, PA, 2000).Google Scholar
59 Floriana, AAM, RS 7, fol. 1161v.
60 Ghaxaq, PA, Lib. Def (1747–1814), fol. 39V.
61 For this belief, see Rosa, Mario, “The Italian Churches’, in Callahan, William J. and Higgs, David, eds, Church and Society in Catholic Europe of the Eighteenth Century (Cambridge, 1979), 74 Google Scholar, and Graf, Arturo, ‘Il riposo dei dannati’, in idem, Miti, leggende e superstizioni del medio evo (Milan, 1984), 151–66 Google Scholar. For St Patrick’s purgatory in Ireland, see Goff, Jacques Le, The Birth cf Purgatory (Aldershot, 1984), 193–201.Google Scholar
62 Ciappara, , ‘Intercessory Funerary Rites in Malta, 1750–1797’, 157–60.Google Scholar
63 Valletta, NLM, Archives 1723, fol. 121r.
64 For the religious significance of burial choice, see the beautiful pages in Ariés, Philippe, The Hour of Our Death, trans. Weaver, Helen (Harmondsworth, 1981), 29–92 Google Scholar; and Rogers, Nicholas, ‘Hic lacet …: The Location of Monuments in Late Medieval Parish Churches’, in Burgess, Clive and Duffy, Eamon, eds, The Parish in Late Medieval England (Donington, 2006), 261–81.Google Scholar
65 Gargur, PA, Lib. Def. 2, fol. 143r.
66 Bredero, Adriaan H., ‘Le moyen age et le purgatoire’, Revue d’histoire ecclésiastique 78 (1983), 429–52, at 448–49 Google Scholar; Geary, Patrick J., Living with the Dead in the Middle Ages (Ithaca, NY, and London, 1994), 95 Google Scholar; McLaughlin, M., Consorting with Saints: Prayer for the Dead in Early Medieval France (Ithaca, NY, and London, 1994), 230–33.Google Scholar
67 Calculated from data in Cospicua, PA Lib. Def. 4–8, and Vittoriosa, PA, Liber Mortuorum 4–5.
68 B’Kara, PA, Lib. Def. 5, fols 85r, 116r.
69 Mqabba, PA, Lib. Def. 3, p. 151.
70 Floriana, AAM, RS 7, fols 1271r-v.
71 This is how the parish priest of Ghaxaq described the death of one of his parishioners in Spain in 1795, ‘Habimus notionem mortis in Hispania Gratio Schembri’: Ghaxaq, Lib. Def. (1747–1814), fol. 37V.
72 See, for instance, Cospicua, PA, Lib. Def. 7, fol. 4r.
73 ‘Canon Law of Burial’, New Catholic Encyclopedia (New York, 1967), 2: 896.Google Scholar
74 Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fols 35r-v.
75 Calculated from data in Floriana, AAM, RS 6–12.
76 Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fol. 8v.
77 For the marble image in the collegiate church at Rabat (Gozo) of Baron Giovanni Antonio Azzoppardi Castelletti as a young man in military dress, see Floriana, AAM, RS 7, fol. 1176r, and Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fol. 105V.
78 Cressy, David, Birth, Marriage and Death: Ritual, Religion and the Life-Cycle in Tudor and Stuart England (Oxford, 1999), 456–73.Google Scholar
79 Harding, Vanessa, The Dead and the Living in Paris and London, 1500–1670 (Cambridge, 2006)Google Scholar. Among her articles, see ‘Burial on the Margin: Distance and Discrimination in Early Modern London’, in Cox, M., ed., Grave Concerns: Death and Burial in England, 1700–1850 (York, 1988), 54–64 Google Scholar; ‘“And one more may be laid there”: The Location of Burials in Early Modern London’, London journal 14 (1989), 112–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
80 Coster, Will, ‘A Microcosm of Community: Burial, Space and Society in Chester, 1598 to 1633’, in Coster, W. and Spicer, A., eds, Sacred Space in Early Modern Europe (Cambridge, 2005), 124–43, at 124.Google Scholar
81 Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fols. 69r-v.
82 Floriana, AAM, RS 9, fol. 659V.
83 Our Lady of Sorrows – Floriana, AAM, RS 8, fol. 8v; Our Lady of the Rosary – ibid. fol. 111v; Our Lady of Carmel – ibid. fol. 556V.
84 Floriana, AAM, RS 7, fol. 856r.