No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
‘Pulp Methodism’ Revisited: The Literature and Significance of Silas and Joseph Hocking
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 January 2016
Extract
Writing pseudonymously in the New Age in February 1909, Arnold Bennett, acerbic chronicler of Edwardian chapel culture, deplored the lack of proper bookshops in English provincial towns. A substantial manufacturing community, he claimed, might be served only by a stationers shop, offering ‘Tennyson in gilt. Volumes of the Temple Classics or Everyman. Hymn books, Bibles. The latest cheap Shakespeare. Of new books no example, except the brothers Hocking.’ Bennett’s lament was an unintended compliment to the ubiquity of the novels of Silas and Joseph Hocking, brothers whose literary careers spanned more than half a century, generating almost two hundred novels and innumerable serials and short stories. Silas Hocking (1850–1935), whose first book was published in 1878 and last in 1934, has been described as the most popular novelist of the late nineteenth century. By 1900 his sales already exceeded one million volumes. The career of Joseph Hocking (1860–1937) was slightly shorter, stretching from 1887 to 1936, but his output was equally impressive. The Hockings’ works have attracted interest principally among scholars of Cornish life and culture. It will be argued here, however, that they have significance for the history of late Victorian and Edwardian Nonconformity, both reflecting and reinforcing the attitudes, beliefs and prejudices of their large and appreciative readership.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2012
References
1 Bennett, Arnold, ‘The Potential Public’, in idem, Books and Persons: Being Comments on a Past Epoch, 1908–1911 (London, 1917), 101–8 Google Scholar, at 103. The article first appeared on 18 February 1909, signed ‘Jacob Tonson’.
2 ODNB, s.n. ‘Hocking, Silas Kitto (1850–1935)’, online at <http://oxforddnb.com/view/article/33912>, accessed 18 August 2009. This article seriously underestimates the output of the brothers, for which see Kent, Alan M., Pulp Methodism: The Lives and Literature of Silas, Joseph and Salome Hocking. Three Cornish Novelists (St Austell, 2002), 221–6 Google Scholar. There are brief biographical articles in John Sutherland, The Longman Companion to Victorian Fiction (Harlow, 1988), 301.
3 Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in Modern Britain: A History from the 1730s to the 1980s (London, 1989), 131 Google Scholar.
4 Indicated in endpaper advertisements in, e.g., Hocking, S. K., The Strange Adventures of Israel Pendray (London, 1899)Google Scholar. Some sources (e.g. ODNB) suggest that a single title sold a million copies, but this is not supported by the contemporary catalogues.
5 Kent, Pulp Methodism, 11–25; Thomas, Charles, ‘Methodism in Cornish Literature’, in Foot, Sarah, ed., Methodist Celebration: A Cornish Contribution (Redruth, 1988), 52–6 Google Scholar.
6 Beckerlegge, Oliver A., The United Methodist Free Churches: A Study in Freedom (London, 1957)Google Scholar, remains the only history of the UMFC.
7 Kent, Pulp Methodism, 66–8; Hocking, Silas K., My Book of Memory (London, 1923), 69–70, 78–83 Google Scholar.
8 Kent, Pulp Methodism, 72, 77–80; Hocking, Book of Memory, 163–90.
9 Kent, Pulp Methodism, 87.
10 Ibid. 99–103.
11 Ibid. 109, 170.
12 Waller, P. J., Town, City and Nation: England 1850–1914 (Oxford, 1983), 7 Google Scholar.
13 Feuchtwanger, E. J., Democracy and Empire: Britain 1865–1914 (London, 1989), 14–15 Google Scholar.
14 Waller, , Town, City and Nation, 268–9 Google Scholar; Vincent, David, Literacy and Popular Culture: England 1750–1914 (Cambridge, 1989), 4 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
15 Sutherland, J. A., Victorian Novelists and Publishers (Chicago, IL, 1976), 64 Google Scholar.
16 Davis, Philip, The Victorians (Oxford, 2002), 226 Google Scholar.
17 Ibid. 223.
18 Vincent, Literacy and Popular Culture, 211; Rose, Jonathan, The Intellectual Life of the British Working Classes (New Haven, CT, 2002), 132–6 Google Scholar.
19 Sutherland, , Longman Companion, 2 Google Scholar.
20 Munson, James, The Nonconformists: In Search of a Lost Culture (London, 1991), 10–11 Google Scholar.
21 Currie, Robert, Methodism Divided: A Study in the Sociology of Ecumenicalism (London, 1968), 133–6 Google Scholar.
22 Helmstadter, R. J., ‘The Nonconformist Conscience’, in Parsons, Gerald, ed., Religion in Victorian Britain, 4: Interpretations (Manchester, 1988), 61–95 Google Scholar, at 87.
23 Hocking, Salome, Some Old Cornish Folk (London, 1903), 175–6 Google Scholar; Kent, , Pulp Methodism, 67 Google Scholar.
24 Hocking, , Book of Memory, 71–2 Google Scholar.
25 The Magazine was renamed The Methodist Monthly in 1892; see April 1894 endpapers for an advertisement for the ‘service of song’, a sequence of songs and readings designed for an informal or midweek service.
26 Hocking, , Book of Memory, 81 Google Scholar; Kellett, E. E., As I Remember (London, 1936), 117–18 Google Scholar. On missionary biographies, see, in this volume, Benjamin Fischer, ‘A Novel Resistance: Mission Narrative as the Anti-Novel in the Evangelical Assault on British Culture’, 232–45. On children’s literature, see Nancy Cutt, Margaret, Ministering Angels: A Study of Nineteenth-Century Evangelical Writing for Children (Wormley, 1979)Google Scholar; Bratton, J. S., The Impact of Victorian Children’s Fiction (London, 1981 Google Scholar).
27 Cunningham, Valentine, Everywhere Spoken Against: Dissent in the Victorian Novel (Oxford, 1975), 56–61 Google Scholar.
28 Gregory, Benjamin, Autobiographical Recollections (London, 1903), 235, 272, 280 Google Scholar; Gregory, Benjamin, Consecrated Culture: Memorials of Benjamin Alfred Gregory (London, 1885), 17 Google Scholar.
29 B[eckerlegge], O. A.., ‘Kirsop, Joseph (1825–1911)’, in Vickers, John A., ed., A Dictionary of Methodism in Britain and Ireland (Peterborough, 2000), 194 Google Scholar. Kirsop was elected President of the UMFC Annual Assembly in 1875.
30 Kirsop, Joseph, ‘Concerning Works of Fiction’, UMFC Magazine 15 (1872), 103–12 Google Scholar, quotation at 104.
31 Hocking, Joseph, ‘Novels and Novel Writers’, Methodist Monthly, October 1894, 304–5 Google Scholar.
32 Sutherland, , Longman Companion, 301 Google Scholar.
33 Ibid.
34 Compare the descriptive passages in The Purple Robe with Joseph’s articles: ‘A Protestant Pilgrimage to Rome’, The Puritan, April 1899, 183–6; May 1899, 312–15.
35 On the portrayal of Jesuits as villains, see, in this volume, John Wolffe, ‘The Jesuit as Villain in Nineteenth-Century British Fiction’, 308–20.
36 ‘Books and Their Writers’, The Puritan, August 1899, 586; Cameron, Howard, ‘Free Church Links with Literature’, The Puritan, February 1899, 13 Google Scholar.
37 Joseph Hocking, Not One in Ten (1933), for which see Kent, Pulp Methodism, 174–5. The cover design showed the heroine watching the celebration of Methodist Union at the Royal Albert Hall.
38 Endpapers of The Quenchless Fire (1911) and The Strange Adventures of Israel Pendray (1899).
39 Methodist Monthly, April 1894, 128; June 1894, 191.
40 ‘Books I have been Reading’, The Puritan, July 1900, 588.
41 ‘Mr Silas K. Hocking: Moral Purpose in Fiction’, The Times, 16 September 1935, 14.
42 Britten, James, ‘The Scarlet Woman’, in Keating, J[oseph], ed., A Brace of Bigots (Dr Morton and Mr Hocking) (London, 1909), 7 Google Scholar. This volume is a collection of pamphlets with separate pagination, consisting mainly of articles reprinted from The Month.
43 The Times, 16 September 1935, 14.
44 Munson, , Nonconformists, 230 Google Scholar.
45 Cameron, ‘Free Church Links with Literature’, 12.