Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-29T02:05:09.606Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘An extremely dangerous book’? James Hope Moulton's Religions and Religion (1913)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Martin Wellings
Martin Wellings*
Affiliation:
Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On 4 April 1917 the British steamship SS City of Paris was torpedoed by a German submarine in the Gulf of Lions, and sank with considerable loss of life. Among the passengers was the Wesleyan Methodist scholar James Hope Moulton.’ Paying tribute to his friend and colleague,Arthur Samuel Peake recorded the ‘tragic irony’ of the death under such circumstances of an eloquent advocate of peace and of a scholar whose international reputation in New Testament studies was signalled by plaudits from Harnack, a doctorate from the University of Berlin and a longstanding academic friendship with Adolf Deissmann. Moulton, however, was more than a New Testament scholar. His presence in the Mediterranean in the spring of 1917 came about through his expertise in the history and thought of Zoroastrianism, which had taken him to India for eighteen months’ work with the Parsee community under the auspices of the Indian YMCA.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 51: Christianity and Religious Plurality , 2015 , pp. 322 - 333
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2015

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Moulton, William F., Moulton, James Hope: By his Brother (London, 1919), 193–5Google Scholar; Moulton, Harold K., ed., James Hope Moulton, 11 October 1863 – 7 April 1917 (London, 1963), 20 Google Scholar; Methodist Recorder [hereafter: MR], 12 April 1917, 4; The Times, 12 April 1917, 8.

2 Peake, A. S., ‘A Record of Professor J. H. Moulton's Work’, BJRL 4 (1917–18), 18–23.Google Scholar The Moulton MSS in the Methodist Archives and Research Centre, John Rylands Library, Manchester, include many letters from Deissmann.

3 W. F. Moulton, James Hope Moulton, 134, 139–45; Moulton, James Hope, The Treasure of the Magi (London, 1917), ix–x.Google Scholar

4 For the history of the WMMS, see Allen Birtwhistle, N., ‘Methodist Missions’, in Davies, Rupert, Raymond George, A. and Rupp, Gordon, eds, A History of the Methodist Church in Great Britain, 4 vols (London, 1965–88), 3: 1–116.Google Scholar

5 W[akefield], G. S.. and L[eary], W.., ‘Fernley-Hartley Lecture’, in Vickers, John A., ed., A Dictionary of Methodism in Great Britain and Ireland (Peterborough, 2000), 119.Google Scholar

6 Moulton, James Hope, Religions and Religion (London, 1913), vii–viii Google Scholar; Moulton, H. K., ed., Moulton, James Hope, 18.Google Scholar

7 Minutes of the Wesleyan Methodist Conference, 1902, 12–13; Birtwhistle,'Methodist Missions', 113–14.

8 Minutes of Conference, 1912, 648; Minutes of Conference, 1922, 119–20.

9 [Kendall, H. B.],‘Current Literature’, Holborn Review 120 (1913), 727 Google Scholar; Moulton, Religions and Religion, vii.

10 ODNB, s.n. ‘Moulton, James Hope (1863-1917)’.

11 Moulton, Religions and Religion, x, pays homage to the author's uncle, James Egan Moulton, a missionary in the South Seas, although without the explicit dedication of the volume coj. E. Moulton, F. W. Kellett and W. C. Tucker implied in MR, 31 July 1913,23.

12 Moulton, H. K., ed., James Hope Moulton, 24 Google Scholar; Moulton, Religions and Religion, viii. For Cowell, see ODNB, s.n. ‘Cowell, Edward Byles (1826-1903)’.

13 Moulton, Religions and Religion, viii. Several letters from Frazer survive in the Moulton MSS.

14 MR, 12 April 1917, 4, referring to Moulton as a ‘stalwart agitator’;W. F. Moulton, James Hope Moulton, 97-103; British Weekly, 17 July 1919, 363.

15 W. F. Moulton, James Hope Moulton, 75.

16 For the development of the discipline and for the chief protagonists, see Sharpe, Eric J., Comparative Religion: A History (London, 1986)Google Scholar; Kippenberg, Hans G., Discovering Religious History in the Modem Age (Princeton, NJ, 2002)Google Scholar; Wheeler-Barclay, Margaret, The Science of Religion in Britain, 1860-1915 (Charlottesville,VA, 2010).Google Scholar

17 Sharpe, Comparative Religion, 27.

18 Maddox, Randy L., ‘Wesley and the Question of Truth or Salvation through other Religions’, Wesleyan Theological Journal 27 (1992), 7–29 Google Scholar; Meadows, Philip R., ‘“Candidates for Heaven“: Wesleyan Resources for a Theology of Religions’, Wesleyan Theological Journal 35 (2000), 99–129.Google Scholar

19 Watson, Richard, Theological Institutes, 3 vols (London, 1831), 1: 33.Google Scholar

20 Burt Pope, William, A Compendium of Christian Theology, 3 vols (London, 1880), 1: 57.Google Scholar

21 Geden, Alfred S., Studies in Comparative Religion (London, 1898), 6.Google Scholar

22 Ibid. 3; Geden, Alfred S., Studies in the Religions of the East (London, 1913), 9.Google Scholar

23 Geden, Religions of the East, 9.

24 Moulton, Religions and Religion, ix.

25 World Missionary Conference Edinburgh 1910 Official Handbook (Edinburgh, 1910), 72, 106.Google Scholar Moulton was one of thirty-eight delegates appointed by the WMMS. For the conference, see Stanley, Brian, The World Missionary Conference, Edinburgh 1910, SHCM (Cambridge, 2009)Google Scholar; for Moulton and the conference, Cracknell, Kenneth, Justice, Courtesy and Love: Theologians and Missionaries encountering World Religions 1846-1914 (London, 1995), 271–82.Google Scholar

26 J. H. Moulton, ‘Into all the World: What the World Missionary Conference is doing’, MR, 23 June 1910, 5.

27 Stanley, World Missionary Conference, 205-47, esp. 246-7.

28 J. H. Moulton,‘Parseeism and Christianity’, Tlte East and the West 5 (1907), 408–18, quotation at 418.

29 Ibid. 418.

30 Moulton, Religions and Religion, 1.

31 Ibid. 5,6, 11.

32 Ibid. 7.

33 Ibid. 13, 16.

34 Ibid. 23-6.

35 Ibid. 49-53.

36 Ibid. 47; cf. Hope Moulton, James, ‘How stands the Bible: Three Lectures on Biblical Apologetics’, in idem, The Christian Religion in the Study and the Street (London, 1919), 1–60 Google Scholar, at 1, 4, attributing the phrase about ‘the infallibilities’ to Harris.

37 Moulton, Religions and Religion, 86.

38 Ibid. 87-8.

39 Ibid. 91.

40 Ibid. 123.

41 Ibid. 99-100.

42 Ibid. 98, 123.

43 Ibid. 132.

44 Ibid. 128, 131, 147-8, 154-5.

45 Ibid. 209.

46 ‘A New Plea for Missions’, Methodist Times, 21 August 1913, 3.

47 W.T. D[avison],‘Religions and Religion. Dr Moulton's Fernley Lecture’, MR, 7 August 1913, 3–4. For Davison's critique of Max Müller, see ‘Max Müller on Natural Religion’, London Quarterly Review 73 (1889–90), 73–94.Google Scholar

48 [Kendall], ‘Current Literature’, 727-9.

49 Denney, James, ‘Religions and the True Religion’, British Weekly, 21 August 1913, 501–2Google Scholar; cf. Denney's comments on Frazer: British Weekly, 4 September 1913, 548.

50 Oldham, J. H.,‘Religions and Religion’, IRM 2 (1913), 804–6.Google Scholar

51 ‘New Plea for Missions’, 3.

52 G. A. C.,‘Religions and Religion’, Irish Church Quarterly 7 (1914), 175.Google ScholarPubMed

53 Henry, Preserved Smith, ,‘Works on the History of Religion’, American Journal of Theology 18 (1914), 415–20, at 417.Google Scholar

54 Vernon, Ambrose W., ‘Religions and Religion’, Harvard Theological Review 8 (1915), 267.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Bebbington, D. W., ‘The Persecution of George Jackson: A British Fundamentalist Controversy’, in Sheils, W.J., ed., Persecution and Toleration, SCH 21 (Oxford, 1984), 421–33Google Scholar; Wellings, Martin,‘Methodist Fundamentalism before and after the First World War’, in Bebbington, David W. and Jones, David Ceri, eds, Evangelicalism & Fundamentalism in the United Kingdom during the Twentieth Century (Oxford, 2013), 76–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

56 ‘Mr Chadwick and the new Fernley Lecture’, MR, 4 September 1913, 3.

57 Armstrong Bennetts, G.,‘The Fernley Lecture of 1913’, Journal of the Wesley Bible Union [hereafter:JWBU],July 1914, 103–5.Google Scholar

58 H. C. Morton, “The Chief Corner Stone: An Attempt to lull Methodists into False Security', JWBU, October 1914, 127–34, at 133–4; Armstrong Bennetts, G.,‘What is the Present Message of the Wesleyan Methodist Conference to Mankind?’, JWBU, October 1915, 217–21, at 220Google Scholar;‘Book Notices’, JWBU, August 1916, 189.,

59 Bennetts, ‘Fernley Lecture’, 103.

60 Whaling, Frank, ‘John Wesley's Premonitions of Inter-Faith Discourse’, in Macquiban, Tim, ed., Pure, Universal Love: Reflections on the Wesleys and Inter-Faith Dialogue (Oxford, 1995), 15–31, at 17.Google Scholar

61 Geden's work ran to over nine hundred pages and retailed at 12s. 6d.; Religions and Religion sold for 3s. 6d.: Methodist Times, 24 July 1913, 1.