Previous work on microstructural characterization has shown variations in terms of defects and organization of nanostructures in the two polymorphs of calcium carbonate, calcite, and aragonite in mollusc shells. Large variations in mechanical properties are observed between these sections which have been attributed to variations in composite microstructure as well as intrinsic properties of the inorganic phases. Here we present local low-loss electron energy-loss spectroscopic (EELS) study of calcitic and aragonitic regions of abalone shell that were compared to geological (single-crystal) counterpart polymorphs to reveal intrinsic differences that could be related to organismal effects in biomineralization. In both sets of samples, local dielectric function is computed using Kramer-Kronig analysis. The electronic structures of biogenic and geological calcitic materials are not significantly different. On the other hand, electronic structure of biogenic aragonite is remarkably different from that of geological aragonite. This difference is attributed to the increased contribution from single electron excitations in biogenic aragonite as compared to that of geological aragonite. Implications of these changes are discussed in the context of macromolecular involvement in the making of the microstructures and properties in biogenic phases.