Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dsjbd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T20:53:32.577Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Philosophy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 September 2018

Extract

Three recent volumes indicate a growing appreciation of the significance and complexity of Plato's account of mousikē in the Laws. Anastasia-Erasmia Peponi's edited work, Performance and Culture in Plato's Laws, collects fifteen diverse chapters by prominent scholars in Greek literature, philosophy, and culture to produce an immensely rewarding and original range of perspectives on Plato's treatment of performance and poetics in the Laws. As Peponi notes in her brief introduction, the complexity of the cultural background that Plato manipulates and appropriates in the Laws, as well as the intricacy of the Platonic appropriation itself, combine to present a very real challenge to any scholar seeking to understand them. In addition, it is hard to see that any robust treatment of the Laws’ political theory can avoid getting to grips with the fundamental connections between politics and performance established within the dialogue. Any reader with an interest in either Plato's political philosophy or his poetics will be well rewarded by time spent with this volume. The chapters are divided into four sections, which focus in turn on issues of cultural identity (‘Geopolitics of Performance’), the role of the choruses in Magnesia (‘Conceptualising Chorality’), the Laws’ treatment of genre (‘Redefining Genre’), and the later reception of the Laws’ poetics (‘Poetry and Music in the Afterlife of the Laws’). In the second of the volume's two chapters on cultural identity, Ian Rutherford considers the Laws’ representation of Egypt as a culture that successfully resists political and moral decline via a commitment to stability in mousikē. Setting Plato's account against the external evidence, Rutherford suggests that the Laws offers a partial fiction of stable Egyptian mousikē, useful not least for the implications of its possible critical connection to Dorian culture. In the last of five chapters on the Laws’ interest in the civic apparatus of choral performance, Peponi demonstrates the singularity of choral performance in the work. Whereas the Laws treats most types of performance as producing pleasure in the spectator, in the case of choruses, the emphasis is on the pleasure and experience of the performers. Peponi argues that this shift in focus represents a Platonic attempt to ‘de-aestheticize’ the chorus. In this way, Plato seeks to rehabilitate mousikē by divesting it of the psychological and aesthetic flaws identified in the Republic’s extended critique. However, as Peponi notes in conclusion, the Laws is not altogether comfortable with this sort of performative pleasure. In the first of five chapters on genre, Andrea Nightingale discusses the Laws’ manipulation of generic diversity in service of the unified truth represented by the law code at its heart. Nightingale presents a fascinating and original analysis of the law code as a written text rather different in character from that criticized in the Phaedrus as a pharmakon that destroys our memory of truth. Rather, it serves to encourage the internalization of truths by obliterating the citizens’ memories of previous unwanted cultural norms. In the volume's final chapter, Andrew Barker turns to Aristoxenus for help in making sense of Plato's suggestion that music can be assessed as ‘correct’ or ‘incorrect’, or as ‘good’ or ‘bad’. Contrasting the Platonic focus on mimesis and ethical correctness with Aristoxenus’ assessment of music ‘by the standard of its own intrinsic values’ (413), Barker suggests that, of the two treatments, Plato's is the furthest removed from general Greek opinion. These varied and illuminating chapters are representative of the scope and quality of the volume, which not only serves to open up new directions for research on the Laws but also makes plain that the Laws is at least as important as the Republic for a thorough understanding of Plato's views on art and culture, and their relation to politics.

Type
Subject Reviews
Copyright
Copyright © The Classical Association 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Performance and Culture in Plato's Laws. Edited by Peponi, Anastasia-Erasmia. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2013. Pp. xi + 460. 14 illustrations. Hardback £92, ISBN: 978-1-107-01687-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Performing Citizenship in Plato's Laws. By Prauscello, Lucia. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2014. Pp. ix + 272. Hardback £62, ISBN: 978-1-107-07288-6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 The City and the Stage. Performance, Genre, and Gender in Plato's Laws. By Folch, Marcus. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. xii + 386. Hardback £56, ISBN: 978-0-19-026617-2Google Scholar.

4 Divine Law and Political Philosophy in Plato's Laws. By Lutz, Mark J.. DeKalb, IL, Northern Illinois University Press, 2012. Pp. ix + 200. Hardback £26.50, ISBN: 978-0-87580-445-3; paperback £19.20, ISBN: 978-0-87580-717-1Google Scholar.

5 Plato, Politics and a Practical Utopia. Social Constructivism and Civic Planning in the ‘Laws’. By Moore, Kenneth Royce. London and New York, Continuum, 2012. Pp. x + 133. Hardback £90, ISBN: 978-1-4411-5317-3; paperback £28.99, ISBN: 978-1-4725-0580-4Google Scholar.

6 Roman Reflections. Studies in Latin Philosophy. Edited by Williams, Gareth D. and Volk, Katherina. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2016. Pp. x + 306. Hardback £56, ISBN: 978-0-19-999976-7Google Scholar.

7 All From One. A Guide to Proclus. Edited by d'Hoine, Pieter and Martijn, Marije. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2017. Pp. xvi + 418. Hardback £70, ISBN: 978-0-19-964033-1Google Scholar.

8 Olympiodorus. On Plato First Alcibiades 1–9. Translated by Griffin, Michael. London and New York, Bloomsbury Academic, 2016. Pp. viii+231. Hardback £90, ISBN: 978-1-4725-8830-2; paperback £28.99, ISBN: 978-1-4742-9564-2Google Scholar.

9 Priscian. Answers to King Khosroes of Persia. Translated by Huby, Pamela, Ebbesen, Sten, Langslow, David, Russell, Donald, Steel, Carlos, and Wilson, Malcolm. London and New York, Bloomsbury, 2016. Pp. vii + 162. Hardback £90, ISBN: 978-1-4725-8413-7; paperback £28.99, ISBN: 978-1-3500-6058-6Google Scholar.