Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Notes on contributors
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction: the human condition is structurally unequal
- Part I International anti-poverty policy: the problems of the Washington Consensus
- Part II Anti-poverty policies in rich countries
- Part III Anti-poverty policies in poor countries
- Part IV Future anti-poverty policies: national and international
- Appendix A Manifesto: international action to defeat poverty
- Appendix B Index of material and social deprivation: national (UK) and cross-national
- Index
eleven - Round pegs and square holes: mismatches between poverty and housing policy in urban India
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 January 2022
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Notes on contributors
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction: the human condition is structurally unequal
- Part I International anti-poverty policy: the problems of the Washington Consensus
- Part II Anti-poverty policies in rich countries
- Part III Anti-poverty policies in poor countries
- Part IV Future anti-poverty policies: national and international
- Appendix A Manifesto: international action to defeat poverty
- Appendix B Index of material and social deprivation: national (UK) and cross-national
- Index
Summary
Introduction
There is growing acknowledgement that poverty, especially in urban areas of poorer countries, is much more than just income poverty captured through poverty lines. There is increasing consensus that poverty analyses should also take into account vulnerability, deprivation and wellbeing (Moser, 1995). These features of urban poverty are a set of relationships and a process, rather than a state (Rakodi, 1995).
Several manifestations of poverty arise from this wider definition, one of the most visible ones being the appalling housing conditions of the urban poor in low-income countries. It is estimated that:
at least 600 million urban dwellers in Africa, Asia and Latin America live in ‘life- and health-threatening’ homes and neighbourhoods because of the very poor housing and living conditions and the lack of adequate provision for safe sufficient water supplies and provision for sanitation, drainage, the removal of garbage, and health care. (UNCHS, 1996b, p 114)
More recently, the State of the worlds cities 2001 report notes that:
worldwide, 18 percent of all urban housing units (some 125 million units) are non-permanent structures, and 25 percent (175 million) units do not conform to building regulations. Most deficient housing units are found in the cities of developing countries, with more than half of all less-than-adequate housing units located in the Asia and Pacific region. (UNCHS, 2001b, p 30)
Official statistics would lead us to believe that 92% of the urban population in developing countries have access to water, and 80% to sanitation. However, independent analyses (for example, UNCHS, 2001a) provide damning condemnation of the reliability of these figures. Moreover, it also casts grave doubt over the appropriateness of the definitions of what is ‘safe’ and ‘adequate’ (UNCHS, 2001a, pp 122-6).
Housing is both a cause and an outcome of poverty, as it comprises differential access to resources and control over them. It is also an important component of urban social policy, since it intersects with a number of social concerns, such as livelihoods, health, gender, age, identity and citizenship.
Therefore, if deprivation underlies or extends to income poverty, what strategies should policy makers and planners adopt in addressing housing poverty? A large part of the problem concerns either a lack of understanding of the nature of the problem or an unwillingness to deal with the complexities of the living reality of the poor.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- World PovertyNew Policies to Defeat an Old Enemy, pp. 271 - 296Publisher: Bristol University PressPrint publication year: 2002
- 1
- Cited by