Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: The regimes and their dictators: perspectives of comparison
- 1 Stalin and his Stalinism: power and authority in the Soviet Union, 1930–53
- 2 Bureaucracy and the Stalinist state
- 3 Cumulative radicalisation and progressive self-destruction as structural determinants of the Nazi dictatorship
- 4 ‘Working towards the Führer’: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship
- 5 Stalin in the mirror of the other
- 6 The contradictions of continuous revolution
- 7 From Blitzkrieg to total war: controversial links between image and reality
- 8 Stalin, the Red Army, and the ‘Great Patriotic War’
- 9 The economics of war in the Soviet Union during World War II
- 10 From ‘Great Fatherland War’ to the Second World War: new perspectives and future prospects
- 11 German exceptionalism and the origins of Nazism: the career of a concept
- 12 Stalinism and the politics of post-Soviet history
- 13 Work, gender and everyday life: reflections on continuity, normality and agency in twentieth-century Germany
- Afterthoughts
- Index
3 - Cumulative radicalisation and progressive self-destruction as structural determinants of the Nazi dictatorship
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: The regimes and their dictators: perspectives of comparison
- 1 Stalin and his Stalinism: power and authority in the Soviet Union, 1930–53
- 2 Bureaucracy and the Stalinist state
- 3 Cumulative radicalisation and progressive self-destruction as structural determinants of the Nazi dictatorship
- 4 ‘Working towards the Führer’: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship
- 5 Stalin in the mirror of the other
- 6 The contradictions of continuous revolution
- 7 From Blitzkrieg to total war: controversial links between image and reality
- 8 Stalin, the Red Army, and the ‘Great Patriotic War’
- 9 The economics of war in the Soviet Union during World War II
- 10 From ‘Great Fatherland War’ to the Second World War: new perspectives and future prospects
- 11 German exceptionalism and the origins of Nazism: the career of a concept
- 12 Stalinism and the politics of post-Soviet history
- 13 Work, gender and everyday life: reflections on continuity, normality and agency in twentieth-century Germany
- Afterthoughts
- Index
Summary
The National Socialist regime is in many respects a peculiar phenomenon which does not fit theories of comparative government. There have been numerous attempts to arrive at a consistent description of the Nazi state, among them Franz Neumann's model of the ‘Behemoth’ state, alluding to Thomas Hobbes, and Ernst Fraenkel's theory of the ‘dual state’, distinguishing between a normative and an arbitrary sector of state power. Both depicted only the early stages of Nazi dictatorship, while the diversity of explanations based on the concept of totalitarianism, including the assumption that Nazism was essentially ‘Hitlerism’, as Hans Buchheim claimed, accentuated the personal aspects of Hitler's rule. All these patterns of explanation tend to omit the point that the Nazi dictatorship was characterised by an inherent tendency towards self-destruction. It did not so much expand governmental prerogative through bureaucratic means as progressively undermined hitherto effective public institutions through arbitrary use of power. An accelerating fragmentation of the administrative apparatus was increasingly accompanied by the formation of new independent administrative bodies controlled by the party and promoting their own agendas. While this procedure of creating new ad hoc agencies increased the regime's short-term efficiency, it ultimately led to a dissolution of the unity and authority of the government. In some respects, Nazi expansionist policy accelerated the process of internal dissolution, because the methods of rule in the occupied territories were subsequently transferred to the Reich itself and contributed to the progressive destruction of public administration, which became more and more controlled by party functionaries.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Stalinism and NazismDictatorships in Comparison, pp. 75 - 87Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1997
- 14
- Cited by