Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: The regimes and their dictators: perspectives of comparison
- 1 Stalin and his Stalinism: power and authority in the Soviet Union, 1930–53
- 2 Bureaucracy and the Stalinist state
- 3 Cumulative radicalisation and progressive self-destruction as structural determinants of the Nazi dictatorship
- 4 ‘Working towards the Führer’: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship
- 5 Stalin in the mirror of the other
- 6 The contradictions of continuous revolution
- 7 From Blitzkrieg to total war: controversial links between image and reality
- 8 Stalin, the Red Army, and the ‘Great Patriotic War’
- 9 The economics of war in the Soviet Union during World War II
- 10 From ‘Great Fatherland War’ to the Second World War: new perspectives and future prospects
- 11 German exceptionalism and the origins of Nazism: the career of a concept
- 12 Stalinism and the politics of post-Soviet history
- 13 Work, gender and everyday life: reflections on continuity, normality and agency in twentieth-century Germany
- Afterthoughts
- Index
Afterthoughts
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: The regimes and their dictators: perspectives of comparison
- 1 Stalin and his Stalinism: power and authority in the Soviet Union, 1930–53
- 2 Bureaucracy and the Stalinist state
- 3 Cumulative radicalisation and progressive self-destruction as structural determinants of the Nazi dictatorship
- 4 ‘Working towards the Führer’: reflections on the nature of the Hitler dictatorship
- 5 Stalin in the mirror of the other
- 6 The contradictions of continuous revolution
- 7 From Blitzkrieg to total war: controversial links between image and reality
- 8 Stalin, the Red Army, and the ‘Great Patriotic War’
- 9 The economics of war in the Soviet Union during World War II
- 10 From ‘Great Fatherland War’ to the Second World War: new perspectives and future prospects
- 11 German exceptionalism and the origins of Nazism: the career of a concept
- 12 Stalinism and the politics of post-Soviet history
- 13 Work, gender and everyday life: reflections on continuity, normality and agency in twentieth-century Germany
- Afterthoughts
- Index
Summary
A volume of essays envisaged more as an experimental workshop than as a set of definitive statements cannot aim to arrive at firm conclusions. Tentative and provisional findings, together with hints at the possible future agenda for comparative research, are also necessarily a reflection of the fact that the historiographies of Germany and Russia have, until now, tended to bypass each other. It was striking that the historians of both countries attending the conference from which this volume has emerged met each other in most cases for the first time. Germanists came armed with many open questions derived in the main from applying to Russian development analogous argument from the German case. They found they had much to gain from the most recent uncovering of sources about the USSR. Experts on Russia and the Soviet Union had the opportunity to see how new, probing questions on their own areas of study could be raised and sharpened by better acquaintance with the rich literature and advanced research on German history. For it remains true that specialists in German history have, on the whole, not concerned themselves greatly with the problems of understanding the structural development of modern Russia. And, vice versa, the same applies by and large to experts on Russian history, for whom the extensive debates that characterise the historiography of modern Germany are for the most part terra incognita.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Stalinism and NazismDictatorships in Comparison, pp. 343 - 358Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1997