4 - ‘Billions and the Retrogression of Knowledge’?: Wealth, Modernity, and Ethical Citizenship in a Northern Vietnamese Trading Village
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 November 2020
Summary
Abstract
While Vietnam's Đổi mới policy, officially introduced three decades ago, had the clear-cut aim of restructuring the economic sector, its impact on morality was not as readily palpable. The standing of merchants in Vietnam has been, and continues to be, particularly ambiguous, as they were able to quickly seize the benefits of Đổi mới, albeit without embodying the state's ideas of modernity. Using Sheri Lynn Gibbings (2016) framework of ‘citizenship as ethic’, the chapter takes a close look at the traders’ performance of moral identities as a way of dealing with the paradoxical economic and political situation they find themselves in.
Keywords: modernity, wealth, ethical citizenship, moral identity, traders, northern Vietnam
Introduction
As Vietnam has signed multiple regional and superregional free trade agreements, among them ASEAN, WTO, and TPP, and is joining the ranks of countries newly classified as middle income, it is increasingly hailed as ‘Asia's next tiger’ (The Economist, 2016). Although incomes have considerably risen and money has become an important benchmark of modernity in present-day Vietnam, wealth continues to be an ambiguous and inherently moral issue. Not only how money is earned, but also how it is spent is a matter of great concern.
State media frequently peddles claims about money corrupting people’s character as well as social relations. Often, this claim targets women in particular, because they are seen as the moral pillars of the family and the nation more broadly (Pettus, 2003; Leshkowich, 2014). The thrust of such discourses is to warn of the potentially negative effects of money on people in the wider process of the individualization of society. The fear of alienation as a consequence of the accumulation of wealth made possible through the capitalist mode of production was crucial in the writings of Marx and other leftist philosophers and politicians, and its presence should thus not come as a surprise in a Socialist Republic.
During what is now called ‘high socialist time’ (from 1954 in the north, and 1975 in the south of Vietnam, until 1986), land was collectivized and only state-owned companies and cooperatives were allowed to produce and distribute goods according to the central government's directives.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Money and Moralities in Contemporary Asia , pp. 85 - 104Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2019