Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- GENERAL INTRODUCTION
- INTRODUCTION TO VOLUME
- CHRONOLOGY OF THE LIFE AND MAJOR WORKS OF ANDREW LANG
- A NOTE ON THE TEXT
- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
- 1 THE METHOD OF FOLKLORE
- 2 ANTHROPOLOGY AND FOLKLORE
- 3 FAIRY TALES
- 4 ANTHROPOLOGY, AND THE ORIGINS OF RELIGION
- ‘Anthropology and Ancient Literature’, The Academy (10 March 1883)
- ‘Fetichism and the Infinite’, Custom and Myth (1884)
- ‘Anthropology and Religion’ I, The Making of Religion, 2nd edition (1900)
- ‘On Religion’, from The Making of Religion, 2nd edition (1900)
- ‘Science and Superstition’, Magic and Religion (1901)
- ‘First-Fruits and Taboos’, Magic and Religion (1901)
- ‘Australian Problems’, Anthropological Essays Presented to Edward Burnett Tylor in Honour of his 75th Birthday (1907)
- 5 ANTHROPOLOGY AND PSYCHICAL RESEARCH
- 6 PSYCHICAL RESEARCH
- APPENDIX I: NAMES FREQUENTLY CITED BY LANG
- APPENDIX II: ETHINIC GROUPS CITED BY LANG
- EXPLANATORY NOTES
- Index
‘On Religion’, from The Making of Religion, 2nd edition (1900)
from 4 - ANTHROPOLOGY, AND THE ORIGINS OF RELIGION
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 October 2017
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- GENERAL INTRODUCTION
- INTRODUCTION TO VOLUME
- CHRONOLOGY OF THE LIFE AND MAJOR WORKS OF ANDREW LANG
- A NOTE ON THE TEXT
- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
- 1 THE METHOD OF FOLKLORE
- 2 ANTHROPOLOGY AND FOLKLORE
- 3 FAIRY TALES
- 4 ANTHROPOLOGY, AND THE ORIGINS OF RELIGION
- ‘Anthropology and Ancient Literature’, The Academy (10 March 1883)
- ‘Fetichism and the Infinite’, Custom and Myth (1884)
- ‘Anthropology and Religion’ I, The Making of Religion, 2nd edition (1900)
- ‘On Religion’, from The Making of Religion, 2nd edition (1900)
- ‘Science and Superstition’, Magic and Religion (1901)
- ‘First-Fruits and Taboos’, Magic and Religion (1901)
- ‘Australian Problems’, Anthropological Essays Presented to Edward Burnett Tylor in Honour of his 75th Birthday (1907)
- 5 ANTHROPOLOGY AND PSYCHICAL RESEARCH
- 6 PSYCHICAL RESEARCH
- APPENDIX I: NAMES FREQUENTLY CITED BY LANG
- APPENDIX II: ETHINIC GROUPS CITED BY LANG
- EXPLANATORY NOTES
- Index
Summary
[From ‘Evolution of the Idea of God’]
To the anthropological philosopher ‘a plain man’ would naturally put the question: ‘Having got your idea of spirit or soul – your theory of Animism – out of the idea of ghosts, and having got your idea of ghosts out of dreams and visions, how do you get at the Idea of God?’ Now by ‘God’ the proverbial ‘plain man’ of controversy means a primal eternal Being, author of all things, the father and friend of man, the invisible, omniscient guardian of morality.
The usual though not invariable reply of the anthropologist might be given in the words of Mr. Im Thurn, author of a most interesting work on the Indians of British Guiana:
‘From the notion of ghosts,’ says Mr. Im Thurn, ‘a belief has arisen, but very gradually, in higher spirits, and eventually in a Highest Spirit and, keeping pace with the growth of these beliefs, a habit of reverence for, and worship of spirits…. The Indians of Guiana know no God.’
As another example of Mr. Im Thurn's hypothesis that God is a late development from the idea of spirit may be cited Mr. Payne's learned ‘History of the New World,’ a work of much research:
‘The lowest savages not only have no gods, but do not even recognise those lower beings usually called spirits, the conception of which has invariably preceded that of gods in the human mind.’
Mr. Payne here differs, toto caelo, from Mr. Tylor, who finds no sufficient proof for wholly non-religious savages, and from Roskoff, who has disposed of the arguments of Sir John Lubbock. Mr. Payne, then, for ethnological purposes, defines a god as ‘a benevolent spirit, permanently embodied in some tangible object, usually an image, and to whom food, drink,’ and so on, ‘are regularly offered for the purpose of securing assistance in the affairs of life.’
On this theory ‘the lowest savages’ are devoid of the idea of god or of spirit. Later they develop the idea of spirit, and when they have secured the spirit, as it were, in a tangible object, and kept it on board wages, then the spirit has attained to the dignity and the savage to the conception of a god.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Edinburgh Critical Edition of the Selected Writings of Andrew LangAnthropology, Fairy Tale, Folklore, The Origins of Religion, Psychical Research, pp. 189 - 206Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2015