Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- List of Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 Aesthetics of Crisis: Art Cinema and Neoliberalism
- 2 Beyond Neoliberalism? Gift Economies in the Films of the Dardenne Brothers
- 3 The Resurgence of Modernism and its Critique of Liberalism in the Cinema of Crisis
- 4 Post-Fordism in Active Life, Industrial Revolution and The Nothing Factory
- 5 Re-evaluating Crisis Politics in the Work of Aku Louhimies
- 6 Crisis of Cinema/Cinema of Crisis: The Car Crash and the Berlin School
- 7 Representing and Escaping the Crises of Neoliberalism: Veiko Õunpuu’s Films and Methods
- 8 The Future is Past, the Present Cannot be Fixed: Ken Loach and the Crisis
- 9 It Could Happen to You: Empathy and Empowerment in Iberian Austerity Cinema
- 10 The Double Form of Neoliberal Subjugation: Crisis on the Eastern European Screen
- 11 Housing Problems: Britain’s Housing Crisis and Documentary
- 12 Miserable Journeys, Symbolic Rescues: Refugees and Migrants in the Cinema of Fortress Europe
- 13 Frontlines: Migrants in Hungarian Documentaries in the 2010s
- 14 Mongrel Attunement in White God
- 15 Labour and Exploitation by Displacement in Recent European Film
- 16 A Hushed Crisis: The Visual Narratives of (Eastern) Europe’s Antiziganism
- Bibliography
- Index
12 - Miserable Journeys, Symbolic Rescues: Refugees and Migrants in the Cinema of Fortress Europe
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 September 2020
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- List of Contributors
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 Aesthetics of Crisis: Art Cinema and Neoliberalism
- 2 Beyond Neoliberalism? Gift Economies in the Films of the Dardenne Brothers
- 3 The Resurgence of Modernism and its Critique of Liberalism in the Cinema of Crisis
- 4 Post-Fordism in Active Life, Industrial Revolution and The Nothing Factory
- 5 Re-evaluating Crisis Politics in the Work of Aku Louhimies
- 6 Crisis of Cinema/Cinema of Crisis: The Car Crash and the Berlin School
- 7 Representing and Escaping the Crises of Neoliberalism: Veiko Õunpuu’s Films and Methods
- 8 The Future is Past, the Present Cannot be Fixed: Ken Loach and the Crisis
- 9 It Could Happen to You: Empathy and Empowerment in Iberian Austerity Cinema
- 10 The Double Form of Neoliberal Subjugation: Crisis on the Eastern European Screen
- 11 Housing Problems: Britain’s Housing Crisis and Documentary
- 12 Miserable Journeys, Symbolic Rescues: Refugees and Migrants in the Cinema of Fortress Europe
- 13 Frontlines: Migrants in Hungarian Documentaries in the 2010s
- 14 Mongrel Attunement in White God
- 15 Labour and Exploitation by Displacement in Recent European Film
- 16 A Hushed Crisis: The Visual Narratives of (Eastern) Europe’s Antiziganism
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
A salient social and political issue in Europe in recent years has been the increasing number of people fleeing war and poverty and attempting to gain entry to the continent. During the so-called ‘refugee crisis’ of 2015–16, over a million people sought asylum in European Union countries, more than double the number for the previous year. As Prem Kumar Rajaram notes (2016: 2), a prevalent Eurocentric perspective on these events holds that ‘it is Europe that has had the “difficult year”, not migrants’. Politicians such as Viktor Orbán and David Cameron responded with dehumanising language, conflating refugees with economic migrants and ‘illegal immigrants’ to talk of ‘unknown masses’ and a ‘swarm’ threatening to engulf the continent. While newspapers and television often amplified this hysteria, the topic has since become ‘only intermittently visible in mainstream Northern European news media’, such that, in Bruce Bennett's phrase, ‘the “refugee crisis” is in part “a representational crisis”’ (2018: 15). Furthermore, a discourse of ‘crisis’ has been used strategically to reinforce the border regime that produced it. Nicholas De Genova writes of the Mediterranean ‘deathscape’:
the invocation of tragedy was cynically conscripted to supply the pretext for reinforcing and exacerbating precisely the material and practical conditions of possibility for the escalation in migrant deaths – namely the fortification of various forms of border policing that inevitably serve to channel illegalized human mobility into ever more perilous pathways and modes of passage. (De Genova 2017: 2, 7)
As both the number of ‘illegalised’ people seeking to enter Fortress Europe and the death toll in the Mediterranean have mounted, some commentators have argued for a mass resettlement programme, comparable to that undertaken for 1.3 million refugees from Indochina in the aftermath of the Vietnam War. Another response, from engaged film-makers working across Europe, has been to stage fictional, symbolic rescues of refugees and ‘clandestines’. Here I analyse films by directors Aki Kaurismäki and Emanuele Crialese in which white characters welcome new arrivals. I also consider two works which attend more closely to the experience of people trying to reach Europe, their dangerous journeys and the problems that await them: Senegalese director Moussa Touré's La Pirogue (2012) and American Italian Jonas Carpignano's feature debut Mediterranea (2015). In all four cases, the migrant character originates from sub-Saharan Africa.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Cinema of CrisisFilm and Contemporary Europe, pp. 198 - 214Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2020