Research into the relationship between the subjective perception of clinical change and the objective evidence of the same is very limited. Less is known about the relationship between clinical judgments by mental health experts and the patient's perception of symptom change, in particular across different diagnostic groups.

This study aims to determine the level of concordance between the HONOS as a tool for clinical outcome monitoring and the self-reported change in psychopathology in a total sample of psychiatric patients as well as stratified by their primary diagnosis at admission.

A consecutive sample of patients admitted to a Swiss psychiatric hospital for either alcohol use disorders, schizophrenic psychoses, mood disorders, anxiety and somatoform disorders, or personality disorders, was assessed using the Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI) at admission and at discharge. The HoNOS were rated by the responsible clinicians. Complete data of admission and discharge were available from approximately 600 cases. Reliable change index (RCI) will be calculated to determine a clinically meaningful change based on the HoNOS scores. Concordance of RCI and change in BSI scores will be explored and compared between different diagnostic groups.

According to our preliminary results from this ongoing evaluation program, we hope to provide a step towards a deeper understanding of the interrelationship between clinical judgments and the course of subjectively experienced mental health problems.

The authors have not supplied their declaration of competing interest.

Subjective perceptions of clinical change in patients with schizophrenia are often not congruent to the objective evidence of the same, especially since a lack of insight is part of the symptomatology. However, the exploration of the relationship between clinical judgments from mental health experts and the patients’ perception of symptom change is fairly understudied.

This study aimed to investigate the performance of the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) as a tool for clinical outcome monitoring in schizophrenia in concordance with the change of self-reported psychopathology assessed with the Frankfurt Complaint Questionnaire (FCQ) in patients with a schizophrenia.

A consecutive sample of patients admitted to a Swiss psychiatric hospital for schizophrenia was assessed with the FCQ at admission and discharge. The PANSS was rated by the responsible clinicians at admission and discharge. Complete data of admission and discharge were available from approximately 60 cases. Reliable change index (RCI) was calculated to determine a clinically meaningful change based on the PANSS scores. Logistic regression models were conducted to explore the link between RCI levels and the change of self-reported perceptions of psychopathology.

Our study found no relationship between the change of PANSS and FCQ from admission to discharge in a sample of patients treated for schizophrenia. Therefore, our findings provide evidence for a large discrepancy between the observed clinical severity and the subjective perception of symptoms in individuals with schizophrenia.

The authors have not supplied their declaration of competing interest.

In psychiatric practice, the assessment of change from pre- to post-treatment is a key approach for monitoring treatment effects and for the prediction of treatment outcomes. The Health of the Nation Outcome Scales (HoNOS) as a clinician-rated measure and the Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI) as a self-report measure are tools (that are) often incorporated in outcome monitoring. Their usefulness, however, has been questioned by two important issues: their psychometric properties and their lack of concordance.

The aim of the study is to evaluate the responsiveness of HoNOS and BSI as well as their interactions to predict clinical meaningful change according to the Global Clinical Impression (CGI) as quasi-gold standard for treatment outcome.

A consecutive sample of patients admitted to a Swiss psychiatric hospital for either alcohol use disorders, schizophrenic psychoses, mood disorders, anxiety and somatoform disorders, or personality disorders was assessed with Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI) at admission and discharge. The HoNOS and the CGI were rated by the responsible clinicians at admission and discharge. Ordinal logistic regressions will be conducted using the CGI categories as ordered categorical outcome. HoNOS and BSI scores as well as their interaction terms will be used as independent variables.

Complete data of admission and discharge is available from approximately 600 cases. Graphical presentations will illustrate the resulting associations.

The authors have not supplied their declaration of competing interest.